Dunlop Sport 2000
Dry: 4
Wet: 4
Value: 4
OEM tyres for my last car. Typical OEM tyre: quiet and reasonable in wet and dry, cold and warm. Not much of a sports tyre, though.
Silverstone Something, who cares
Dry: 4
Wet: 3
Value: 3
Silverstone make some of the crappiest tyres on the planet. Every person I know who's used them has hated them; no grip and wear quickly
Pirelli P5000 Drago
Dry: 5
Wet: 6
Value: 6
These are a good wet weather tyre. Two big centre channels and directional tread. I found myself doing Old Pac in the wet only 5-10km/hr slower than in the dry. Even though I had them for longer than the Silverstones, when I had to swap 2 out due to puncture the Pirellis still lasted longer than the Silverstones I replaced them with.
Falken Azenis RT215
Dry: 7
Wet: 4
Value: 5
Everyone knows about these tyres. Didn't last long, but I could hammer my car and the thing would just stick. In the wet you noticed the lack of tread blocks, but in the dry I was finding myself taking corners flat that I'd normally have to lift on. Shame about the tyre life.
Bridgestone Potenza RE040
Dry: 5
Wet: 5
Value: 5
OEM tyres on my current ride. Great OEM sports tyre. Progressive, and with a reasonable amount of grip even when cold. They also do OK in the wet. The only problem is they can't handle heat. The first time I took them to the track, I baked them and they didn't grip properly cold after that. I'd get a fair amount of slip until I got heat into them.
Falken Azenis RS-V04
Dry: 8
Wet: 2
Value: 4
Ignore what some people tell you, Formula R semi slicks are not daily drivable. They were noisy as hell, and only by babying them did I get 8000kms out of them. I'd average one oversteer moment per drive in the wet, and they'd pick up stones and either embed them into the rubber or flick them up onto cars behind you.
But, in the dry and in anger, a Formula R tyre redefines what you think your car can do around a bend. I had a couple of situations where I went into a corner too hot and I thought I'd slide out; on these tyres the car just did what it was told. And, on the track, they'll do it lap after lap.
Definite "second set of rims" rubber. There are better Formula R tyres out there, but not for the pittance I paid for them.
Dunlop Direzza DZ101s
Dry: 6
Wet: 8
Value: 7
Current tyres. In the dry they provide good grip (at least as good as the RE040s, if not better) and in the wet they're phenominal. I can't believe how much grip I can get, even in standing water, and even when they let go its progressive and its easy to bring them back on line.