You're going to get mixed answers. Insurance is all dependent on where you live, your age and driving history. (And obviously the car you drive and what you paid for it).
To me that that price sounds somewhat reasonable, I doubt you'll get a better price anywhere else. From the sounds of it, you're probably 24-25 in a pretty cushy suburb? Just Car wanted $1, 700 from me with a much higher excess and I'm 22. However my car is only a GTS-T.