Jump to content
SAU Community

High Knock Reading


Recommended Posts

  • Replies 52
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

so what should i do, i'v taken the car back numerous times and it's always the same result, all that happens when i take it back is the tuner just keeps lowering the timing, to me it seems like he just can't be bothered

I might as well get the stock ecu put back in, cause thats what it feels like

Edited by Hulk1010
Link to comment
Share on other sites

It really depends where it is knocking.

If it's on over run then not a major concern, or if you are bouncing off the limiter then it isn't uncommon as the pfc cuts fuel creating a lean condition

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It really depends where it is knocking.

If it's on over run then not a major concern, or if you are bouncing off the limiter then it isn't uncommon as the pfc cuts fuel creating a lean condition

Fuel cuts aren't a lean condition as all the injectors are shut off. Knocking on the rev limiter is usually from crackshaft harmonics due to the massive rotational decelleration. Find out when the knock occurs and we might be able to help you out more.

Edited by rob82
Link to comment
Share on other sites

thanks for the replys

I'ts always before the limiter, at random times, I might give it a boot from 2nd, 3rd, 4th etc and end up getting a high reading, could it be the knock sensor?

a week back i gave it a boot from second and then checked the knock level reading and it read 111, the RPM was 5500

Link to comment
Share on other sites

thanks for the replys

I'ts always before the limiter, at random times, I might give it a boot from 2nd, 3rd, 4th etc and end up getting a high reading, could it be the knock sensor?

a week back i gave it a boot from second and then checked the knock level reading and it read 111, the RPM was 5500

By that knock level you should actually start to hear it through the fire wall. Is it a temperature based problem ie does it do it at night on the highway or slow cruising around town in the heat of the day?? If you pull 2 deg out globally does it stll do it??

Link to comment
Share on other sites

By that knock level you should actually start to hear it through the fire wall. Is it a temperature based problem ie does it do it at night on the highway or slow cruising around town in the heat of the day?? If you pull 2 deg out globally does it stll do it??

OK - I kind of have this problem too – but not as bad

I have an R32 GTR with Weisco forged pistons - and my knock reading creeps up to the high 50s from time to time. I have also seen bursts up into the 70s but only if I'm using bad fuel.

I have had my engine checked by 3 different tuners - all using head phones to listen for knock - and they all confirm that my engine is NOT knocking

Under the settings menu on your PFC you add advance / retard timing and increase the injector duty cycle across the entire rev range – or 'globally'

I tried taking timing out in steps. I stepped up from -2 / -4 / -8 degrees - and it made no difference to the readings.

I then added more fuel 'globally' - still no difference

I then did some tweaking to both at the same time – still got the same readings (shrugs)

So - I figure I either have a dodgy knock sensor - or just a noisy engine :)

or possibly both

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The knock reading can be misleading as ive seen many cars with high readings with no det at all.One GTS read a count of 93 no matter what you did, we even backed the CAS off asd far as it could go and retarded timing with the PFC with no change,even changing the knock sensors did nothing.Use the reading as a guide only but its no where near perfect so us other means as a back up if your not sure.

A maximum power tune will give readings in the 50s also,this is why i like to use other tools for det detection on the dyno on hi powered cars.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Does it do it all the the time?

Every now and then I'll get really high readings,spoke to the tuner and he mentioned it could be the fuel pump.

I've just replaced it and its still playing funny buggers, highest knock of 120 when overtaking in fifth gear with less than 3 qtr throttle.

All other times sits on mid to low 30's!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

same boat **raises hand.

Mine has hit a max of 84, but after a bit of driving in low and high revs the knocking is down to lower than ~30. Is this a problem at all?. If I am driving with no hard boosting the knocking is lower than 20....

Also have been told to watch for blowing smoke.

White = water

Brownish = fuel

Black = oil

is that right?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

should i get my mechanic to check out my knock sensor before i do anything else? the car is due for a service soon anyway so i could get him to do it then

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I've put about 6,000km on my GTR in the past 4mths driving in conditions from 5c-44c on 0.8-1.4bar and never have I seen my knock level go above 32.

Maybe it is time for you to find a different tuner Hulk.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I have the same problem with my gtstr33. it spikes upwards of 120 with the aircon on, and up around 50-60 with aircon off. It happens at around 4500-5000 rpm.

I have my map locked so i cant take out any timing to do some fault finding. This is quite annoying seeing the engine check light flash rapidly at me. I hate the thought of slowly killing my engine.

I had mine tuned at one of the best tuners in sydney and it was not detonating on the dyno. I even took it back for them to play with and they did take some timing out. I am wondering if its possible for the car to be using different load points under wot on the dyno to wot on the road. In this case that part of the map may not be tuned????

Does any one else notice a rise in knock if the aircon is on???

Link to comment
Share on other sites

^ The engine is working harder with the aircon on... so its gonna show up.

