Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

whats your opinions people.

a turbo exhuast housing bag or a metal cover over the top?

whats the good and bad points of each?

hks turbo cover is like $180, the turbo bags im unsure.

ive been told the turbo bags make the turbo have more thermal stress and wear out quicker?

dont wanna wreck my brand new $3400 turbo anytime soon :confused:

cheers

Brad

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/107593-turbo-bag-or-heat-shield/
Share on other sites

  • Replies 49
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

I would say the turbobag would be better because it seals off the housing's heat better than a sheild can do.

Although personally I would take off the turbine housing and get it ceramically coated too, as an internal coating helps keeps the heat out of the metal in the first place. (I would also do the manifold while you're at it!!)

Edited by Busky2k

Heavily vented bonnet works best for getting rid of heat :)

If its plastic surround componants you want to save then the turbo bag is the best.

If its the turbo you want to save before but still want to help keep the heat near the turbo then the heat sheild is the way.

no worries guys, cheers for the comments.

anyone know shops who are selling the hks metal cover? or even some plain ones for a more reasonable price? or i might just make one up myself :(

i'd like some vents for the pod and turbo area but the cops wont like it at all, and the rain is an issue :) plus stagea bonnet r not easy to find second hand if i gotta get it back to stock, and i'd prefer the sleeper look.

yeah im not sure about the bag but i think the chrome cover is just for looks...but i have to say the HKS cover would look damn hotl... specialy on the T04Z

i took the cheap option and got a chrome cover from autobahn that was meant for an air filter and bolted it into place.....but then again i have the dump wraped and a vented carbon bonnet for my HKS T04S..my cover gets damn hot after a flog

cheers

francisco

ok ive been chasing prices on the metal heat sheilds and local hks distributor in WA wants $280 for one thats suits a hks T51 turbo and needs modifying, hahah good value :)

over east rang bd4s and they want $270 as well, for a pissy piece of metal and a bracket.

gcg want $220 for a plain non branded one

perfect run emailed and reckons hks japan dont even have them anymore :)

nengun is like $180 i think, just i need it within the next 2 weeks and nengun take forever.

might have to make one up until i get the hks one.

are they ally or stainless steel?

how far off the actual housing do they sit? 10mm? 20mm? or what?

cheers

Brad

i have heard rumors of heat bags trapping too much heat in and causing the turbine seal to leak prematurley. we run heat bags on some of our engines at work which range from 6ltr inline 6 single turbo to 69ltr V16 quad turbo's, but these are desiel hahaha.

from my experiance on desiels the non bagged ones last longer.

just some input, hope i dont confuse you.

cheers,

ryan

Putting a Bag on it will heat cycle it ALOT more as you're containing the heat. A heat shield would be the way to go as it let's the heat dissapate, though wouldn't decrease overall underbonnet temps as much as a bag.

Any sort of steel will do. SS would be best for looks - just don't go too thick so that it can loose the heat quickly otherwise you'll end up with heat storage in the shield..

Just get a sheet of 2mm SS, make a bracket and bend the SS to suit. $180 is crazy pricing - let alone more..

i got a turbo bag on mine and i rekon it shits on a heat shield

there was a test in hpi magazine not long ago also stating this, and u can also get a dump pipe bag which they said had great results,

the bag traps alot more heat in and i personally cant see it doing any damage, ive had mine along with alot of mates have theres for 1000's of kms and nothin wrong at all

plus with the heat shield my air con and surrounding plastics were melting

ben...

Putting a Bag on it will heat cycle it ALOT more as you're containing the heat. A heat shield would be the way to go as it let's the heat dissapate, though wouldn't decrease overall underbonnet temps as much as a bag.

I reckon the bag is better because the turbo will cool down slower than an a fully exposed one.. therefore the cooling stress on the metal is less. Although one could argue that a 'bagged' turbo will heat up faster...

Its a catch 22. In the one hand i like the bags as they are far more effeicient at insulating the emgine bay from the heat.

But, my main concern with this is it traps the heat around the cartridge. Even if the thing is water cooled i dont like the idea of holding all that heat around the cartridge.

So i thin the best solution is a stainless shield over the exhaust housing (combined with HPC coating the exhaust housing). Racepace in melbourne have about the best type i have seen as the cover actaully saddles the cartridge and acts as a kind of partition...its the way to go

u can raise the back of the bonnet up a bit if u want.

take off bonnet and put some washers on em to act like spacers and raise is 5-10mm doesnt look too different and dramatically realeses heat from the RB26 lol. i would put a shield around ur ABS actuators and a turbo bag. and shield ur exhast.

rain wont really do anything to ur turbo or exhast.. when engines r washed down they spray water straight onto everything.. a little bit of rain will do nothing.

my old GTiR has vents stock as well as that sexy bonnet scoop. and rain got in.. did nothing.

u can raise the back of the bonnet up a bit if u want.

