Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

I've got a rattling noise coming from the engine somewhere (seems to be low-down, not in the head) that disappears as the engine warms up. At first I thought it might be the cat, because I had a similar rattle in my Commodore and it was the cat, but that noise didn't go away when it got hot. I tried muffling the cat with a towel anyway just to make sure but that didn't make a difference.

It's hard to tell whether the noise is coming from the front or back, but my current theories one of the timing belt pulley bearings or maybe the clutch thrust bearing. I'm not sure if either of these noises would disappear with the engine warming up though. I don't think it's anything too far into the engine because it doesn't sound muffled by anything other than the firewall and bonnet.

Has anyone got any ideas?

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/17076-rattling-noise-when-cold/
Share on other sites

Have you got an A/M zorst?

I've got a similar rattle in mine, turns out it was just the bracket on my Apexi N1 rubbing against the factory rear exhaust mount.

I shift the rubber hangers around until the mounts have a bit of distance between them and it's fine for 4-5 weeks. Then it's time to move them again.

Yes, aftermarket exhaust. I guess that's possible, it might be something rattling on a flange and then as the metal heats up it kind of "seals" the gap so to speak. The noise isn't getting any worse (been this way for like 6 months now, maybe longer) so I'll get the workshop to take a look when I upgrade the dump pipe in a month or 2.

  • 9 months later...

Hi JimX,

Did you ever solve this problem? If so, what did you have to do to fix it?

Thanks Mate,

Brad.

I've got a rattling noise coming from the engine somewhere (seems to be low-down, not in the head) that disappears as the engine warms up. At first I thought it might be the cat, because I had a similar rattle in my Commodore and it was the cat, but that noise didn't go away when it got hot. I tried muffling the cat with a towel anyway just to make sure but that didn't make a difference.

It's hard to tell whether the noise is coming from the front or back, but my current theories one of the timing belt pulley bearings or maybe the clutch thrust bearing. I'm not sure if either of these noises would disappear with the engine warming up though. I don't think it's anything too far into the engine because it doesn't sound muffled by anything other than the firewall and bonnet.

Has anyone got any ideas?

Jeebus, NOW you're testing my memory. Let me think.... Oh yeah, I remember now. It was my wastegate (internal). The pivot was borked due to having been welded shut at some point by the previous owner and then cut open again. The result was that it was sticking and not closing all the way when cold and rattling. I got it repaired at Garrett for around $150 (I removed/replaced the turbo myself), after which the noise stopped and I also noticed a power increase because the wastegate could then shut more easily and properly.

I did have another rattle more recently, this was due to a blocked lifter. I spoke to a guy at Autobarn who also owns a Skyline, asked him if he heard of anyone having problems with Motul oil, which I had just switched to. He said no, but asked if it was my first sump full of Motul. I said yes, and he said to his co-worker "What happens on the first oil change with Motul?" The guy said that you get a lot of blow by and a really dirty exhaust, as the Motul cleans out the old crap that was in there because it's got a lot of detergent in it. That's exactly what happened so it wasn't really the Motul oil to blame.

The car's running fine now. I have switched to Fuchs for now, because it's also meant to be a "clean" oil like Motul and Mobil. Apparently Fuchs make a lot of synthetics for other companies too and they re-badge it. I'll try Motul again if I have any problems with Fuchs.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • There are certain tasks, like replacing head gaskets, where it is very much best to already know what you are doing, and if you are not already an expert, then the next best thing is to have an expert around to help it get done. Little annoying checks and steps that are easy to forget or not interpret the results of properly, etc etc. It is hard to convey that to someone as a lesson prior to taking on a job, because there can be a whole list of "if you see this then it means that", or "if this is what you find then you will need to do these other 4 steps first". All the little bits of knowledge around sealant choice (ie, sealant at all? or no sealant? sealant only in certain parts of the gasket? sealant for this type of gasket but not that type of gasket? etc etc) cleanliness checks and methods, surface straightness and finish checks and methods, etc etc, all combine to mean that people who have done many of the same type of job will struggle less to get a good result than someone who hasn't done it before. I've been around this stuff since forever. But I will still consult with my expert(s) before taking on the big stuff with higher risk profile.
    • Well if I end up having to do the head gasket I will certainly find the necessary tools and instructions before beginning... Let's hope it won't come around.   Definitely. Depends on the job but I think "if you want it done right, do it yourself" applies almost every time
    • Can you at least move to a location without so many ladders, black cats and mirrors precariously propped up ready to be knocked down? Or buy yourself a 1 ton bulker bag of salt to drag around with you. Just, you know, sling it over your shoulder?
    • Meh, what's the worst that can happen? If is is supposed to have a washer, and: the spring retainer seals reasonably well on the surface, maybe just allowing a little bleed of oil out, and the spring does not coil bind when compressed that little extra bit, then the end result will be slightly higher relief pressure setpoint, and no other noticeable effects.
    • Weirdly I see a flat washer on aftermarket pumps but as you said it doesn't seem like new OEM pumps have it. EPC doesn't break out the regulator as a separate component either. I'm guessing if the pump came that way it's safe to use as-is. 
×
×
  • Create New...