I can't say I've actually owned both of these cars, so don't know how much help I can be, but I have driven both... To me it would be more of a question of a difference in driving style and your preferences. If you've already owned a Supra, Soarer and gtt then you'll obviously be fairly used to a powerful and torquey (spelling?) engine. I found for me that the rotary just didn't 'feel' right in the way it drove to me. My main suggestion would be to try to go and test drive each one and see what you think...