Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

hey, i have been tossing up which gauge to buy, cosmetics is not an issue, so i just want to get the best performing gauge possible for a reasonable budget.

i have looked at autometer and the following options are:

mechanical

electric - short sweep

electric - full sweep

veiw here: http://www.autometer.com/cat_gaugeseries.aspx

my question is, what kind of accuracy differences are there in the gauges? i figure the electric ones are easier to install, and i know the full-sweep is the most accurate out of all of them, but if there is minimal difference in acuracy between the mechanical and short-sweep electrical and the only difference is ease of installation and cost then the mech might be a good idea.

also what is the value for all of these as i need to know whats a good buy. does $300 for a 66mm Oil pressure, 52mm Water temp, 52mm Boost/Vaccum all short-sweep electrical and sport-comp, and a DIN holder sound?

cheers

Edited by nisskid
Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/156528-gauge-qs/
Share on other sites

which are terribly innacurate and inconsistent. i remember once i could smell my engine cooking during a fairly spirited hills run, so i backed off not knowing what was going on, about 20seconds lately my water temp gauge shot up to the high reading over about 3 seconds (real handy, lucky i have the nose of a dog lol). not to mention in the morning it will go from stone cold to opertation temperature within 10-20 seconds, even after a few minutes of driving.

then we get to oil pressure, lol, basically i havnt been able to drive my car for a few weeks now as the gauge is f**ked and i cant get a proper reading, and since i have a few problems related to oil pressure at the moment i do not feel confident driving it without a proper reading of oil pressure.

so then we get to the boost gauge, well i think we can all say without doubt that it is a POS and doesnt even read to what most of us boost our cars to anyway. i am about to install a bleed valve along with a new turbo, so i will need acurate readings to set my bleed valve at the right level.

i actually made a mistake, its a oil temp gauge, not a boost gauge included in that $300.

the oil temp isnt as important, but there is still lag between oil temp and water temp so its a good reading to know.

also i saw these, they have stepping motors etc and seem to be relatively cheap, but they are autogauge so im weary.

http://cgi.ebay.com.au/AUTO-GAUGE-52mm-Oil...1QQcmdZViewItem

Edited by nisskid
Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/156528-gauge-qs/#findComment-2909193
Share on other sites

the stock gauges are idiot dials, they give you a basic indication but are slow to react and hide changes from you (eg water temp gauge shows halfway no matter if it's a cold winter morning or hot summer day).

bear in mind that mechanical gauges are sometimes a defect item - you cannot run a mechanical oil pressure gauge inside the cabin because a leak will spray hot oil around at high pressure which is dangerous. mechanical boost gauge is fine IMO, worst that's going to do is hiss at you.

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/156528-gauge-qs/#findComment-2912304
Share on other sites

Please consider...

Don't buy crap gauges, as well as looking tacky, they aren't reliable or accurate.

The gauges will be your link to monitoring the running condition of your engine.

The autogauge boost gauge that I had started off fine, then went south, eventually checked against a mechanical test gauge and found it was ~5psi out.

Using a mechanical apexi el gauge and happy.

The difference between mechanical and electrical isn't that big so just get what you want. Nothing says that the electrical is going to be any better than the mechanical. If anything I'd trust the other way.

Running greddy electrical ex.temp and oil.temp gauges and very happy with those as well, just wouldn't want to have to pay for them again...

James.

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/156528-gauge-qs/#findComment-2913656
Share on other sites

^^yeh, i would only consider a mechanical boost gauge as i dont want hot oil coming into the cabin, but i still need to know whether i should be looking at full sweep or short sweep electric ones.

in theory they should be similar accuracy, but a full sweep gauge makes it easier to visually identify smaller changes.

i'd go with what looks better, myself. either way, a quality aftermarket gauge that reacts quickly is better than the stock dials.

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/156528-gauge-qs/#findComment-2913670
Share on other sites

  • 5 months later...

I have 3 autometer phantomn guages.

mechanical oil temp

mechanical water temp

electrical afr

the temp ones are both great, but the afr one jumps around so much i never really look at it

happy camper tho. They look great also

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/156528-gauge-qs/#findComment-3284824
Share on other sites

Autometer aren't that accurate. If you do a Google search on Autometer gauges you'll find heaps of ppl saying how crap they are. I had an Autometer Sportcomp mechanical boost gauge which gave me low readings and also never sat on zero when the car was turned off.

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/156528-gauge-qs/#findComment-3284908
Share on other sites

I'm only aiming at a 250 rwkw daily driver, so they don't need to be perfect... They are easily accurate enough for my needs. And yes they are in cabin :thumbsup:

Edited by joeyjoejoejuniorshabadoo
Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/156528-gauge-qs/#findComment-3284964
Share on other sites

As far as I know any mechanicel gauge is illegal as mentioned but they don't really bother with boost. Oil/Fuel/Water on the other hand is a dangerous one.

Has anyone successfully installed a Autometer oil pressure short-sweep electric into a rb20det r32 with the fttings they supply? Also where is the oil pressure sensor and what is the procedure to fit the autometer sensor/sendor unit into position.

Edited by Kane_R32
Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/156528-gauge-qs/#findComment-3285998
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • Just checked in first post and you should be able to bring it home November this year, right? I'm amazed you made it through four years of this. As hard as it feels now the rest will go by in a breeze in hindsight, I'm sure.
    • Realized I haven't been back here in a while. Still here, still alive, still waiting for the car.  I went back again the only time last year from Oct-Nov for R's Meeting and drove it around some more, including a few laps on Fuji Speedway(in the wet, sadly). The car still feels good, but have a couple small things to address. I've been getting more parts but have slowed down still, and most of the bigger purchases are now out of the way. I find myself getting impatient more and more when it comes to getting started on this project; it's quite hard for me not being able to really dive in and start making this car my own because it's halfway across the world. At times it doesn't even really feel like I own one of these. Haven't really been motivated or had the desire to document the last trip on here or social media for, well, reasons... but here's some pics...it's also still alive and well as you can see: I've narrowed down to the last large part purchases(anything over $2k) before the engine build to be: 1) Ohlins Road & Tracks 2) ATS Twin Carbon clutch 3) Endless BBK with some custom options and 4) Kansai Service carbon driveshaft I don't think the budget exists for all of these this year, but I'll try for one or two items I think. Though, every time I look at my spreadsheet I sigh, shake my head, and get depressed just that little bit more.  'til later.
    • It's a stunning location!  I've been to NZ twice but haven't made it to the North Island yet.  Definitely on the cards but the South Island is hard to tear yourself away from too... Looking forward to see what you can wring out of it once you can get it to hold together!  Be awesome to get a low 11 or even sneaking into the high 10's pass out of it.  That's a bloody quick car that most people will never experience in their life.  Enjoy!
    • Nominally yes but I’m not really at that stage yet. Outsourcing to Japan is also a relatively good deal at the moment because their currency has devalued much more against the USD.  You would assume this but a lot has changed from the pandemic. Mechanics are in short supply and demand for fixing old cars has gone up from the cost of new cars. 250-300 USD/hr is not an unusual shop labor rate in California and you’re paying that regardless of whether the guy is competent or not. Coworkers have been quoted 3000 USD for a water pump and thermostat at a dealer on an N54. Oil changes went from ~75 USD to 150 on fairly normal cars like Civics. The cost of the oil and filter hasn’t even kept up with inflation.
    • The downside to that is that the cost of everything, particularly labour, is significantly higher here than it is over there in the Disunited States of Slavery. You can hire 3 tradesmen over there for just the Ranger Raptor allowance of a single 3rd year apprentice over here.
×
×
  • Create New...