Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

Hey guys,

Driving home tonight gave it a squirt in first put it into second, full throttle and then when it came onto full boost I hear BANG and the whole car jerks and theirs a massive rattle sound coming from the gearbox,

I quickly pulled over and turned the car off had a look underneath to see if anything was fallen off or anything but coudlnt see anything out of the ordinary, got back in the car started it, MASSIVE rattling sound coming from the gearbox on idle even when the car was in neutral, car very hard to get into gear, took off in first took off very hard just that massive constant rattle, everytime I tried to put it into second I just get a massive bang and the whole car jerks and it wont go in so I managed to baby the car home in 3rd (with that loud rattling noise still going constantly seems to ease up a bit when the clutch it put all the way in and the car is idling)

Ive booked a tow for the morning to get the car to a workshop but does it seem like the gearbox is gone?

Why do these things happen at the worst times was just preparing to put my new turbo on and fix some other things on the car :cheers:

Edited by Dave69001
Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/128343-did-i-just-kill-my-gearbox/
Share on other sites

if it's at idle (in neutral), its likely that it's the clutch and not the gearbox

because obviously nothing in the gearbox should be moving in neutral

does it still make the sound if you push the clutch pedal in?

Hmm hopefully thats what it is mate I just replaced the clutch with a heavy duty one 2 months ago though so not sure why it would of caused this.

Yeah it does seem to go away if you put the clutch in and its idling but when I was babying it home whenever I put the clutch in as the car was going along it would still do it but I guess the gearbox would still have things moving if the cars moving right?

Edited by Dave69001
Sounds like the g/box is gone, when in neutral the main shaft still turns . The only time it doesn't is when the car is not moving and clutch pedal pushed in.

you learn something new everyday!

thanks for clearing that up :cheers:

to put it plain and simple:

if your car is rolling (clutch in OR out)- there will be a section of the gearbox that is moving.

if the clutch pedal is out, and its in neutral (regardless of rolling or not rolling) there will be a different section of the gearbox thats moving.

to get a very good understanding of how gearboxes work i reccomend this link:

http://auto.howstuffworks.com/transmission.htm

your description to me sounds like your gearbox has been raped.

my condolences for your loss (as much as i like to be right, i hope im wrong). i hate it when bad shit happens to pride and joys.

cheers. james.

EDIT: took me so long to write this up, your question has been answered before i finished! but atleast i supplied a good link! cheers.

Dude if you are upgrading to a bigger turbo I would change to an R33 gearbox as 20 ones are fairly weak. Is a bit more expensive but better in the long run as its 1 less thing to worry about busting all the time.

Shit bad luck dave and you haven't even been able to put my turbo on yet!! :P

Although R33 boxes are stronger, I can't see the need to upgrade to one unless your pulling some decent figures already, and plan to take the car alot further power wise.

FRom what i've been told you need the g/box itself obviously, approx $1500, get it fitted, and i'm pretty sure you also need a custom made tailshaft, and alot of other crap to get it working.. it's a costly exercise, but you would never have to worry about breaking the box again!!

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • Out here E90s are the cheapest way into a sporty-ish car because everyone knows just how expensive the repairs can get. 8-10k USD for an automatic 335i. 
    • Noted. Have noticed BMW are more 'high maintenance' for sure. They've attracted my attention as I think the used car prices seem reasonable vs other options, and the extra quality overall vs a commodore / camry / corolla or similar of the same vintage is appealing, especially the interior, and they are more on the sporty side whereas the others mentioned can be more cruising or economical A-to-B only.
    • Haha yeah I know, this is SAU after all, why are we talking about BMW's of all things!? I hear you on the 'don't have to worry about it' side of things. Having been fortunate enough to be have been able to buy a brand new motorbike or two...never really enjoyed them as much as I'd have liked as you worry so much about where you park it, will it get scratched, stolen, attempted theft, knocked over, etc...and yes dirty. Older less valuable bikes you can just go where you want and park it wherever and not really worry that much in comparison. And who cares if it gets dirty! Never owned a V8, and have had my eyes on VE / VF commodores for years but with their prices climbing so high, the M3 has come into focus more as prices are much closer than I've ever seen...is it a potential contender now?...of course need to factor in the S65 'maintenance' especially and like you said general M car 'tax'. One can dream anyway. But more on the reality front - did read the whole 330i thread as well and was a great read too, both threads enlightening as I've never even driven one of these cars! I do recall 330i didn't seem to have the same amount of issues for almost the same car (turbos and related differences notwithstanding)...perhaps down to getting it earlier in it's life so looked after better than the 335i? Perhaps so as your 130i has been good and quite similar, so finding a car that's been looked after well is the especially-crucial-BMW-first-step.
    • Nice. Dont worry about the time of not running. My current skyline hasn't run since I bought it. About 8 years ago.
    • It's also worth noting that I am heavily and unconditionally biased. I've had a lot of cars including some GTRs a fair while ago. I love my BMW's now a lot. They make no sense a lot of the time and the guys on here remind me regularly that I could get something else that does what I want better and cheaper. If you're going to take on an older BMW it's definitely a commitment. If you bail on it early you'll lose money and also the ability for it to put a smile on your face. Stick with it and it just gets better.  f**k I should get into advertising.  
×
×
  • Create New...