Take it back to this "one of the best tuners" and tell them its still happening. Sacrafice a little bit of power for the overall health of your engine...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share




  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • Well.... yes and perhaps no. It depends on what you mean by "spool". For most of us, the point that we would describe as where the turbo is "spooling" is the point where the wheel speed gets high enough for it to start making some boost. This is coincidentally around about the point where it starts making noise - hence the "spooling" sound. If that is what you mean, then no - the wastegate should still be shut at this point. The boost will still be way below the point where it should start opening. If, on the other hand, you mean "spool" as "reach full boost", then yes. At the point where the boost has reached target, then boost control has already started. The wastegate is already open, and has been for some time. Some short time, definitely, but still, some time. If you have no boost controller - just the wastegate actuator connected to the boost source, then you have a mechanical system working as a pressure balance. There is pressure on one side of the wastegate actuator's diaphragm from the spring, and pressure on the other side coming from the boost measurement location (the "source"). This is not a digital thing. The wastegate does not stay shut until the boost pressure reaches the spring "pressure". The spring will start to compress as soon as you start to apply any pressure onto it. This can be controlled somewhat by adding pre-load into the spring, but you cannot add enough preload to make it into a digital switch behaviour. The wastegate will crack open and start to leak exhaust out (and therefore not though the turbine) well before you reach the target boost pressure. Electronic (and some mechanical/pneumatic) boost controllers will act to prevent the boost source applying pressure to the actuator until just before you reach target boost, thus preventing the wastegate from creeping open. And some boost controllers will apply boost pressure on the spring side to further push it shut. And this can be be necessary because the exhaust pressure in the manifold also pushes on the wastegate valve and tries to open it and you cab get it leaking even without it being connected to the boost source.
    • A stand alone boost controller will not give you the control you need, unlike a modern ECU. Your boost will always naturally target the wastegate's opening pressure first, your controller then will allow you to add more boost as required.
    • I recently discovered that I could not remove the outer bolt on one of my rear UCAs. Looked like it was seized to the crush tube. It wasn't all that long since I had last had that arm out (I dunno exactly, but certainly <2 yrs), so I was a bit surprised. I thought I had stock bushes in the rear knuckles, so I ordered some new PU bushes and resigned myself to having to do some dismantlery....and some butchery. It was clear that the seized bush was going to need to have the bolt cut out of it and then possibly some more brutality after that. Upon getting the 3x arms on each side disconnected from the knuckles (with the exception of the seized one, of course), I discovered that I had in fact put PU bushes into the knuckles when I did the subframe conversion about 12-13 years ago. So, I say "Oh, good, I might not have to swap any of these others out". We set to work butchering the bolt out of the seized arm. Stainless blade in a big-arse Milwaukee recipro made short work of it, and also damaged the arm, which added a welding and grinding and painting step to the whole exercise. During the butchery it became clear that the bolt was not just seized but bent. Head scratching ensued, as it is hard to understand how that bolt could get bent. I did suffer a broken (stock) toe control arm on that side a few months ago, and drove some miles with some significant rear wheel self steer and lack of control, which probably was the cause. But it's still hard to understand how it would bend that bolt, rather than just bend the arm. But here's the start of the real discoveries. The crush tube was rusty as all shit. I mean seriously rusty. A little on the inside, contributing to the tube seizing to the bolt (along with the bend). But the outside had at least 2-3mm of compressed flaky iron oxide jammed in between the parent metal and the PU bush. This one was brutalised and still took some effort to get the PU off the crush tube. So I thought I'd inspect the others more closely. The one on the tension rod adjacent the bent one was first. I had to use a 2-jaw puller to get the crush tube out, and it took some effort. It came out looking like the first one. All 6 of them were the same, except for one that looked not too bad. Had some corrosion on it, but was mostly OK. There was also a significant amount of corrosion on the inner surfaces of the knuckles. They took some convincing with pointy tools to let go their grip on the inside of the holes they were in. There was no sign of the original (SuperPro) lube anywhere. I and my bro-in-law have never seen any crush tube end up looking like this. It was seriously like the car has spent time putting boats into the water at the boat ramp. So, it seems like the PU might have been bonded to the steel on both sides, which would have to make them work more like stock rubber bushes (where arm deflection results in twist inside the rubber). Despite this, I have never had cause to believe that they were so tightly bound up. The suspension moved up and down much as you'd expect. The car never made any noises in those bushes that would have led me to believe there was a problem. Maybe the rusty interfaces actually were "sliding". Anyway, lesson learnt. Even quiet, non-troublesome PU bushes should be inspected every now and then!
    • the boost controller allows you to adjust the opening of the wastegate (which only has one preset spring) I'm going to see how it acts on it
    • I studied the principle of wastegate to begin with. so if I understood correctly. the moment when the turbo "spool" is where the boost control begins. When the target level of "psi" is reached the wastegate opens to regulate the exhaust pressure passing through the turbo and thus control its speed and the rate of boost
×
×
  • Create New...