Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

I was having a discussion with a friend today about LSD's, and it made me think up a few questions. I know that when a tyre spins, it makes the car want to pivot around that axis (the tyre), so wouldn't that mean that a car *without* an LSD would tend to lose the rear end (ie: fishtail) *more* than a car with an LSD (ie: it is more dangerous in the wet than with a car with an LSD)?

So, with my original situation where I was going around a LH turn at a constant 50 km/h up a hill, the inside (LH) rear tyre would be the most likely to spin since it has the least weight on it and it has drive torque passing through it. I was under the impression that once the LSD senses that tyre spinning, it would lockup the diff to a certain percentage, thereby allowing some drive torque through to the RH rear tyre. That should stop the LHR tyre spinning, thereby correcting the slide (well, this should all happen before the car starts sliding, but anyway...). So, the only reason that I would be sliding is because the drive torque passing through the RHR tyre has overpowered the amount of grip available, and now *both* rear tyres are spinning, thereby causing the car to lose rear end grip and thus oversteer? Basically, what I'm asking is, did my car start to slide because only the LHR tyre was spinning (the first paragraph), or because *both* rear tyres were spinning? If it's the former, then would that make my LSD stuffed? If it's the latter, I presume my LSD is working, but wouldn't that mean that cars equipped with LSD's are actually more dangerous to drive in the wet than with cars that have open diffs? I'm all confused now... :happy:

And finally, what about when you see two tyre marks left on the road as a result of a burnout? That means that the tyre with the least grip has lost grip, which has sent torque to the other rear tyre, which was then overpowered by that torque? But why do both tyre marks look about the same "darkness"? Shouldn't one be much darker because that tyre is spinning faster than the other (ie: the wheel that initially lost grip)?

What did you mean by Skylines having better balance, therefore equalling more wheelspin? Do you mean front/rear weight distribution, or having more "neutral" handling characteristics, ie: not as understeer-biased as the Calais?

Yes, more neutral. If a car is understeer biassed and you put your foot down the rear grips, the front scrubs and you go straight ahead. If a car is neutral and you put your foot down the back wheels spin and you get oversteer.

Now re your above post... Your comment about the car pivoting around the spinning wheel is false IMO.. I don't believe it works that way.

When you have no LSD then the tyre with the least grip will spin. The thing is, this is unpredictable and the spinning tyre can change from moment to moment. Hence, yes, you can fishtail and lose it with an open diff in the wet because when you correct, the weight shifts and the other wheel spins up, making it snap back on you.

A V-LSD is in some ways almost as bad because the LSD action is related to SPEED differential. Not applied torque from the engine. So you must have some wheelspin in order for the LSD to start working. Again, if you have small amounts of wheelspin it can behave like an open diff. My R33 is really quite twitchy in the wet sometimes.

A clutch type LSD operates on torque - the more torque the more LSD action so they are much better LSDs.

Then you've got locked diffs - by which I mean there is no differential action both wheels always rotate at the same speed. This is bad for handling, bad for tyre wear and bad for your rear bushes. Not to mention really bad for grip unless your wheel is pointed dead straight. HOWEVER, with a locked diff you always know that any wheelspin means both wheels are spinning, and they are very predictable in that respect. Of course, if you don't know how to drive then you WILL end up reversing it into a tree because you thought that giving it a hit around a wet corner was a smart idea. Totally dangerous and illegal. But fun. Apparently. :rofl:

Regarding your rain problem, I'd say you spun the inside wheel, as it had less grip. Then the V-LSD saw a speed differential between the wheels and started transferring torque to the outside wheel. Since the engine is now revving harder through the spinning wheel you've got more torque available and this overpowers the other rear wheel and then you're going sideways.

Regarding your rain problem, I'd say you spun the inside wheel, as it had less grip. Then the V-LSD saw a speed differential between the wheels and started transferring torque to the outside wheel. Since the engine is now revving harder through the spinning wheel you've got more torque available and this overpowers the other rear wheel and then you're going sideways.

Hmm... that's exactly what I originally thought was happening. But then I started thinking about the "inside wheel acting as a pivot" concept and it started to make sense. I mean, thinking about the initial corner, I wasn't really applying all that much throttle, so was it really possible for the other wheel to become overpowered? That's the bit I was getting confused with. I would understand if I were applying WOT or I was in a low gear, but I wasn't. I was literally just trying to maintain a constant speed, albeit on a relatively steep hill and turning a (gentle) corner.

