Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

A while ago i got in an accident (like 2 years ago). I need to know whos fault it is... i would be leaning towards mine which is why when i found out they were taking me to court i never bothered to fight it. But i want to know incase i shouldnt have to.

heres a pic.

accident.jpg

sifnt l3373s7 paint skills :D

heres the explination...

LEGEND:

Pink Car - Me

Black Car - Other driver

Green Car - Stationary Wreck from panel beaters

Yellow Car - Chris

Chris needed to get out of his car park at appx. 5pm

My car was blocking his path and as such had to be moved.

I got into the car, did the usual checks, rear mirror, side mirrors, seat belt and nothing was in the way.

I then proceeded to turn the car on and put it into reverse while still checking the mirrors.

Gipps St is very busy at this time.

I proceed to reverse the car while turning around and backing the car up, looking out the rear window

of the hatch and the side windows to see what i could.

Then i impacted with another car. (the black one on the pic)

The car had pulled in to do a 3 point turn from the otherside of the rd or maybe even from the same side

i still do not know what she was doing.

My question is, whos fault is it?

PS. i left out the car that was parked in front of mine which meant i couldnt move fwd.

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/11312-help-with-a-whos-fault-is-it/
Share on other sites

  • Replies 46
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

oh yeah the reason this was never sorted out there and then was because of the stupid insurance company i was with... who said "theyd sort it out" after i faxed all this and the info thru... well a month back i got a letter saying that the ppl in the accident were requesting i pay the money... so i tried contacting the insurance company again and again to no avail then they (the idiot driving the other car) took me to court without me even knowing and got awarded that i pay them!! all because i never got back to the solicitors in time cause i was waiting for the insurance company to hurry up and get back to me... i wasnt even told of a court hearing in regards to it so had no chance to defend myself... so now i have a summons to go to dandy court this wednesday to organise payments.

meh

That is one tough scenario. I would think that the other driver was at fault as she was completing a turn, thus must give way to all moving traffic. I would be inclined to ask vic roads.

Man, i hate to say it but it was a bad idea to not resolve the issue asap.

Are you able to appeal the finding? If they did not notifiy you how the hell are you suppose to show up for the hearing. I would ask for proof of notification, as that is just BS!! If your insurance company was to take care of it, i would seriously consider seeing a lawer and maybe suing them for not doing their job. Also if you were insured at the time of the accident and it is deemed to be your fault, shouldn't you only need to pay the excess required for a claim at that time, hell that's why you are paying for insurance.

yeah i know... i thought that they would have taken care of it and shared the view that it wasnt my fault and thus not had to pay the excess (what i thought) as it was the other persons fault... i knew nothing about how it all worked and just thought id let them handle it as they said they were going to.

i dunno... its all ***t up... worse comes to worse they get 50 a month out of me for the next few years lol *** em

thats defenitely a tough one, It could be either depending on which way you look at it. from what your saying you were looking behind you, did you see the car driving into you or not?? did you brake, then they hit you or were you reversing while they hit you??

So where did you impact? Did they impact while you were still reversing, or when you went to go forward??

It could be 50/50... when turning you need to give way to all ongoing traffic. Likewise when reversing you also have to give way to all ongoing traffic.

Insurance companies can dick around for months. Once it took 6 months to get a car fixed after an accident!

btw: there is a limit on the amount of years they can take like something this to court. Might want to check on that.

yer they pulled in behind me as i was reversing.... its hard to see something like the low front of a car thru ur back window and as i checked my side mirrors thats when we impacted.

I still think it still could be 50/50, as the other guy should have given way, and both couldn't fully see everything before doing what they were doing. It sounds like just one of those freaky unlucky things that neither party could avoid.

It sucks, 'cause often reversing you just have to go and hope that nobody is coming, especially in car parks with fugged up 4WD's where you can't see shit through them!

cant remember the lines... will go down and check.

they were doing a 3 point turn... all the other parks in our building were taken... i was parked on the side of the street where i park everyday.

the double lines is a good point.

nark: i ask my frends whose pro at car accidents

he say if u already reported to ur insurance company and they send u the claim number also u paid the excess fee. then when the court day comes u show the magistrate ur documents from ur insurance company. it will be the insurance's fault for not paying up.

if u didnt have claim no.s and didnt report, and the other party does not have witnesses then u can defence for urself, saying that u wasnt reversing while the black car impacted with u, argue that the black car should take full responsibility for it since ur car wasnt moving in anyway. say u were just parked there talking on the phone. but if the other party got witness, then most likely u will lose. otherwise the magistrate will either make u win or both at fault-"to deal between u and the other party".

why it took so long to proceed what happened 2 yrs ago due to maybe the other party repaired the car themselves and now claiming back there money, but this they have to prove that the invoice day was like 2 yrs ago.

