Obviously a higher comp engine will be more responsive, never get an argument from me on that front. Price of using a stock 30 bottom end might be a reason to go this way, after all RIPS can't have it all wrong.
I would argue your friend needed a smaller turbo to make some airflow down low to compensate for the lower compression. Going to a larger turbo (albeit larger turbine in your example) surely would have made it doggier down low.