With "V-LSD", are you referring to a viscous-type LSD? Because I was under the impression that these were an option on the GTS-T, and are quite rare? They are apparently the same type of diff as used in the GTR. So that would mean that I should have the more common, and theoretically, more secure, clutch-type LSD?

Anyway, is there any way to check to see if my diff is stuffed? I mean, a proper, controlled test, not just one where I go to the nearest corner, stomp on the accelerator and see if I still have drive? Well, the answer to that last part is "yes", I can still feel drive going to the tyre with the lesser grip, but whether the amount of torque being transferred is how much it's supposed to be, I don't know. This is what I want to find out. And if my LSD is stuffed, how much am I looking at to get it fixed or replaced?

Yep, he offered me an "excellent price". I had no idea of their going price, but I was planning to buy some performance Bridgestones (can't remember which but I think they'd just placed highly in a Wheels or Motor tyre test) and these Nexens were close to half price. He told me stories of how previous customers had also come in wanting to buy expensive tyres but had supposedly taken his advice and bought the Nexens, even with a money-back guarantee, and he'd only heard good feedback from them. I wasn't overly keen on spending $1000+ on tyres at the time, so I went with the ~$550 Nexens. Guess I'll know what to say next time eh?

I think its quite obvious how much respect I have for salespeople, especially commission-based ones, so I won't go into a massive rant.

"Good customer feedback" without some kind of auditable paper trail means about as much as "new and improved taste" or "if you only see one movie this year....."

tis the tyres for sure.

the stockies have shit tyres on em ( i killed the other ones, and couldnt be f**ked spending heaps on tyres for the gay stockies so meh ).

hence why i try to avoid driving if its heavy rain... coz i tend to go nowhere fast except sideways or wheelspinning. :D

With "V-LSD", are you referring to a viscous-type LSD? Because I was under the impression that these were an option on the GTS-T, and are quite rare? They are apparently the same type of diff as used in the GTR. So that would mean that I should have the more common, and theoretically, more secure, clutch-type LSD?

yes, viscous. they are standard on GTS-t models, active LSD (A-LSD) was an option on them - it is a computer controlled clutch type diff and you will have a dash light inside your tacho if you have it. Unless someone has replaced the diff in your car then there's a 95% chance you have a viscous LSD in it.

The GTR has a mechanical (clutch type) rear diff, that much I am certain of. I'm not sure about the front diff.