I hope U are fine Inark, i pray for you:)

hehehe nah i aint lying... i was moving.

silly cow... i'll go past there tomorow night with the camera and check the lines.

as for the insurance company they never gave me a claim number they just said they would take care of it.... which they never... never being in an accident or even using insurance to make a claim i took their word for it on face value... should have consulted my parents about or something as they would have told me that they needed to give me claim numbers etc.

meh its not really that bigger deal... its only 2k.

nark:i am sure if u can save up the 2k u will b happy coz u can contribute more to something u like!

then...do they have witness? u know...the insurance company is really shifty....u got no prove now!! i will never trust any associations unless they give me prove of evidence!!:( ok if u are not lying then u mite lose...or maybe both-at-fault...but this is a disavantage for ya...so the magistrate might take the first option..mm:( i was like telling the truth aboout my accident so i got diversion...i think if u b sorried u mite get diversion too?

u know if the case is braught to court...u will be recorded as convicted....so should get some legal advice....

otherwise i can ask fren more...

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now



  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • Turbo gods, some assistance and recommendations please I'm looking into a turbo kit for my 2.5 from MX5 Mania >>>>> https://mx5mania.com.au/products/copy-of-mx-5-nc-2-5-litre-engine-conversion-turbo-2005-2013 Power wise I would like about 200kw atw, and of course dose noises, apparently if you keep a stock 2.5 under around 200kwatw the engine and drivetrain will not hate life even when ragging on it a bit Max RPM on the 2.5 is around 6500rpm The turbo MX5 use is something around the disco potato size as  packaging room for the turbo is pretty limited, which will, I believe, give me my power goals I want and not have the turbo either under, or oversized, but the rear housing bit is confusing  It comes with either a 0.64 or 0.86 From my understanding, which so far is based off googling, so make of that what you will 0.64: spools faster = good Makes more EGT heat on boost = bad Less topend power than 0.86 = I'm only looking for 200 atw so that point may be mute????, I don't know, hence my questions  0.86: Spools a "little" slower = how much slower??? remembering 6500 is my max rpm Makes less EGT heat = good Makes a little more power up top = again, power goals is only around 200 Also, this is a street car, so there will not really be any long track sessions, in saying this I would want it so it was happy with at least 3 hot laps at Wakefield Park if the need arises  I already have a fancy pants triple pass radiator, and a oil cooler with thermostat will be getting installed as well Thanks for any information or recommendations you have 👍, and of course, the comments about me wasting money on drive in drive out modifications, or any other snide remarks about my manhood for owning a MX5 🤣    
    • Tape some wool onto the vent then take it for a drive I did this to my reverse cowl and was instantly unhappy, as anything over about 60kph would have the wool enter the engine bay, thus just adding underbonnet pressure and stooging my coolant stack, it did let alot of heat out when stationary though, which really didn't help once the car was moving, with the reverse cowl you could watch the coolant temps cheap up the faster you went on the hwy, I assume it would be alot worse doing track day speed With the vented bonnet (just after the radiator and about 1/3 up the bonnet) on my old R33 the wool on the leading edge sat at about a 45° angle as air poured out of it From looking where your vents are, and their size, I believe you should be fine at speed and air should be evacuated from the engine bay, I think it will be a night and day difference when stuck in traffic though for removing the trapped heat, and not sitting there cooking when parked up after driving around... #convection  Post wool tuft pics and data for science  This beastie is one nice and unique rig, enjoy
    • It is possible to do this stuff for "cheap". But you need to be able to get deals on all the bigger items, and it really helps if you're fully capable of doing your own work. As soon as you're paying retail for new parts, or buying "kits" because you can't fabricate necessary bits and pieces, and if you really need someone else to take the reins of doing the work because you don't have the space/time/skills/confidence to  rip deep into the car and put it back together in a working fashions.....then you pay. And these days, pay means a lot of money. You'd think things would get cheaper, but they don't. They just seem to keep getting more and more expensive.
    • It’s almost the price of an engine build, you won’t have anything to bolt onto it though 
    • Hopefully it's enough to help with the temps! I was also only shit stirring, regarding Murphy's Law basically. I've found, what ever spare parts I have, are the parts I don't break. Ever. Also have never had issues with oil/spinning bearings until I put oil pressure gauges on the car. 😛
×
×
  • Create New...