Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

hey guys, just went to WSID and was happy with the time i pulled 13.75 with only a cat back and 10 psi boost...HOWEVER, the last run i shifted from 3rd gear redline into 2nd gear, would this of damaged my car engine (such as pistons working too hard?) or would the rev limiter cut it off even if u shifted from 3rd to 2nd???

wat are the possible damages i coulda done??? cuz my car runs alright but just paranoid man

  • Replies 54
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

hey i saw your car! i wasnt competing, but i would like to in a few weeks, 16th methinks.

didnt see the mis-shift, and im no techhead but i have heard it can do all kinds of things such as valve-bounce, the piston coming up and smashing into the valve. of course that is just heresay, if its running fine i shouldnt be too concerned.

not like that poor bmw that got towed. or whatever it was that shat its guts up the end and delayed proceedings.

ill race you if i see you there again. mind you im expecting mid 12s with a 230-240rwkw R33. :D

if u shifted to second from 3rd wen u were on the limiter id be more concerned about ur gbox and driveline hence a massive compression lock usually... but if u had sticky tyres well i dont know but i wouldnt have thought it would have affected ur engine much cept for pinging of limiter

yep the gearbox is actually quite fine imo...

i didn't have sticky tyres, i only had some low profile "roadster" tyres at rear...and wat do u exactly mean by driveline issues?

i shoulda mentioned before, i did smell something badly right after it happened whether its the clutch or brake pads i don't know but there was no smoke or bang noises...

but the thing is i thought the rev limiter woulda cut it off so i woulda been safe? or am i just lucky the pistons didn't fly out?

well the way i figure it, if you let the clutch right out, there is nothing stopping the engine from doing say 10000rpm. the rev limiter wont prevent this, it only cuts the spark (or fuel?) in an attempt to drop the revs. remember, if the tyres are going 150kmh, this speed is transferred through the drivetrain, and then to the engine. in 2nd this would = 10500rpm.

this normally results in compression skid, where the tyres lock up, or the engine doing 10000rpm momentarily lol.

i shoulda mentioned before, i did smell something badly right after it happened whether its the clutch or brake pads i don't know but there was no smoke or bang noises...

hopefully that was your clutch slipping. best possible result! burnt clutch smells like shit, i daresay thats what it was. :D

oh alright thanks ALOT GUYS! just bloody paranoid after that....

but yeah like u said the tyres did lock up and made me skid~! so does that mean the rev wouldn't of gotten to 10000rpm? or it still would have and kinda stuffed up my pistons u reckon?

oh yeah another thing is, when i tried to step on it on 2nd gear after i mis-shifted, the rev went up as if the clutch was slipping, i thought that was the rev limiter kicking in? or is it really just a clutch slip?

Edited by R33Turbo
but yeah like u said the tyres did lock up and made me skid~! so does that mean the rev wouldn't of gotten to 10000rpm? or it still would have and kinda stuffed up my pistons u reckon?

oh yeah another thing is, when i tried to step on it on 2nd gear after i mis-shifted, the rev went up as if the clutch was slipping, i thought that was the rev limiter kicking in? or is it really just a clutch slip?

yes the revs probably did get up to 9-10000. i think its worse for your valves than your pistons, but if something let go it would probably have happened instantly and been catastrophic. so dont do it again lol.

revs going up, but not speed, is generally a good sign of clutch slip.

why don't you give it another run? because if the valves did bend due to the mis shift then wouldn't the performance be affected in a bad way ? or maybe not? can someone correct me on this?

thanks for the input guys. well im taking it in for a compression test tomorrow to make sure, but apparently to find out for sure i need to pull apart the head

*sigh* shouldn't of went to WSID tonight

Edited by R33Turbo

SoSK did similar, 4th to 3rd instead of 5th. Result 12 bent exchaust valves, no compression, engine no run. If the engine still runs OK, then chances are you got away with it, consider yourself very lucky. A leak down test will confirm that everything is OK.

Cheers

Gary

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now



  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • To expand on this to help understanding... The bigger/longer the block is, the more it's going to work to sit on your far away high areas, and not touch the low stuff in the middle. When you throw the guide coat, and give it a quick go with a big block, guide coat will disappear in the high spots. If those high spots are in the correct position where the panel should be, stop sanding, and fill the low spots. However, using a small block, you "fall off" one of the high spots, and now your sanding the "side of the hill". Your little block would have been great for the stone chips, where you only use a very small amount of filler, so you're sanding and area let's say the size of a 5/10cent piece, with something that is 75*150. For the big panel, go bigger!   And now I'll go back to my "body work sucks, it takes too much patience, and I don't have it" PS, I thought your picture with coloured circles was an ultra sound... That's after my brain thought you were trying to make a dick and balls drawing...
    • Oh I probably didn't speak enough about the small sanding block for blocking large areas.  In the video about 3 minutes in, he talks about creating valleys in the panel. This is the issue with using a small sanding block for a large area, it's way too easy to create the valleys he is talking about. With a large block its much easier to create a nice flat surface.  Hard to explain but in practice you'll notice the difference straight away using the large block. 
    • Yep I guessed as much. You'll find life much easier with a large block something like this -  https://wholesalepaint.com.au/products/dura-block-long-hook-loop-sanding-block-100-eva-rubber-af4437 This is a good demo video of something like this in use -    You have turned your small rock chip holes into large low spots. You'll need to fill and block these low spots.  It's always a little hard not seeing it in person, but yes I would go ahead and lay filler over the whole area. Have a good look at the video I linked, it's a very good example of all the things you're doing. They went to bare metal, they are using guide coat, they are doing a skim coat with the filler and blocking it back. If what you're doing doesn't look like what they are doing, that's a big hint for you  
    • The odometer does go up when driving.  Does this tell it is an issue with the speedometer itself?    Where can I look for replacement cluster? Or speedo? I can likely do the repair.. Will ER34 cluster work on HR34? Or do I need a HR34 20GT S2 specifically lol   
    • Mine's a bit bigger at 70x150mm roughly. The spots are flat, just can feel the edges if I dig my nail into it. I did fix some other other ones by both using my finger to sand that small spot (I'm a bit wary of doing this and creating hot spots and a bigger mess) and I also did sand over it flat and others, but this also worried me a bit because if I create an overall low spot on the panel on paint that is good.  Correct me if I'm wrong but as long as it's flat even if I can feel the edges, I can put filler because it will all be level once I sand it? I can see myself going in a circle after sanding guidecoat with 320 grit if for example the panel is flat with my hand but because I sanded the guidecoat I could have created a low spot again somewhere. Unless where I'm going wrong is what I mentioned previously where I didn't go low enough on the grits. It's 1 step forward and 2 step backwards here haha. I'll probably need to experiment with it more. Last time I go back to bare metal lol.
×
×
  • Create New...