Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

Hi all..

Just rebuild my engine and have been running it for a week and today it died!!

It seems that the crank angle sensor completely seized up and snapped the end of the exhuast cam off!!

Has anybody ever had this happen??

Also, the 4 bolts that hold the exhuast cam gear on were scrapping against the crank angle sensor and there are metle shavings everywhere!!

Anybody shed some light on this????

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/102397-this-has-never-happened-before/
Share on other sites

I actually installed it and did it to the book...

Why is it touching the bolts???

I left the timing belt cover off, I think the sensor bolts onto this after the cover is put on so in theory, if I don't put the cover on, then, the sensor would bolt up that much closer to the cam gear, therefore, touching the bolts??

Does that sound possible???

It seems that the crank angle sensor completely seized up and snapped the end of the exhuast cam off!!

This is very unlikely.....almost certainly the camshaft was cracked, possibly at installation. Under load with the engine running the crack progressed until the camshaft failed completely. The metal shavings, etc are probably from when the cam pulley bolts contacted the back of the CAS or the CAS mount at failure - the engine would have continued to turn for a short time after the ex cam failed.

I've seen a few failures of cams in RB engines as a result of incorrect installation - when doing up the cam cap bolts it's quite easy to put a bending load on the camshaft, and cast iron doesn't take kindly to that.

Anyway, that's my theory, I could tell for certain by examining the camshaft.

One other thing - you need to hope that valves didn't contact pistons.

Thanks for all your comments mate, I will take them on board....

The actualy cam is in one piece, it's just the very tip of it that the crank angle sensor slips onto that snapped off.. that piece is still in the shaft of the sensor when I took it off....

Does that clarify things anymore...

The actualy cam is in one piece, it's just the very tip of it that the crank angle sensor slips onto that snapped off.. that piece is still in the shaft of the sensor when I took it off.... 

Take some pictures if you can, I'm intrigued by how much of the cam has broken off.

Yeah, I will try and take some pics of it.... keep an eye on this thread.. I'll post them here tomorrow..

I will be sure to put spacers in when I put it back together.. an expensive lesson!!

If I were to put aftermarket cams in, what would you all recommend and can I run cams with more lift and longer duration with the standard ecu??

I'm guessing that I can but I just won't get the power gains until I get the ecu changed....

Thanks all..

damn, I did so well with the rebuild too... Did it all and I stuff up something like this... feel like a damn idoit!! Ahh well, you live and learn I guess.....

If anybody has an exhuast cam for the rb25det, let me know..

I have been told that the rb20det is exactly the sam cam so I can use that if I have to......

The half-moon is only an aid to getting the angular relationship between the cam and CAS correct. The CAS keeps turning because of intermeshing of the teeth set on the CAS and the cam.

Without the half-moon, you need to visualise where they would line up. If you get it wrong, the engine won't run (but no damage is caused).

I would love to be able ti use the cam still but it didn't just snap off the half moon part of it, it snapped the whole spline off of the cam down to the end!!!

The whole piece was jammed into the CAS!! Nothing left for the CAS to grab onto caus it got snapped off down to the base!!

I just brought another cam and fitted it last night... Runs like a dream and yes, I've now put some washers in place of the timing belt cover so the CAS doesn't touch the cam geard bolts....

A valuable lesson learnt but if this is the only mistake I've made with the rebuild, then I'm as happy as a pig in....... ;-)

  • 3 weeks later...

