Ive seen Carillos, Argo, Eagles, Scat and Spool rods fail - all have been due to oil starvation. Any rod will fail if it welds itself to the crank at high rpm.
Rod choice all comes down to your budget and personal preference ( and what you hear )
My engine makes 560rwhp and turns to 8000 rpm daily - it is over 12 months old and has done 126 power runs on a dyno in that time.
There are a few XR6 turbo engines making 620 - 650 rwhp with Spool rods now.
So I know they are good and there are plenty of people and trade customers using them in big power street, drag and drift cars and have been for years now.
Hope that helps.