Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

Just done a piston ring and was wondering what i was better off doing. i have sourced out a second hand engine for $1500 + 500 to put the thing in. Would that be better than rebuilding because i know rebuilds are very expensive and i also have the drama if there is a damaged block or valves, just a waste of time i think. correct me if im wrong.

Also can anyone tell me of there experences and how they got out of it. Where they went how much?. How much would a full rebuild with forgies,bored and balanced be.

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/205260-engine-rebuild-or-second-hand-motor/
Share on other sites

Id say do a rebuild.

You have the option of getting all the extras ie forgies etc etc and at the end of the day you know the engine is basically going to be new. Whereas buying secondhand... well its second hand. Guess it depends apon your budget etc too.

what comes with the second hand engine? you might be able to sell off leftovers to recoup money ie turbo/loom/head (always people wanting to go RB30DET) or was it 1500 for the bottom end only? (rip off if it is)

If you are going to get a rebuild done by someone else and do nothing yourself then you wont get any change out of 6 GRAND, now that is 3 second hand motors fitted. The other thing is the type of power you are (or planning to) make. If your car is mostly stock and going to stay that way then a rebuilt motor is going to be a waste of money. I was in the same boat about 4 years ago and went for a full rebuild with plans of a monster engine but it never happened and I sold the car with the motor in it and did not make any extra money out of it. So you have to be realistic about what you want to do in the future and use that as the basis for the new engine. I wish I had taken the cheap option as that would of given me more money to do some of the basic mods like computer and front mount and high flow instead I ended up having a car with a built motor and nothing to make it go fast.

All the best with the decisions.

Andrew

If you are going to get a rebuild done by someone else and do nothing yourself then you wont get any change out of 6 GRAND, now that is 3 second hand motors fitted. The other thing is the type of power you are (or planning to) make. If your car is mostly stock and going to stay that way then a rebuilt motor is going to be a waste of money. I was in the same boat about 4 years ago and went for a full rebuild with plans of a monster engine but it never happened and I sold the car with the motor in it and did not make any extra money out of it. So you have to be realistic about what you want to do in the future and use that as the basis for the new engine. I wish I had taken the cheap option as that would of given me more money to do some of the basic mods like computer and front mount and high flow instead I ended up having a car with a built motor and nothing to make it go fast.

All the best with the decisions.

Andrew

$6000 to rebuild a motor your f**king crazy.

R33747 pm me i have a number for you to get rebuild wont cost much at all

Edited by rich flavour

1500 for a complete motor minus loom and ecu . i have an afermarket turboand power fc that ill be using so i could sell the stock turbo here for a couple of hunderd bucks. Not bad considering how much a rebuild would cost. ive spoken to my mechanics i use a both said that the better option because stuff can go wrong with a rebuilds.

Also wondering how can i tell if a motor is in good condition. Can you do a comp test when the motor is out of the car? Ive got 5 to choose from but have do i decide which is the best one?

basically - the rebuild is a better option if you can afford it, and you are planning to keep the car long term.

but the difference between rebuild and second had is literally thousands $$$ so if you can't afford it just grab the second hand one.

I've done both - second hand into the road car and rebuild the race car. the second hand motor was fine.

Um im surprised noones susgested it yet but wouldn't u atleast pull old motor out pull the head off etc and inspect engine damage before writing the old engine off im sure a new set of pistons and getting the cylinder bored, 2nd hand gtr rods etc wouldnt cost a hell of alot more then 2nd hand motor and atleast u no if u looked after the old motor ur not getting another motor which has already doen some work as opposed to rebuilt orginal motor thats been looked after. But if the motors bad needs headwork etc to repair mayaswell throw it away.

thanks just my opnion Rory

2nd hand way cheaper. rebuild takes time and money. you cant say that rebuilt motors are always more reliable then 2nd hand. whats if the bloke building the motor does fantastic work but comes in 1 morning after a hard night and stuffs something without realizing it. bang goes the motor and ur back to square 1. it has happened before. you might get a crappy 2nd hand 1 as well. just gotta check out the motor before buying it if u go 2nd hand.

Um im surprised noones susgested it yet but wouldn't u atleast pull old motor out pull the head off etc and inspect engine damage before writing the old engine off im sure a new set of pistons and getting the cylinder bored, 2nd hand gtr rods etc wouldnt cost a hell of alot more then 2nd hand motor and atleast u no if u looked after the old motor ur not getting another motor which has already doen some work as opposed to rebuilt orginal motor thats been looked after. But if the motors bad needs headwork etc to repair mayaswell throw it away.

thanks just my opnion Rory

hahaha thats called a 'rebuild' dude, have you actully been reading the thread?

just rebuild mine. done a big end bearing.

replaced the crankshaft, bearings, rings, conrod, cleaned head, gasket kit. all done at repco just over 2 grand.

also had the comptuter chiped by Dr Drift and my rb20 turbo now with steel wheels and inlarged.

could of got a engine for a grand, which is about what i thought it would of cost but cost double!!

seem to have a loose tappet and a noise coming from the front cam wheel cover (unrelated i know) that we cant pin point.

started removal work on xmas day and turned the key friday (8th)

JBR

post-26265-1202626526_thumb.jpg

Edited by johnGTS-t
does anyone know of good places in melbourne that do good cheap rebuilds?

i do them, usually only by reference, but you will have to drop the engine off to me in keysborough. i will strip and photograph your eng and only replace what is needed or i can do some killler monster engine... whatever your budget or choice. If you want refferences i can give you the number of guys whose engines ive built.

