Malcolm, I started out this post intending to extract and quote all your points I thought were excessive, unnecessary and deliberately inflammatory. I soon realised it was going to take an inordinate amount of my time to do so.
While positive feedback and constructive criticism are welcome, a torrent of discontent as vehement in its tone as your post was is a little harder to accept.
From your description of the judging as a debacle I deduce the following.
Your expectations of what the day was going to be and what it actually was were two very different things.
The day was never going to be Pebble Beach. It was a club Show and Shine day. A simple event where people with a common interest gather their cars and admire a fine group of vehicles. The judging criteria were deliberately low key and the Judges were instructed to use their discretion. Additionally, the Judges were chosen as representatives of the various parties supporting the club.
For example one of the Judges was the Manager at Mingara. Getting him involved was a brilliant idea and great PR for the club. I do not know this gentleman but I doubt he would have felt like crawling over and under 50 or so cars. This is just one example of what the intent of the day was.
Granted we can do things a lot better next year, but before we try to turn the event into Auto salon we will be focusing on organisational aspects like the awards ceremony, display layout and similar. The event is one where you can shine up your daily driver and display it with pride. It is not an elite affair solely for those with a pristine example of a Skyline. This is where the judging discretion can level things out.
Further to your comment:
"Let’s face it there is no point in awarding any prizes at all unless they are awarded to the best car in their category."
The winning entries were awarded to the cars the majority of Judges felt were the best in that category. We will not be requesting any trophies be returned and even if they were they would not be re-awarded next year.
Please take a leaf out of Thorpie's book and get over it.