Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

Hows it going guys, long time lurker decided to make an account..

Just under 2 weeks ago i got a new excedy twin plate pull-type put into my car (93 BNR32) I also got new transmission & transfer case fluid's. I asked my mech to put in redline, but due to the un-availability of it he put in a motul oil. The first night i picked up the car the clutch was quite noisy when cold and got a bit better when warm, i also found that 2nd gear was crunching and so was 4th (4th used to only crunch when driven hard and changed into at over 80). I also found that the car off the line would really struggle to move unless i rode the clutch a bit (1200-1400rpm) ... I rang my mech in search of answers, he told me that it was a new clutch and that once the necessary 500km's are driven to wear it in, it should all level itself out..

Week and a bit has past and i travelled the 500km, last night i took it for a quick spin.... I then decided to give it a quick squirt 1st into 2nd.. i noticed that it was terribly rough and could feel 3 very quick gear box shudders before it took of in 2nd, i tried it again and the same thing happened. I then decided to shift slower and much more deliberately into 2nd and it worked fine...

Today i took it for another drive to the shops, no hard driving.. and noticed on start up the knock went to 18... i've never had knock go over 1 on start up before... It was also a pain in the ass to start moving from stationary and was making all kinds of noises.

So atm just waiting for my mech to open again so i can give him a call..

I have a feeling that somehow the box was not put back in properly or the clutch isn't balanced... pretty new to all this, but i do remember the mech telling me he hadn't done a pull type clutch in quite some time, i have a sneaky suspision that it may have been a rush job.... Car was in the shops for 2 weeks, Majority of that time was waiting for late parts... Most of the work was carried out in 1 day, so i dunno..

Anyone have ideas on what could be wrong and what would be the best way to approach my mech about all this?

merry chrismas

Edited by pytanie

Nothing is wrong with knock hitting 18 on start up.

What motul gearbox oil did he put in? Mineral junk or the full synth Gear 300?

The gear 300 is excellent stuff and will not cause shift problems. The mineral HD motul stuff will.

Motul Gear 300 > Redline anyway. :thumbsup:

Not really.. I went from Valvoline semi-synth stuff to VMX80 with an improvement; then to Gear HD and it was horrid, worse than the very cheap valvoline semi-synth

Motul gear 300 ftw if you want good shift quality or simply run the cheap VMX80.

Not really.. I went from Valvoline semi-synth stuff to VMX80 with an improvement; then to Gear HD and it was horrid, worse than the very cheap valvoline semi-synth

Motul gear 300 ftw if you want good shift quality or simply run the cheap VMX80.

So what your saying is all my gearbox problems "could" be caused by the fluids im using?

wtf does knock have to do with a clutch?? twin plates are noisy.

ive installed trillions of the bastards and theyve all been noise.. thats how they are.. tripples r even worse and 4 r worse again.

as for ur crunching. definately sounds like wrong oils. 75-140 is way too thick for the box anyway. Factory recommends 80/90 which is what i use and i have no problems @ all..

change ur oils. as for shudders and vibrations before takin off?? wtf does that even mean.. when u accel, petrol goes in motor, explodes, makes engine move connects to flywheel wihch moves clutch hence moves car..

it wont vibrate a few times b4 moving.. its not a horse. you open throttle, it moves, unless theres something wrong with ur tune/engine. gearbox doesnt have anything to do with that.. all it does is transfers energy from engine to wheels.

where abouts are u from? i could give u a hand with it if ur in melb.

wtf does knock have to do with a clutch?? twin plates are noisy.

ive installed trillions of the bastards and theyve all been noise.. thats how they are.. tripples r even worse and 4 r worse again.

as for ur crunching. definately sounds like wrong oils. 75-140 is way too thick for the box anyway. Factory recommends 80/90 which is what i use and i have no problems @ all..

change ur oils. as for shudders and vibrations before takin off?? wtf does that even mean.. when u accel, petrol goes in motor, explodes, makes engine move connects to flywheel wihch moves clutch hence moves car..

it wont vibrate a few times b4 moving.. its not a horse. you open throttle, it moves, unless theres something wrong with ur tune/engine. gearbox doesnt have anything to do with that.. all it does is transfers energy from engine to wheels.

where abouts are u from? i could give u a hand with it if ur in melb.

I know there meant to be a harsher and noisier then standard..

Im glad it's just oils, thought i may have had something worse on my hands...

Disapointed that the mech put it in there with all the experience he's got with gtr's :)

Im from queensland mate... cheers

it wont vibrate a few times b4 moving.. its not a horse. you open throttle, it moves, unless theres something wrong with ur tune/engine. gearbox doesnt have anything to do with that.. all it does is transfers energy from engine to wheels.
I've noticed HD clutches require a slight change to driving style to get the car moving. I only fitted a HD single plate clutch. Before that, I'm pretty sure I could ease the clutch - no throttle - and the car would start moving. I now find I need to give some revs or the engine will stall.

So, try giving a few more revs before you start to engage the clutch, see if that solves the "shudder".