$6000 to rebuild a motor your f**king crazy.

R33747 pm me i have a number for you to get rebuild wont cost much at all

he had a fully built engine, so i'm assuming forged pistons/rods etc etc you will EASILY spend 6k if you take it to a workshop for a "tough" rebuild

pistons, bearings, headstuds, gasket kit, timing belt, water pump etc etc all those things should be done while its torn down, and when your paying for labour it adds up very quickly, or you can go cheap and replace only the broken piston but that wont be any better than a second hand engine anyway.

If your not planning on making over 400rwhp get a nice low km engine, they can do a compression test on them outside the car, and buy the one that pulls the highest and most even numbers

or take it to URAS, it seems he knows something about skylines haha jks :thanks:

Edited by R34GTFOUR

i have a mate that works at Top Torque in Nunawading. don't know how much they charge, but theres no harm in asking. they've done a few cars from Chasers Motorsports. so im guessing they're pretty good

heres the link

http://www.aussieweb.com.au/details.aspx?id=2009642

I've just re-built an RB25DET, Rings, bearings, one piston, gasket kit, timing belt, tensioner, idler, faced flywheel, relined 5 puck clutch plate, faced pressure plate & fitted new fingers, filters and oils. Just under $1500.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • Because all parts that are put into your papers usually are assigned a badging if they did not come with one. So other people can just check that badging to tell if it is the parts your papes outline. But my pipe has NOTHING on it whatsoever. No idea why this even passed as a Mines pipe to begin with. I see this going two ways: -nobody cares and it's a non-issue, but that is unlikely -the pipe will just have to be assigned a bagding, for sake of argument, a Mines logo, and the papers corrected accordingly If it interests you I will post what the actual solution ended up being. All I care about is that it has to sound equal length and nobody can screw me later on because of a pipe being illegal.
    • The fasteners to the pipe are not subject to TÜV I guess, if we really start putting nuts and bolts through technical tests I'm going to hang the people responsible and then myself. Usually on a modern-ish EU normed car, you would just replace the pipe. Because if you start hacking away at it and welding new pieces on the cops will definitely find a reason to tow your car. That is just how it is sadly. On old cars and imports with no clear "standard" stuff like that won't matter too much. Most cops or inspectors probably won't even really know what they are looking at. But there is experts for this stuff even among cops, and some of them know the rules to a T and even have extensive knowledge about many vehicles. For "just a pipe" to be legal it usually is included in a set of parts, like a complete intake kit or a full exhaust. For example my exhaust needs to pass a noise test, meaning they have a standardized test track with a set of instructions and they run the car through there 3x for an average noise value that is 75dB(a) at point x of the test track. If it's above that, fail. For a turbo setup to be put in your papers you have to do dyno runs, emissions testing etc. So quite costly
    • Would this not be the same for the exhaust you've posted up?  If your exhaust volume and emissions are fine, why does the brand of pipe matter? 
    • The issue is more the fact that there is inspectors that deal with japanese cars a lot and they might know what a real Mines pipe looks like. And then they're gonna get antsy and not pass your car. But I'd have to talk to one of them about this, because you know as well as me that it's just a damn pipe and it effectively doesn't do anything. As I need to have my GT2860s and my exhaust setup (and the increase in HP) TÜV'd anyways maybe they can just correct the entry in the papers or assign a badge to the front pipe. I'm no expert either though, will inquire about this.     Thanks for the insight. Not sure if having a custom made pipe is good or not. Will find out in due time I suppose. Would be kind of funny if this was made in Germany though.
    • See this is a really tricky topic as technically the same rules apply to all cars but for cars but there is a difference. If you want to modify a car like the Skyline which never existed here you have a bit more freedom as they do not adhere to EU specs anyway. Any modification you do has to be in dividually checked anyway so as long as one of the inspectors think it's ok and within the TÜV ruleset you can get stuff like a top secret rear diffuser put in your papers. Which frankly would need a shitload of tests and certificates for EU spec cars, like a 2010 BMW M3 for example. But if you DO run these tests and all tests come out ok (safety stuff for the most part) there is no problem running such a part legally. It's just way too expensive to do for a single person on one car. The most touchy parts are emissions related mods, like an exhaust, turbos, air intakes. If it makes noise or alters the carbon emissions it's essentially illegal until you prove it's not. Meaning it doesn't exceed noise limits or have worse carbon emissions. I'd say for hoses if you replace them same same it doesn't matter what material they are or what brand you use. Same for nuts and bolts usually, they won't go and specifically check that your water hoses and some bolts are 100% OEM parts, that is nonsense.
×
×
  • Create New...