Jump to content
SAU Community

Rda Vs Dba Rotors

SimonR32
 Share

Recommended Posts

SimonR32 Grand Master

SimonR32

Posted
Posted

I'm looking at upgrading my R32 GTR brakes as they aren't handling the new power too well.

I'm going to get some good DOT5.1 fluid, braided lines and Ferrodo 2500 pads and I'm looking at upgrading the rotors.

My choices seem to be RDA slotted rotors or DBA 4000 series rotors. The RDA seem to be cheaper but I have not heard of their performance that much, while I have heard stories of the DBA's cracking under hard use.

The car is fairly quick and be used mainly for street use, but driven fairly hard and the street and the occasional track day (possbily at Wanaroo which is very hard on brakes).

What I'm looking for is value for money, in terms of both performance and wear resistance.

Let me know any thoughts.

Cheers

Simon

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/175635-rda-vs-dba-rotors/
Share on other sites
Roy Grand Master

Roy

Posted
Posted

If your having brake problems on your GTR, putting replacement rotors on will do very little. Stick with the pads and fluid and see how that goes. If your rotord are undersized and need replacing then i would personally just use the RDA because they are cheaper. Its unlikely that on the street you will pick any difference between a cheap rotor and more expensive. Especially since the 296mm rotors will do a good enough job, but as soon as you start to punt it hard at the track for more then a few laps. no 296mm rotor is going to do a great job

djr81 Grand Master

djr81

Posted
Posted (edited)
I'm looking at upgrading my R32 GTR brakes as they aren't handling the new power too well.

I'm going to get some good DOT5.1 fluid, braided lines and Ferrodo 2500 pads and I'm looking at upgrading the rotors.

My choices seem to be RDA slotted rotors or DBA 4000 series rotors. The RDA seem to be cheaper but I have not heard of their performance that much, while I have heard stories of the DBA's cracking under hard use.

The car is fairly quick and be used mainly for street use, but driven fairly hard and the street and the occasional track day (possbily at Wanaroo which is very hard on brakes).

What I'm looking for is value for money, in terms of both performance and wear resistance.

Let me know any thoughts.

Cheers

Simon

My thoughts:

You can get a set of RBA slotted rotors from the group buy at a fraction of the price of the DBA4000's from any normal outlet.

So irrespective of which may be slightly better (I have no reason to believe the DBA's to be superior simply because they crack from the stupid little return slots on the rotors) they cannot be sufficiently different to justify spending extra money on the DBA's.

:P

Oh and don't bother with DOT 5.1 nonsense. Find a bike shop that sells Motul RBF600 & spend $28 for 500ml. You will fade the DS2500's around Wanneroo long before you boil that stuff. Trust me I know from btter experience.

Edited by djr81
WRRR Rising Star

WRRR

Posted
Posted (edited)

RDA/DBA - Have a look at the Group Buys the RDA deal is pretty special and looking at the RDA rotors I bought they seem as good as DBA .

I would suggest if you are serious about pushing hard at Wanneroo for more than a few laps at a time you will be better off with a more race oriented pad than the DS2500. It is not that hard to change a set of pads over before hitting the track.

The 2500 are a good compromise for road/some track but won't take long term punishment like you are talking about. Loss of brakes at the end of the downhill is a "puckering" experience.

Edited by WRRR
djr81 Grand Master

djr81

Posted
Posted
how many laps did you get from ds2500's

with the power im making i'm thinking i wont last more than 3 or so haha

Well it depends on a lot of things - temperature on the day, how much hp you have, how heavy the car is, what tyres you are running, how aggressive you are under brakes, how much ducting you have, stone guards etc etc etc.

DS2500's will be fine for a three lap run, ie warm up three laps, cool down. Which is pretty standard for drive days & lap sprint events.

msnismo Grand Master

msnismo

Posted
Posted
WOW OUCH!!!

i just got a email from UAS for a quote for just caliper adaptors from 296 to 324mm, i think they must have liked the look of me because they tried to bend me over.

does anyone make them?!?

There is a place in Sydney where we got the brackets to mount R31 calipers & rotors to a hilux diff in a Datsun Sunny. Its called Craft Differentials... they might have something???? 02 9637 1973

Roy Grand Master

Roy

Posted
Posted
WOW OUCH!!!

i just got a email from UAS for a quote for just caliper adaptors from 296 to 324mm, i think they must have liked the look of me because they tried to bend me over.

does anyone make them?!?

