Jump to content
SAU Community

Loud Tapping Noise From Top Of Engine - Diagnosed!

PHATR32

By PHATR32,
in Engines & Forced Induction

 Share

Recommended Posts

PHATR32 Grand Master

PHATR32

Posted
Posted (edited)

hey guys,

I pulled into the petrol station today to fill up (after a 80k freeway drive, mostly doing 110kph), and was about to shut the engine off.

It suddenly started making a real loud knocking/banging noise, and idling rough. It sounds like the noise is coming from the top of the engine, but i can feel it through the clutch pedal.

The things ive checked so far are the oil and coolant, which are in perfect condition.

The spark plugs are in mint condition.

I had a look at the pistons with torch and they look excelent too

I pulled the cam cover off the intake side(which is where the noise sounds like its coming from) and everything looked to be in order.

the only mods i have are a pair of pods, and a cam gear. car is driven daily, but not thrashed daily (although it copped a fair bit saturday). Oil changed every 6000ish k's, and its always run on ultimate 98. Its never caused any problems in the 2 years ive had it.

When you crank the engine it doesnt make the noise, only when it fires up.

im thinking the timing belt has slipped a tooth, the cam gear has loosend, or there is some serious bottom end bearing damage.

I know its hard diagnose problems over the web, but any ideas would be great.

thanks heaps,

steve

Edited by PHATR32
GeeTR Grand Master

GeeTR

Posted
Posted

Big guess to say it's slipped a tooth. How olds the belt in it?

I wouldnt think a big end knock (bearing issue) would cause it do idle funny...

Could be the other way around. If the cars missing (usual AFM, AAC etc) the piston can do funny things when it goes over TDC and doesn't fire. It can knock about... thats possibly what your hearing.

Sorry I'm no real help, just some thought :)

dead32 Mentor

dead32

Posted
Posted

try and issolate a cylinder if possible. depends how harsh the noice is, wouldnt wana cause any more damge. however by issolating the cylinder your in the general direction. could be a collapsed lifter?

Ryanrb25 Grand Master

Ryanrb25

Posted
Posted

they actually have solid lifters and naturally have fairly loud heads.

My mates GTR had simular noise, sounded like it was in the top of the head etc etc etc, turned out to be a bottom end bearing spun. worst case scenario and for your sake i hope its not.

PHATR32 Grand Master

PHATR32

Posted
  • Author
Posted

well i took off the cam cover from the other side (exhaust) and it looks fine, also the timing belt is fine and the markings are exact. the adjustable cam gear also hasnt moved from 0.

i turned the engine over a few times by hand and found it gets stuck when cylinders 3 and 4 are at TDC (or there abouts).

it will turn over bout 2 or 3 times and id feel slight hesiation (cyl 3 and 4 TDC) then on the next turn it would get stuck to the point where id have to give it a bit of force to keep it turning.

Ive checked the belt incase theres a rock or something in one of the teeth but i found nothing.

the tapping noise is REALLY loud btw, but i havnt reved it over 1k, only idled it for a few seconds.

steve

Scottydoo Community Regular

Scottydoo

Posted
Posted (edited)

Im very new to skylines and this is probably wrong but thought i'd throw it out there for the hell of it

My brothers r32 (rb20) started making a really loud tapping/knocking noise a couple of days ago, would rise with revs and sounded like it was from one of the front cylinders. It actually turned out to be the clutch on the fan had given up and was making the racket. Its easy enough to test cause you can just slip the belt off and see if the noise goes.

My 2c worth

*Edit* After reading your latest post, probably not what im suggesting...

Edited by Scottydoo
PHATR32 Grand Master

PHATR32

Posted
  • Author
Posted (edited)

lol, i got shit in my wallet......

when i push the clutch in it still makes the noise, that said, i could definetly feel the banging through the clutch.

although, the clutch wouldnt screw up exactly when pistons 3 and 4 are TDC.

i do all the work my self, of course if the engine requires rebuilding ill have to get a pro to do it as i dont want to risk screwing it up etc.

ill do a compression test tonight to see if itll show anything?

steve

Edited by PHATR32
PHATR32 Grand Master

PHATR32

Posted
  • Author
Posted (edited)

hey guys,

i just ran a cold compression test and all cylinders were between 135psi - 140psi except for cylinder 3 which is at 45psi!

as mensioned above when i turned the crank by hand it would get stuck when cyls 3 and 4 would hit TDC.

so i pulled the cams off and took off the lifters on cylinder 3. it all looks ok, and the valves move in when i apply force. How can i tell if a valve guide has dropped?

im gonna have to pull the engine out either ways but would anyone have any idea on what could be causing the banging and low compression?