take off bonnet and put some washers on em to act like spacers and raise is 5-10mm doesnt look too different and dramatically realeses heat from the RB26 lol. i would put a shield around ur ABS actuators and a turbo bag. and shield ur exhast.

rain wont really do anything to ur turbo or exhast.. when engines r washed down they spray water straight onto everything.. a little bit of rain will do nothing.

my old GTiR has vents stock as well as that sexy bonnet scoop. and rain got in.. did nothing.

the bonnet idea is a good one, though my mate did it to his mz20 soarer and every car that he pulls up next to at lights tell him he has left his bonnet up haha.

the water on turbo is more of an issue if its boiling hot after a big thrash and then suddenly water hits it it changes temperature soo quick (immediately almost) that it shrinks and ive heard problems of cracking the housings though i dont know how true that is :confused:

the heat bag issue as roy has said is exactly what my point was about the bags being too efficient and not letting the air circulate at all. i'd imagine the turbo getting more than twice as hot as one without a bag on it.

whats these racepace ones worth? might give em a call tommorow, does anyone have a contact number and dont forget the state phone number first as im unsure which state they are in.

cheers

Brad

Edited by CruiseLiner

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now



  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • Jap premium will be 100 RON. You should use 98.
    • The exhaust gases are at their highest temperature as they leave the exhaust port and enter the manifold. They cool as they flow through the manifold because they transfer heat to the manifold and the manifold loses heat to the surrounding environment. Thus, inevitably, the exhaust gases are cooler as they enter the turbo compared to when they entered the exhaust manifold. So, yes, the exhaust manifold can easily get as hot as the turbine housing. Having said that, you will generally see the highest temperatures where the exhaust gases have to slow down or they are concentrated into one area - which is usually the collector on the manifold and in the turbine housing, because the gases slam into the metal at those places, increasing the convective heat transfer coefficient and transferring even more heat to the metal than they might just flowing past elsewhere. Exhaust manifold heat shields are a good idea - certainly for the stock manifold they are there from the factory. People seldom have anything like that on a tubular manifold because they are hard to achieve. Some might wrap a tube manifold with fibreglass tape - but this has a reputation of leading to cracked welds. The best case is generally to put ceramic coating onto the manifold to prevent it getting as hot (internal coating) and radiating/convecting heat into the bay (external coating). All the real heat from a turbo comes from the exhaust side. The gases entering are at ~800-900°C and the steel/iron gets nearly that hot. The compressor side is only going to heat the charge air up to <<200°C (typically not much more than 100°C). So that's nothing, by comparison. The compressor is not a significant source of engine bay heat.
    • Late to the party, specifically joined this forum as I just bought one of these and this thread has been a gold mine of info. If the OP is still around, mind if I ask what gas you been putting in yours? Mine has a Japanese sticker in the cap saying premium but it seems to get way worse mileage on premium (95) than 91. I always thought it was meant to be the other way round🤷 I do think Nissans claimed "6l/100km" is a bit fantastical 😂
    • Does exhaust manifold get hot as turno exhuast side? I have a turbo cover to managr heat in the engine bay but  nothing is covering the exhaust manifold before turbo   i know as turbo does compress air, the temp does go up however does that mean exhaust manifold would be as hot?
    • It's excellent but I'm still breaking it in so I'm not 100% sure where it'll end up. I would say it's about 15% heavier than stock and the smoothness of the slip zone is quite progressive but you need to be a little patient compared to stock or it'll bite hard and stall. Stock I got away with absolutely horrid clutch control. Like I said before I couldn't even tell where the clutch would grab when it was stock so releasing way too quickly without enough revs it would just slip and the revs would drop lower than ideal but that would be the end of it. Currently there's a bit of a nasty clutch judder if I don't apply enough revs + find the exact wrong point of the slip point in the clutch pedal but it feels like it's slowly resolving as I drive it more. I would not recommend the competition clutch unless you really need the extra clamp force. I think this clutch combined with the Nismo operating cylinder is going to be exactly what I want. Enough bite that you need to remember the release point to avoid stalling or rough shifts, but progressive enough that it's not hard to drive by any means and not heavy at all. I tried a "super single" clutch on my friend's 997.2 Turbo 6MT and that was absolutely horrid. It runs an electrohydraulic power steering pump for the clutch power boost so there's zero feedback in the clutch pedal and there was a horrific clutch shudder well after break-in due to the lack of marcel springs or hub springs in the friction disk. It felt like the slip zone was the thickness of a single toe twitch as well so it was almost impossible to avoid stalling it unless you gave it a ton of revs and just dumped the clutch instead of trying to be smooth with it. I was terrified of pulling out in front of traffic. I have also tried some kind of "super single" on an EK9 and that makes this twin plate Coppermix look like a stock clutch. Releasing the clutch pedal even slightly too quickly feels like you're getting rear-ended. The pedal is extremely heavy as well and there's no vacuum assist like the GTR.
×
×
  • Create New...