LOL, sell your GTR calipers and rotors and buy my GTSt calipers with near new DBA 4000 rotors, rebuilt and HPC coated calipers and the 280 to 324mm adaptor. the 280-324mm adaptor is more robust then the 296 to 324mm adaptor, its simply a finction of hte meat afforded by the larger change in diameter

If you buy the adpators for less then $250 then they are a steal

alexk Collaborator

alexk

Posted
Posted

I use RDA rotros (group buy) with EBC redstuff pads, RBF600 fluid and braided lines for my R32 GTR. although i haven't taken it to a track, i do take it regularly to the mountains and i push it hard - especially on the down hill. No problems with the rotors so far and no fade.. now imagine if i had cooling ducts to each corner and suspension :rant:

Roy Grand Master

Roy

Posted
Posted

Yeh $365 seems like a fair whack of money until you consider that the billet they are made form has about 40% wastage. So thats material you have to pay for that isnt ended up beign used. Billet alloy isnt cheap to start with. Then you have time for setup and machining, then tapping threads etc.

So i have no idea how the $180 each is broken down. But consider a machine shop charges for programming and setup time. Then actual machining time. Then materials cost. Then high tensile caps. Dleiveyr between machine shop and seller. Then of course the bloke selling them wants to make a dollar. But thinking about it he isnt making a lot from them.

Anyway, they still work out good value as the 324mm rotor hangs in there a bit longer then the 296mm rotors

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share
Go to topic listing


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • cobo_11
      My BMW 335i

      By cobo_11 · Posted

      Noted. Have noticed BMW are more 'high maintenance' for sure. They've attracted my attention as I think the used car prices seem reasonable vs other options, and the extra quality overall vs a commodore / camry / corolla or similar of the same vintage is appealing, especially the interior, and they are more on the sporty side whereas the others mentioned can be more cruising or economical A-to-B only.
    • cobo_11
      My BMW 335i

      By cobo_11 · Posted

      Haha yeah I know, this is SAU after all, why are we talking about BMW's of all things!? I hear you on the 'don't have to worry about it' side of things. Having been fortunate enough to be have been able to buy a brand new motorbike or two...never really enjoyed them as much as I'd have liked as you worry so much about where you park it, will it get scratched, stolen, attempted theft, knocked over, etc...and yes dirty. Older less valuable bikes you can just go where you want and park it wherever and not really worry that much in comparison. And who cares if it gets dirty! Never owned a V8, and have had my eyes on VE / VF commodores for years but with their prices climbing so high, the M3 has come into focus more as prices are much closer than I've ever seen...is it a potential contender now?...of course need to factor in the S65 'maintenance' especially and like you said general M car 'tax'. One can dream anyway. But more on the reality front - did read the whole 330i thread as well and was a great read too, both threads enlightening as I've never even driven one of these cars! I do recall 330i didn't seem to have the same amount of issues for almost the same car (turbos and related differences notwithstanding)...perhaps down to getting it earlier in it's life so looked after better than the 335i? Perhaps so as your 130i has been good and quite similar, so finding a car that's been looked after well is the especially-crucial-BMW-first-step.
    • luke gtr
      So i brought a boat...

      By luke gtr · Posted

      Nice. Dont worry about the time of not running. My current skyline hasn't run since I bought it. About 8 years ago.
    • PranK
      My BMW 335i

      By PranK · Posted

      It's also worth noting that I am heavily and unconditionally biased. I've had a lot of cars including some GTRs a fair while ago. I love my BMW's now a lot. They make no sense a lot of the time and the guys on here remind me regularly that I could get something else that does what I want better and cheaper. If you're going to take on an older BMW it's definitely a commitment. If you bail on it early you'll lose money and also the ability for it to put a smile on your face. Stick with it and it just gets better.  f**k I should get into advertising.  
    • PranK
      My BMW 335i

      By PranK · Posted

      Careful with posts like that around here without the flame suit on @cobo_11! 😂😂 My 330i journal is on here too. That car was so good and super reliable. We still have a 130i in the family which is almost identical to the 330i and easier to find in manual. It has also been almost faultless over the 6 or so years in the family.  I used to want an M car a lot more than I do now but if I'm honest and without trying to sound like a wanker, I can get such good performance and handling out of my 335 without needing to worry about all the crap that goes along with M car ownership. I don't need to worry about my bearings or subframe issues or the cost of replacing brakes or suspension or whether it has been impeccably maintained. And I can leave it places and not get upset when it's always filthy.
×
×
  • Create New...