Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

Hey guys,

I am in need of some advice.

It all started when I was making my way out to QR for a drift practice on Sunday 21st of November I think it was. Coming onto the Ipswich motorway I was in second and gave it a stab and a clutch kick, everything was going fine and dandy until I hit third and then BANG shake rattle rattle grrr (all kinds of nasty noises) I clutched in and the engine died instantly. I was rolling with the clutch in trying to re-start it, but it wouldn't even turn over :P

Got towed to my mechanics, and then he went to hospital for 2 weeks. So finally we have the engine apart, and the rod in cylinder 6 twisted and then snapped (will post pictures, I'm using it as a paper weight at work). Here is where my problem lies. The engine was a decent piece of gear (or so I thought) It was a stroked RB25DET with forged internals, big set of cams, HKS cast Manifold and an early HKS T04 kit.

To get me back on the road quickly I am thinking of putting an RB20DET back in (car is an R32) while I build up an RB30DET. What I want to know is what are your opinions on this? Another idea was to put a stock RB25 back in while I build the RB30. But RB25's are expensive and hard to source at the moment, and I am only going to be ripping it out in less than 6 months anyway. But how much am I going to have to change to put the RB20 back in? Will the exhaust manifold bolt back up to the RB20? Is the deck height that much difference that the cooler pipes will have to be modified? What about engine mounts and cross member?

In essence I would prefer to put a RB20 in, because they are cheap and they rev and I know I will thrash the living shit out of it and have a great time doing it not caring. If there is going to be way too much stuff to change I will fork out for an RB25 but then have to treat it with kid gloves so it is still in good condition so I can re-sell when the RB30 goes in.

Sorry for the long thread, and thanks for reading.

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/148002-so-i-dropped-a-rod-in-cylinder-6/
Share on other sites

did little bits of metal work there way through the engine and cause any extra damage?

Yes, yes they did.

Also when the rod broke, the piston continued up into the head and took a chunk out of it (not too bad though). My rebuilt T04 <1500km now has some pretty nasty co-axial play in it. And some "glitter" in the exhaust housing :)

and why did the rod break? how bad was it pinging? or did a bearing spin?
Thats a bit of a concern for the rod to do that under those circumstances.

Before you do anything, diagnose exactly what happened.

My first guess is a bearing problem

My guess as to why the rod broke is that who ever built it in Japan didn't want to fork out the extra dosh for forged rods and just got the stockos shot peened and treated. Also the rev limiter was set pretty f**king high for a stroked engine, (I just tried to stay away from it) and with a chipped ecu I could not change this as I was waiting for my PFC injectors and an EBC to all go in at once.

I was so hoping for a spun bearing rather than a dropped rod, but alas they look to be in good condition. Especially considering the state of the oil that was in the engine when the car came over from Japan. Oil changes every 500km or so over half a dozen times and the oil was still totally pitch black after 100km or so.

get a 25DE and bolt your shit on

cruise around in it until your built 30DET is finished then start thrashing again.

25DE is around $700

This leads me to my next question.

What about wiring for the RB25DE? Can I use the existing wiring loom and ecu from my RB25DET? Can I swap the DET injectors over into the DE manifold? What compression ratio does the RB25DE run?

I know a few people have done RB25 conversions this way on the cheap, so what kind of power will the DE tolerate with a decent tune?

Finally, how hard is it to get hold of an RB25DE? Is my best bet to cruise the forums looking or just go straight to an importer?

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • I think my main complaint with your idea is that there is a veneer of idealism spread across it. You want the simple numbers to make it easier, but all they will do is make it easier for someone to come to the wrong conclusion because the fine details will kick them in the nuts. As it is right now, the tiny bit of arithmetic is NOT the obstacle to understanding what will fit and what will not fit. The reality of trying it is what determines whether it will fit. If you had a "standard rule" that R34 GTT guards have that magic 100mm space from the hub face to whichever side you were worried about, and someone said "excellent, this wheel is only 98mm in that direction, I'll just go spend $4k on them and jam them on my sick ride".....they would just as likely find out that the "standard rule" is not true because the rear subframe is offset to one side by a fairly typical (but variable) 8mm on their car and they only have 92mm on one side and 108 on the other.
    • It still combines inches with mm, especially when you have .5 inches involved, and mm and inches that can go in either direction. This would give a clear idea on both sides of the rim, right away, with no arithmetic. Even better if somebody gives you the dimensions of the arch of multiple cars. i.e GTR may be 125mm, a A80 Supra may be 117mm, or something along those lines. Yes, you can 'know' that going from a 10in rim to a 10.5in rim with the same offset moves both sides about 6mm, but you still have to 'know' that and do the math. Often it's combined. People are going from 9.5 +27 to 10.5 +15. You may do the math to know it, but if it was going from (I had to go look it up to be sure) 241mm/2 - 27 - 93.5mm from the center line to (more math) 266/2 - 15 (118mm) from the center line. Versus 93mm vs 118mm. It's right there. If you know you have a GTT with 100mm guards you can see right away that one is close to flush and the other absolutely won't work. And when someone says "Oh the GTR is 120mm" suddenly you see that the 10.5 +15 is about perfect. (or you go and buy rims with approximately 118mm outward guard space) I think it's safe to say that given one of the most common questions in all modified cars is "How do offsets work" and "How do I know if wheels will fit on my car" that this would be much simpler... Of course, nothing will really change and nobody is going to remanufacture wheels and ditch inches and offset based on this conversation :p We'll all go "18x9+30 will line up pretty close to the guards for a R34 GTT (84mm)" but 'pretty close' is still not really defined (it is now!) and if you really care you still have go measure. Yes it depends on camber and height and dynamic movement, but so do all wheels no matter what you measure it for.
    • But offsets are simple numbers. 8" wheel? Call it 200mm, near enough. +35 offset? OK, so that means the hub face is that far out from the wheel centreline. Which is 2s of mental arithmetic to get to 65mm to outer edge and 135mm to inner. It's hardly any more effort for any other wheel width or offset. As I said, I just close my eyes and can see a picture of the wheel when given the width and offset. That wouldn't help me trust that a marginal fitment would actually go in and clear everything, any more than the supposedly simple numbers you're talking about. I dunno. Maybe I just automatically do numbers.
    • Sure! But you at least have simple numbers instead of 8.5 inches +/mm, relative to your current rims you do maths with as well, and/or compare with OEM diameter, which you also need to know/research/confirm..
×
×
  • Create New...