Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

Ok .. So lets run this past you all..

Ive read there is no point having a cat which flows more than your exhaust because it enters and it cant exit at the speed it flows through anyway. True for False?

Im looking at a X force cat.. about $180 from just jap. or a BATMBL high flow 5" wide body magic cat or whatever for $360..

The CFM difference is 150ish cfm but the cost is about $200 different, so how do I justify buying such a expensive cat.

- Yes im looking for an excuse to spend money. Ive heard x force are crap cats can anyone confirm?

Ive got a 3.5" Exhaust Kikomoto(best one avaliable), split dumps 3", and looking for the cat obviously, 4.5" Cannon..

Who can help?

Edited by DECIM8
Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/184806-cat-help/
Share on other sites

if you have a 3.5 inch exhaust, then the cat is probably going to be the biggest restriction. ie a high flowing cat wont be wasted on your setup.

my personal opinion on the xforce ceramic cheapie: i didnt like it. it seemed to cause turbulence or something. introduced crazy drone too, on my system anyway. i took it off.

Edited by Munkyb0y
Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/184806-cat-help/#findComment-3345182
Share on other sites

Thanks for your help, Maybe the Bos imports is better then. It is recommended alot so I guess its a viable option.

My cat at present is only 2.5" btw lol Looks quite funny looking at the pipe size difference.

I did do a search btw guys but no one actually gave any deffinative answers in the posts/threads I looked at.

I guess the tip is buy the expensive one :) What about a nismo or sard etc option?

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/184806-cat-help/#findComment-3345199
Share on other sites

If your looking for an excuse to spend money, then dont grab the X-Force one.

Grab one from BOS Imports or SMB

The SMB ones at least are known to go on some fairy quick rota's and if it can survive the exhaust temp of them, it will suit your civilized RB just fine. I see it as a do it once, done right thing.

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/184806-cat-help/#findComment-3346551
Share on other sites

But would the xforce be a waste of time on a mild power setup? It wouldn't reduce performance on a close to stock setup, right?

What power rating would the X be good up to??? I'm aiming for 200rwkW roughly. Would this cheaper option be bad for someone in my position?? Considering the rest of the exhaust was ur average just jap quality stuff too.

Edited by R338OY
Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/184806-cat-help/#findComment-3346568
Share on other sites

But would the xforce be a waste of time on a mild power setup? It wouldn't reduce performance on a close to stock setup, right?

What power rating would the X be good up to??? I'm aiming for 200rwkW roughly. Would this cheaper option be bad for someone in my position?? Considering the rest of the exhaust was ur average just jap quality stuff too.

even a stock cat will see you thru to 200kw, but is it performing as well as it can? remember, the cat will most likely be the limiting factor in your exhaust.

like i said, i'm sure there are many using the ceramic xforce without issue, but i personally didnt like it. when the guys on here told me to pay more for a better cat, i said pffft. now i'm getting a better cat lol.

dont mean to hi-jack, are the r32 and r33 cats interchangable? both original and after market?

yes they are interchangable.

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/184806-cat-help/#findComment-3347093
Share on other sites

I got 240rwkw out of a std [well ADR] cat.

I got a BOS, looked at the Metal Cat, but they were approx. $150 dearer. Plus BOS have a very good flow rate. Metal Cat brag that they are all stainless, not sure if BOS are, but probably still last a long time.

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/184806-cat-help/#findComment-3347338
Share on other sites

just some more info for you

i fitted a nice highflow stainless internal cat yesterday.

its 50,000 times better than the xforce highflow ceramic.

seriously, more response, more power everwhere. although i did get a retune and new dump.

but my tuner agreed, the cat made a big difference.

Edited by Munkyb0y
Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/184806-cat-help/#findComment-3367064
Share on other sites

speaking of cats. Has anyone tried the apexi hi flow cat advertised on nengun.com?? I've gone through 3 metal cats (or cheap chinese rip offs with badge on it) and am looking for different brands.

if you're talking about the catco metalcat, i'm not surpirsed. have heard bad things about them, and have seen 2 with melted internals recently.

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/184806-cat-help/#findComment-3368509
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • Well, I'm tired. I'm tired because about 4PM yesterday, before today's appointment someone immediately bought my bumper. They couldn't get it any other day as they're on the way back to NSW. So I had to do that big GTR conversion I had been planning. Unfortunately, the information on SAU about what you need and how this is done is incomplete. So what should be a simple bolt on affair, yeah, it's not. Did you know if you use all GTR items the bonnet won't close? This little manuever sent me into about 1am the night before trying to dodge a way to get it closed. I will have to revisit this in the next few days  - or maybe not, I may let a body shop figure it out. It all needs to come up and my motivation to pull the bumper off is low. It also seems to hit things in the bay where the GTT bonnet didn't. Yes I used 100% new OEM GTR items. Today, I had the joy of driving to the dyno looking like this: Given I had roughed in the fuel and given sensible but pretty conservative timing, I didn't really bet on having the car drive out any real difference than when it drove in. Sadly due to a miscommunication and laptop fun and games (and almost bricking the dongle, prayers and firmware updates indeed), I ended up using HP Tuner credits to licence the car that was already licenced. So in the end my laptop was used. It turns out my butt dyno is still well calibrated after all this time. The 325kw was on 74% Ethanol, the 313kw line was on 98. The other line is the 'before' line which was 281kw. While the numbers are pretty low, they're pretty in line with what you'd expect. Even if US dynos bump the whole result up about 50KW, gaining 10-15% is similar gains.  The curve of the cam is pretty much spot on with what was discussed as well. All this said, it still feels bad to not see the number you secretly want to see. Even if the car drove great beforehand, and I knew pretty confidently the car would drive out much the same way it drove in due to the nature of a wellish dialled in LS1 not gaining much if anything at all from being tuned from where it was. As expected, the car isn't particularly sensitive to running it at anywhere between 12.0 and 13.0 - And the initial timing at 20deg and 12.0 made 308KW. So 3 degrees of timing, and leaning it out to 12.7 for 5kw, anything above stopped giving any benefit until E85 (which has an additional 2 deg as before). Car itself behaved entirely fine. I found out that 100C = 1.15V! IAT at about 7pm was 19C. I might mess with the bonnet mounting.. but given the REO NEEDS TO BE CHOPPED TO FIT A GTR BAR this is possibly something I may leave gathering (more) dust until it returns to paint jail.
    • It sounds farrrrrrr too cold at your place Duncan... Here I was thinking our 10 degrees overnight is getting cold...
    • oh yeah, reminded this morning....bin lids frozen shut too
    • In my case not, because of total reno. But yeah.
    • Did you use an electronic speedo drive? Does you speedometer read all the way to 180km?
×
×
  • Create New...