driving a powerfull car in the wet with a light rear end is absolutely dangerous if your a fool like me and stab the throttle everywhere... Wheelspinning in 4th is pretty bad. So just take it easy in the wet and drive slow.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • My thing I'd be doing, is pulling it out, and just getting the tune cleaned up for now. Before that even happens, checking over everything, like vac hoses, fuel hoses, etc. No point dropping thousands on sensors if the moment you start it back up all the oil leaks out, or it has massive vacuum leaks etc.   But really, to know what to do, depends on what your use case is. Hard core track car? Throw most sensors available at it. Street car, I'd probably just run oil pressure, oil temps, water pressure, water temp, probably fuel pressure too. I don't know exactly what the Link can handle and do with those though. And if it's mainly just to cruise the streets, rather than mountain runs, you can probably skip most of the above if you've already got them in as gauges and warning lights.   PS, inb4 "sell it and buy a modern sportscar"
    • Keen to see the turbosmart data, to date I've only seen negative things in terms of response for them. Very small sample size though.     Hawkins is a big advocate in his videos of the larger rear housings. I managed to make similar power with a lower spec motor on the smaller .8 rear, keeping decentish spool.  The people he works with now are big power cars compared to mine though, mine really is setup to drive around and enjoy.  I don't have any back pressure monitoring though, so couldn't say if its good or bad on my car, just that it does what I want it to do.   Future I want a higher compression more cubes motor to give a bit more bottom end and hopefully the new g35-1150 gets me to the 850 rear comfortably.  But maybe I won't due to exhaust back pressure.
    • No, I refuse to buy their cheap ass crap! I do need to order a bunch of different nuts/bolts to refill my nut/bolt wall though. Maybe you could go for a walk through Bunnings for me? (Or send me some stuff from your work? )   I really struggle to work out how the US standardised to Metric in what the 70s or 80s, and yet, half a century later, there's been little done to actually bring it into fruition. It truly baffles me    On the whole Fastenal thing, I went reading their site (My god they sell a lot of varied stuff!), and it seems like it really depends what store you're near if you can walk in and just grab a few small things, or if that branch is primarily distribution with only a small window of "counter time" available (if at all). That definitely makes it harder, as move locations and it drastically changes your ability for success   For things like your M6x1.0, if you want to work on your own Skyline, and you also have a "home workshop" I'd recommend setting yourself up a small Nut/Bolt wall/section. It doesn't even need to be big at all. Most things depending on the diameter, will be a specific pitch, like the M6x1, M5x0.7 etc. Bigger bolts is mostly 1.5, except for a small number of things and that will come down to torque. From memory bolts for the brake calipers (and other things that need a lot of torque) will end up being a 1.25mm pitch. Save up a few dollars, and order a range of nuts/bolts. If you want to minimise cost a little, buy something like M6 x 40, and M6x70mm (1mm pitch) in both. In addition, buy yourself an M6x1mm thread chaser. That way you have long bolts that you can cut down to size, and then chase the threads out. Funnily enough, I find what I'd pay here for ordering 5 bolts, I can pay about 50% more and you'll get 100 of them.   If that doesn't quite work out due to space / ability to buy plenty up front, then each time you need some bolts, order 100 of what ever you're getting. Put them in clearly marked containers. Over a few years, you'll acquire plenty of different sizes, and will end up ordering less and less. And the cost for 100 bolts won't be much more than you paid for your 5 you needed to order anyway  Just takes a little planning ahead, by investigating what nuts/bolts you'll need, and ordering them before doing the job.     Edit: If it's also primarily for working on just the Skyline, for some reason my brain is screaming that at some point, either Nissan, Nismo, (Or possibly a third party) was selling a "kit" of every nut and bolt in a Skyline, purely for people restoring/rebuilding. It'd likely be quite expensive, but would give you every/any nut/bolt you need for stock/factory things. I'm not sure if it's still available, or even if it actually fully came to market, it's just something niggling in the back of my brain that you could look into further if that sort of thing interested you? (It might have been for the R32 GTR or something specifically too, and not just any Skyline)
    • 90lb/min @ 20psi is wonderful, not so much of a problem with the G35-1050's compressor efficiency (aside from how bad they roll back at higher pressure ratios).  The issue is more to do with the turbine's flow, which is why I'm not sold on going an even higher flowing compressor with the same turbine.  I'd say go back over Motive DVD's testing of the G35 1050 and Hawkins's comments regarding exhaust back pressure issues with it, I'd need to go back but I have in my head he went to the biggest hotside and ended up sacrificing a lot of spool (so it ended up behaving like a bigger turbo) and still had EMAP issues.  I've heard various other experiences along the lines of that. At this stage at least I rate all I've seen about Xonas (for transparency I've not used one directly, but I have spoke plenty with people who have) to have low exhaust restriction for the response they offer for any given setup - basically they allow the engine to breathe, which is good for the engine and makes making power a lot easier.  You arguably don't have to even push quite the same amount of airflow through an engine to make the same power if you don't have the bum plugged up with exhaust gas struggling to escape the engine due to an underflowing turbine.   In terms of reliability, to be fair I've had great luck with Garrett turbos as well - my GT3076R lasted forever, then I sold it and the next owner had no issues, then that car got sold and it was still going strong last I ever heard about it.  The trick is with the old GT-series turbos the compressors etc were no way near as efficient as what we have these days, it was almost hard to push them into severe overspeed situations without having a boost leak or something - and that is what often starts the failure situation.    In terms of your G35 I'm pretty sure you're running yours within sensible limits, something people with Xonas and Precision turbos aren't often so inclined to do.  The "compressor maps" are "Joe blogs ran 45psi through his 6466 so I can do the same" and built their setup to send it to the moon.  I've seen EMAP and compressor speed data where people have actually set that stuff up on Precisions and Xonas which have been run hard and the comp speed numbers are very very exciting at times - like I've seen 76mm Precisions run at rpm that you ideally shouldn't run a G35 1050 lol.   I know people who have run G-series Garretts hard and hard a failure, then replaced them with Pulsar turbos as a cheap "get it going" stop gap with the intent of doing a proper upgrade when THAT fails... and are still running the same thing.   Like anything, ymmv and it's not always to do with the quality or trustworthiness of said product. I've been provided with a bunch of compressor maps for Turbosmart turbos and will update my list based off that, they could prove to interesting reading and an interesting alternative as well.
    • Just cage it, call it a race car, and then fall in love with the chirp chirps through pit area!   Also, this is coming from someone with a completely locked diff...
×
×
  • Create New...