Not really.. I went from Valvoline semi-synth stuff to VMX80 with an improvement; then to Gear HD and it was horrid, worse than the very cheap valvoline semi-synth

Motul gear 300 ftw if you want good shift quality or simply run the cheap VMX80.

the last week i was the same problem to you men i have a skyline gtr r33 and i chance the oem clucth for to put a hks twin plate, and mi mechany put a oil in mi gear box motul ATF gear box the colors was red, when i was in the drag racing and i was running mi firts race the gear box transmission don't take the 1,2,3,4,5 speed i don;t know what happed, but i need to way like 1 hours for to move the car, later the car don't take the 3 and 4 gear the syncro was damage..!and right now was to need a buy a other transmission gear box here and mi country dominicain republic i have the only one gtr r33 , and i search a others transmission gear box but is for the gtr r32 i have a questions to you is the same a gtr r33..? i know there i need to chance the clutch because the gtr r32 early model is push type and mi car gear box gtr r33 is pull type i only wanna to know if is diferent... and what type of oil there really need to put in mi transmission gear box, right know a chance and i put the oil motul 75w90 gear box, and what type of oil used the DIFFERENTIAL is the same of gear box oil...? or is diferent thanks for all and help me about this problem........

Reset says

MOTUL GEAR 75 / 140 COMP GEARBOX

Hey hi i have a gtr r33 i put in mi gear box a motul 75w90 gear box mechany and in the differential a put this oil too ,is correct oil for both parts thanks i living in dominicain republic you know here is too much warn , thanks for all....

Motul Gear could be Gear HD the mineral junk.

Gear 300 is the only stuff you want. I've tried the Gear HD and it is Nooooooo good. Bulks on fasts shifts once warm also. :S

Hey hi i have a gtr r33 i put in mi gear box a motul 75w90 gear box mechany and in the differential a put this oil too ,is correct oil for both parts thanks i living in dominicain republic you know here is too much warn , thanks for all....

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • Given you already have the engine cross member to match and likely gearbox mount to. The SR20 has a head start on the RB in this case. They handle GREAT with an SR20, lots of fun.   One I did back in the day
    • have no doubt and wanted too trust me and may regret later not necessarily worried about weight (would be 8 kg ish total) it was more the $$ to do it properly is about $6 - $7K in hardwear need long 310mm stroke jacks etc - plus install and call me whatever im not doing it myself even if wanted too cant weld etc  - thats $10K installed vs fraction of that cost while Ive spent some money on this POS I actually really dont like doing so unless its got a large chance to make me go faster 😁 hey in still carting this things around on a 15 yr old rusted open trailer so I can spend on racing not buy a new trailer to look better the manual jacks Ive had done are heavy and take space but are transportable and usable anywhere - taking or organizing even compressed air let alone nitrogen which is more whats needed coming from Perth to Winton or Sydney or the like honestly just adds to my brain headaches/ hurts of organisation also ha 15 mins job will get down to 2 - 5 min job vs 1 min job for airjacks - all tradeoffs I spose
    • Purely out of curiosity, how do you know all this @dbm7? Do you work with automatic gearboxes professionally? This goes way way way beyond "I've had an automatic Skyline once and did some mucking around"
    • I'll just reiterate that it's best to do all the wiring diagnostics, before even thinking about buying replacement solenoids ~ that is, be absolutely sure the solenoid is bad.....ie; bad connector(s), rodents chewed through a wire, etc etc. If you don't so this, you can fork out all the money for solenoids, only to find something else is wrong (this'll make you cry if you pull the valvebody only to find a broken wire is at fault... ...some more glue on the solenoid packs -- this is the RE5R01A shift solenoid assembly.... ...these are all shift solenoids ~ ostensibly they're the same as the shift solenoids from the 4-speed auto.... ...this is the RE4R01A solenoid set... ...with these, you have 3 shift solenoids attached to the plate, and the separate solenoid is the EPC solenoid (line pressure control) -- with both designs, the TC lockup clutch solenoid (also PWM so they could slide the clutch shut), is located on the lower valvebody half.... ...(story time)...back in the 90's, it was a common fault that the EPC solenoid (or TC-lock solenoid) would fail, but Nissan only sold them as part of the assembly (think ~$350 at the time) ~ thing was, Isuzu also used these boxes in light commercials, and you could buy the PWM solenoid as a separate part, so it was possible to buy/use that solenoid (around $65), and make it fit (remove the circlip, fit to old plate and deal with wiring)...making it a more cost effective repair. I've not seen the RE5R01A shift solenoid assembly, but with the 4-speed RE4R01A it was possible to hack/fit a single shift solenoid onto an other working set, using a donor solenoid from another set with failed EPC....(by rights the whole set should be replaced), but it ends up being a question of how much life is left in the box itself ; sometimes it's a viable repair to fix one solenoid, just to get another 100k of road miles out of it before it needs first overhaul...other times the box is that old/worn, you're as well doing first overhaul and replacing the solenoids and starting fresh... What Nissan did here with the 5-speed, was relocate the EPC solenoid to the lower valvebody (next to the TC lockup solenoid), and stuck the direct-drive clutch solenoid (for the extra gear) where the EPC solenoid used to be on the 4-speed....I can only imagine they did this for serviceability ; the PWM solenoids are most likely to fail, and it's a doddle to drop the pan and change these out (as opposed to dropping the valvebody itself to get at a top mounted EPC)... ...also keep in mind, that some BMW 3/5 series & Mazda (and maybe some Ford/Mazda rebadges, not sure), also used the RE5R01A box under a different name/part number...not saying parts availability is any better, but sometimes it helps to know this when it comes to NOS floating about in the EU.... HTH  
    • FWIW, air jacks are actually pretty light and simple to add, they are just 4 hydraulic cylinders (often at the main cage A and C pillar points) and an externally accessible airline  - they make quick work a breeze
×
×
  • Create New...