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • Ok, so first round of maintenance done. I didn't get much history with the car but I know it was well looked after. That isn't enough for me though, so ...  I had to do the oil filter housing gasket. It was leaking a lot, and also as part of that I did the anti-return valve and the VANOS oil line (from HEL).  But, then I got hit with the while-ya-in-there's. Did both accessory and A/C belts, tensioners and pulley. The accessory belt that came off had a huge hole in it, like somebody hung it up with a nail. The pulley and tensioners seem ok, so I'll keep those just in case. I did water pump and pump pulley. The water pump had a small bit of play so timing was good.  I also did fan clutch. I don't know how to test the old one but between the water pump and the fan clutch the car is running a little bit cooler (not much ~2 - 3 degrees maybe) so good result. Unfortunately the thermostat and housing didn't turn up in time so I'll shelve those. I have no concerns at all on the current ones.  Then I spent what seemed like 40 days and 40 nights bleeding the air from the cooling system. She also got new air filter, fuel filter and did a Mobil 1 change with oil filter. Hilariously, not an hour after telling my wife how proud I was of myself to be going slowly and meticulously and making sure everything was torqued and nothing missing I went and started it without the oil filter in. The car complained immediately of no pressure and after only a few seconds I turned it off and discovered a shit tonne of oil on the driveway. Sigh. I've driven it since and thankfully doesn't seem to be any problems. AND THEN during the test drive a ratchet extension fell into the battery area in the boot and JAMMED right next to the positive terminal and the car body. Like, just touching it made sparks and it was jammed in there. So, almost killed the engine and then almost burned the car to a crisp. Good start. This was the rails under the splash guards. So stoked, she's straight as and super clean. No rust anywhere. There was a heap of caked dirt that I removed but otherwise looked great. All 4 jacking points are perfect.   Next I want to service the gearbox. Sometimes it's a little reluctant to shift up and I'm hoping a fluid change will sort it. I also have 4 new rear subframe bushes. They're as big as a toddler. I'm renting a tool to help put them in. I can't wait for this because its a bit crashy back there at the moment.  
    • Remember when those donkeys kept using freedom units and smashed that satellite to bits on the moon? NASA has their brain switched on and uses the metric system.
    • Don't use "gasless MIG" (FCAW) you want to use proper MIG. FCAW burns a few hundred degrees hotter than MIG will for mild steel. It is a true ball ache for sheet metal. New MIG / TIG machines even have features like "Spot Weld" as well as "Automatic" settings. Plenty of people say for DIY home hobby, the auto machines are pretty good for 95% of welding. I personally, I'm a sucker for punishment and wanting to dial it in, and be able to adjust the machine. Mainly because I used to MIG weld for a living, and being able to tweak and tune things ever so slightly was my preference. Hence when I bought my ACDC TIG, it has all the adjustments for everything and no "easy" mode. Ha ha I have stick, MIG, "gaslessMIG" and ACDC TIG at home. Out of them, if you're doing mild steel sheet metal repair, and want to do mild steel exhausts, go MIG. If you're thinking you'll want to get into doing some aluminium stuff, or stainless steel, get an ACDC TIG with HF start. If you can, get one with a foot pedal too. My MIG machine is a UniMIG, and my Stick/TIG is CigWeld. If I were buying another machine, I'd buy another CIGWeld. Lots of people having issues with UniMIG, and them not wanting to cover warranty. Everything has to go back to UNIMig themselves. CIGWeld, I've had to use their warranty on my machine for a gas leak, they have repair centres everywhere, (contracted authorised repair centres). First repair place I used were hopeless, but the second place were amazing. Warranty process itself super easy, and second repair place was telling me CigWeld actually cover in their warranty, upto an hour of techs time to help you with your machine, and going through the settings and helping teach you the machine. UniMIG keep trying to get out of replacing motherboards on 12 month old machines.   TLDR, mild steel sheet welding, buy a MIG. my vote is CigWeld for brand.
    • I guess that's what happens when someone can't convert metric to freedom units to machine something. 😛
    • I've watched some vids and the technique seems to be to butt the sheets up to one another and use MIG to spot weld and slowly fill in the spots until its eventually all sealed. No runs as you would normally do, as there's too much heat generated that way. Yeah my stick welds are terrible these days because its been so long since i've done any of it. I expect to be spending many hours practicing
×
×
  • Create New...