thanks guys,

steve

Edited by PHATR32
  • 2 weeks later...
PHATR32 Grand Master

PHATR32

Posted
  • Author
Posted

well, ive been pull the engine bay apart these past few afternoons, and found the pipe that controlls the wastegate actuators had come undone!!

weird thing is i hadnt noticed any increase in boost?? that said, i do have a stock exhaust.....

engine will be out and apart this weekend hopefully.......

giant Mentor

giant

Posted
Posted

i would put money on a spun big end bearing!

i know that sound well, sorry to hear that.

most the time when a big end bearing starts to go , it sounds like it's coming from the top.

russ

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share
Go to topic listing


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • EndZee
      Weird compression after rebuild

      By EndZee · Posted

      I can also smell fuel in oil if that helps. 
    • EndZee
      Weird compression after rebuild

      By EndZee · Posted

      Hello, after engine rebuild(new cylinder liners and piston rings, arp headstuds, metal cometic tripple layer gasket, all new main/rod bearings) and roughly 100km made I did measure compression and it’s (1-6) - 80, 60, 90, 120, 110, 135. It’s rb25det series 1 - hydraulic lifters. Measured on cold engine. Didn’t check on hot due to overall car problems such as broken 3rd gear, idle issues, misfire etc. I did smoke test only on 2nd and 5th cylinder bcs soldering iron used with this method broke itself. So after setting cams to side - side 90 left/right angle I can see smoke coming off from intake manifold and turbo exhaust flange. 5th didn’t notice any smoke. Shop did head, valve etc job but I assemble it by myself. So I thinking about lifters. I don’t remember if they were soft or not it was long time ago. In my opinion I didn’t bleed them and they can be opened more than they should be. Can it be more likely possible? Or timing can be off by 1 teeth and can cause such weird compression? But if timing would be out wouldn’t it be like such big difference across all cylinders? Please help I’m so sad it happened. 
    • sunsetR33
      newbie attempts the GTR life.

      By sunsetR33 · Posted

      Hey, yeah I really like the color. Only paint I'd rather have is KN6, but those are expensive. Right now I'm trying to get the car to the point where I can get it tuned to 370hp so the whole setup can be driven legally, and pass the next inspection that is already due anyway. Beyond that lots of rust fixing I'm afraid, winter project is most likely going to be a front end teardown and fixing the strut tower rust. I know these can be driven daily but I don't think I will do so anytime soon. Will post a build thread soon with a list of issues and futute plans.   Cheers
    • codygrimm27
      Attesa pump mount options / ideas? R32 gtr style.

      By codygrimm27 · Posted

      Wanted to reply to this topic. I'm in the somewhat same boat with our Stagea. I'm trying to install a different rear diff. The Stagea/Skyline uses mounts on top of the rear diff for the ATTESA pump. Any way you can relocate the pump? I did find this kit https://theskylineshed.com/products/nissan-oem-attesa-mounting-kit-to-suit-r32-r33-r34
    • codygrimm27
      Can you mount the ATTESA pump in other locations?

      By codygrimm27 · Posted

      So here's the deal, my wife picked up an S2 AWD Stagea. Super cool, clean car. Looks like the owner in Japan went track spec as it's got some heavy modifications including Exedy twin disk, tension rods, coilovers, GTR brakes, oil cooler & a Nismo 2 way rear diff. Now, cool mods for sure. But, she is just using this as a casual daily driver. The 2 way rear is AGGRESSIVE. It also has solid subframe bushings & poly diff bushings. So that doesn't help either. So far I've tried changing the diff fluid to the correct fluid. Even tried a little friction modifier. No help. This thing clunks, skips the tires & has some slight whine/NVH when driving. Might sound like I'm being picky, but just trying to find a better solution. Here in the states, it's impossible to find a Stagea rear diff. No luck. I do have a 300zx non-turbo diff. Same ratio, 5 bolt axles. On the Stagea, you need both front & rear diff ratios to match. This car is a 4.083. I'd like to just swap a normal rear diff into this thing. Nothing fancy. Even open diff is fine. She's not tracking the car LOL The difference is that the ATTESA pump mounts to the top of the rear diff. There are 3 total mounting points for the pump on top of the diff. With all this being said, what would be the best way to go about this? I could remove the Stagea diff & see if I could get somebody to possibly weld the 3 tabs/mounting points onto the 300zx diff so we could mount the pump on the 300zx diff. I could swap the internals from the 300zx into the Stagea diff but this is not in my comfort zone. Is it possible to mount the ATTESA pump to the underside of the car? Sorry for the paragraph. Just trying to figure out how to go about this. Any help is much appreciated! Stagea Differential - Note two top tabs, one bolt hole for ATTESA pump mounting   300zx Diff - No mounting tabs Also found this mounting kit ?? https://theskylineshed.com/products/nissan-oem-attesa-mounting-kit-to-suit-r32-r33-r34  
×
×
  • Create New...