Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

Oh o.

I have just put DBA 4000's on the front and rear with Hawk HT-10's front and rear. Might have to keep an eye on them. They cooked the fluid fisrst time at the track but thats my fault for not flushing and changing the fluid with some good stuff. So what does the paint on the rotor tell me. So the set up is a R32 GTSt with UAS adapter plate to run DBA 4000 GTR rotors with Hawk pads.

Cheers

  • Replies 177
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted Images

Gary from what I've seen the difference is simple.

slotted DBA 4000 crack.

unslotted 4000 and any 5000 series seem to be OK, I'm sure there are differences in design that is making the difference. there have been waaaay too many slotted 4000s crack in the last 18 months to be coincidence and dba are doing their business real damage in the enthusiast market by ignoring and denying the problem.

Interesting read.

I'm in the process of upgrading my brakes and was thinking, RDA or DBA slotted rotors front and rear, QFM KR750 pads, and braided lines all round.

Now having read all of this it sounds like thats a bad idea as they're just going to crack....So my question is, what options are available to me? Doesn't seem to be many...

Car is a S2 R33 GTS-T, 250~rwkw, daily driven so need a pad that will work on the street as well as take some track work.

  • 4 weeks later...
they claim they are 'heat treated' I'll give them some fking heat treating. my next set will be project mu or endless. I have a new set of RDA sitting here and will give them a crack but I'm not putting too much hope out there.

+1 for endless, running their slotted disc with my ap's and they love the abuse :down:

Gary from what I've seen the difference is simple.

slotted DBA 4000 crack.

unslotted 4000 and any 5000 series seem to be OK, I'm sure there are differences in design that is making the difference. there have been waaaay too many slotted 4000s crack in the last 18 months to be coincidence and dba are doing their business real damage in the enthusiast market by ignoring and denying the problem.

You could be right, I am still using the 4000 series rear rotors that are at least 3 years old, compared to the third set of front rotors but they are 5000 series. Maybe the newer 4000's are the problem.

Cheers

Gary

  • 3 weeks later...
Ok I recently became a victim of the dreaded cracked DBA 4000 rotor club. Wasn't overly impressed as they were near new. But with the rotors on the bench and inspecting the rotors with DBA it appears as though there could be a fault with the caliper and the use of the rotor…combined with the fact they were used for a hard stop from over 200km/h when cold at an airport run.

So looking at the rotor the outside face (the side that cracked) has obviously run hotter then the inside face. This is evident by the blue hue in the rotor face as well as the paint markings on the outside of the rotor where two of the three thermal paint stripes have been completely burnt off. All whilst the inside face is only on the middle temp paint with all three stripes still being visible and a shiny silver as you would expect.

So, differential expansion as a result of a big temperature gradient hasn't helped these rotors. Combined with the big hit of heat when cold. The rotors are off for some more testing and inspection. Will post up the feedback when I get it.

But some things we all may want to check. Make sure your pistons are not dragging the pads on the rotor. This is a possibility in my application even though the calipers have been rebuilt. Perhaps where was a bit if run out (doubt it) or the design of thw wheel limits airflow to the outer face (doubt it) Most likely pistons rubbing the pad on the rotor a little, or when I jump on the brakes the outer pad works a lot harder then the inner pistons.

Now finally, especially since its been a buzz topic lately. Be careful if you are going to be running brake ducts. I trialled some ages ago but took them off because I was not happy with them, and decided I would wait and do it properly when i get my new Brembos on. But if you are running DIY ducting ensure that the ducting is directed the centre of the rotor and the air then travels up through the vanes of the rotor. Simply ducting it towards the inner edge could lead to one side of the rotor (inner) running cooler then the outer face. This gives rise to differential expansion which is a known problem for stressing steel components. The main reason I removed my ducts was that I wasn't satisfied that in the wet they woudlnt be guiding water/mist onto the inner edge causing massive temperature differentials and thermal shock to the rotor. I had not really considered that air itself could have resulted in a 200degC temperature differential across the rotor.

Hi,

I've been reading all these posts with great interest up to page 4-5.

I'm due for front rotors soon and yes, learning along the way, I've decided to go for G4 or DBA5000 where the slots don't go up to the edge

Two Reasons

1) Being a chemist, I've noticed that tablets that are scored (ie slotted) across the middle are harder to break if the score doesn't reach the edge and

2) Having cut glass for leadlight many times, it's much easier to break the glass if I start the glasscutter from right over the burr of the edge - meaning it's hard to snap the glass panel unless I start from right at the edge.

Therefore the newer DBA4000 rotors are simply a very bad design - and they'll need to change it quick.

As they say in business: it takes 10 years to build up trust - and 10 minutes to lose it!!!

Chow

Hi,

I've been reading all these posts with great interest up to page 4-5.

I'm due for front rotors soon and yes, learning along the way, I've decided to go for G4 or DBA5000 where the slots don't go up to the edge

Two Reasons

1) Being a chemist, I've noticed that tablets that are scored (ie slotted) across the middle are harder to break if the score doesn't reach the edge and

2) Having cut glass for leadlight many times, it's much easier to break the glass if I start the glasscutter from right over the burr of the edge - meaning it's hard to snap the glass panel unless I start from right at the edge.

Therefore the newer DBA4000 rotors are simply a very bad design - and they'll need to change it quick.

As they say in business: it takes 10 years to build up trust - and 10 minutes to lose it!!!

Chow

It's catch 22 with slots. If you don't take them to the edge, then they simply don't work as well in their wiping function. The trapped gas and loose material can't escape the slot, so it builds up under the outermost portion of the pad (the outer end of the slot). This decreases the braking performance and causes uneven pad wear.

Cheers

Gary

It's catch 22 with slots. If you don't take them to the edge, then they simply don't work as well in their wiping function. The trapped gas and loose material can't escape the slot, so it builds up under the outermost portion of the pad (the outer end of the slot). This decreases the braking performance and causes uneven pad wear.

Cheers

Gary

The G4 kit doesnt take the pad all the way to the edge, so it should avoid that problem. Also the radial direction of the DBA4000 slot seems to contribute to the stress build up. On other designs the slots are about 45 degrees to the tangent, rather than being almost 90 degrees.

Hi,

Just got a price on getting some blank DBA heat treated rotors (4000's????) and getting SCBC to machine some wiper slots in them more like the project mu's for $630.00 a pair to suit the front 324mm brembos.

Do you think these will have a greater chance of not cracking or is the cast metal just not up to the task of hard braking?

Cheers,

Ryan

Hi,

Just got a price on getting some blank DBA heat treated rotors (4000's????) and getting SCBC to machine some wiper slots in them more like the project mu's for $630.00 a pair to suit the front 324mm brembos.

Do you think these will have a greater chance of not cracking or is the cast metal just not up to the task of hard braking?

Cheers,

Ryan

Well to be perfectly honest for the amount of messing about & the cost - why don't you just import some Project Mu rotors & be done with it?

As has been said it is not believed to be a metallurgical problem moreso a problem derived from the use of the small return slots around the outer circumference of the rotor.

Well that is some good news. The Stoptech gear certainly move some air through the rotors.

Not exactly light weight, however.

But the big question is: How much?

The one disappointment of the Priject Mu 2 piece was the lack of proper vanes, although they are better in that regard that the DBA gear.

I can add my same experiences to this thread too.

I cracked 2 sets of 296 Dba's before I went to 324mm on the front of my 32GTR.

I have now cracked my second set of 324s. After cracking the first set, I ran ducting to the centre of the disks, and still cracked the disks.

So.... DJR81 like you I'm swaying towards the Project Mu's. How have you found them ?

And more importantly have you run them at barbagello more than once ? I can get a year of sprints out of a set of disks, but as soon as i take them to a long circuit where braking from a high speed is involved, they crack, (from the slots in the 4000's.)

Stoptechs are a second thought, but they seem to be about twice the price ?

The most annoying thing is, that if i had not given dba the benefit of the doubt I could have saved a lot of money or upgraded seriously with the same dollar amounts i have wasted.

Anyone else using Project Mu's ?? or will i crack them too ?

Got some advise regarding cracking/crazing rotors from a brake joint in Penrith.

He said that cryogenically treating them makes them less likely to go to crap out, but it doesn't make them last longer.

Might try it out on the next set of rotors.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now



  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • What is the current snail?
    • Never an issue with boost control. No weird boost issues pre throttle at partial throttle like you're suggesting. It worked.   As for all the turbo damage claims, they all were started by aftermarket BOV companies. At least turbo timer companies had SOME truth about them, except people failed to realise that except for in extreme circumstances, that small amount of driving you do to park/ through pit lane etc, is enough to not have a need for a turbo timer.
    • I tell people all the time this stuff runs on a 2 MHz 8-bit MCU. The math is a bit arcane, they do a lot to get around their limited resolution and so on but it works great as-shipped. So if an 80 to 160 MHz modern 32-bit MCU can't make it work you've really screwed something up badly. Your average graphing calculator is faster these days, god forbid we start talking about what's hiding in vapes or some stupid internet-connected "smart appliance".  I suspect the lore about off-throttle surge damaging turbos must be very, very old if it was ever true. I still don't think off throttle surge is good for turbos because you're rapidly having air going in and out of the turbo on top of rapid loss in shaft speed which presumably does impart some kind of unusual load on the rotating assembly. As for the recirculating valve, I believe Nissan actually in a press slide deck of some kind explained for the RZ34 they found it improved response. Prior to that they kept the throttle cracked open instead which causes rev hang and because the throttle/engine is a substantial restriction a ton of the energy in the air stream is lost just to pumping past it. Recirculating helps reduce energy loss by bringing the intake side of the compressor up in pressure so it's not working as hard to pull air in. In DCT cars where they can slam gears I believe Porsche hangs the throttle wide open with no fuel injection to keep turbo RPMs as high as possible during the shift. As for running post-throttle boost source, I would be concerned that at partial throttle on boost you would have driveability issues. It would be constantly trying to run crazy amounts of boost before the throttle to compensate for the throttling effect. Maybe with a much more sophisticated boost control setup you could activate a solenoid that goes from a conventional 3-port setup to something that allows the wastegates to see full vacuum in that specific case? 
    • Did you clean everything out? Take all intercooler piping off, empty the intercooler of oil, clean the exhaust out, etc? Intercoolers make great catch cans... Which makes them less useful for intercooling... But very worth cleaning out, along with all adjoining piping.
    • Update Got turbo back from hypergear, installed everything etc. Bled coolant, wasn't smoking so I thought beauty she's sorted now. Went on a drive, car up to temp, let it idle for about 15 seconds, gave it some gas...nice puff of smoke again. Fml No doubt my turbo was pretty worn anyway but nonetheless frustrating that the problem persists.
×
×
  • Create New...