Jump to content
SAU Community

Gran Turismo 5 - My Quick Review


Dean_HR31
 Share

Recommended Posts

Ok here it go's:

Graphics:

Excelent, nothing to complain about, simply fantastic. (besides having no tyre marks)

Sound effects:

Disgusting. The level of graphics DO NOT match the level of car sound quality in this game. I am EXTREMELY disapointed by this part of the game. I can hardly see ANY imrovement of engine sound/tyre screeching etc in this sequel from Gran Turismo 2!!

The R34 GTR for example sounds just like it did in GT2... very electronic, plain, flat, no depth just boring. I was actually getting annoyed listening to it on a 3 lap race!! Im sure i wouldnt be getting annoyed listening to an R34 GTR reving to 8000rpm in real life for 3 laps!! I'd happily take 78658765 laps of that sound in real life!!

Also the sound of the other cars racing with u on the track is pathetic. Makes me sick. How can these guys concentrate so much on graphics but leave sound technology at that of 8 years ago in gaming????

With the turbo cars, you cannot hear any turbo spool what so ever & or any sought of flutter/dose when backing off or changing gears. Also the wind down noise of the engines in the cars is even worse!! Sounds like need for speed hot persuit or something from 1997.

Rev limiter noise could also improve HEAPS. Just to fake & electronic. Needs to be more dirty, a little exhaust popping etc etc.

Car handling physics:

Big imrpovement from the previous GT series games. Its now to the extent where if u want to drift u need to HAVE an idea! And u need a steering wheel to do it properly! The cars whip lash if u over correct etc, throttle control means heaps in this game too.. pretty impressive.

However I will extend this part of the review once i have my G25 steering wheel. Because with the controller the whip lash thing seems a little over exagerated, but this will be confirmed once i have the wheel...

So they are the good points... Now for the bad points... I parked a car on a slanted part of the track... now guess what the car did?? It started sliding down the hill like it was on ice!!?? WHHAATT THHEE F*****!!! How can a game of this calibre allow to have such a stupid **** up like that. Thats the sought of thing id expect on a nintendo 64 racing game!

Also... braking traction... the car still stays straight no matter what gear ur spinning. It occasionally will come out one way sliiigghhtly when ur lucky but thats it. This is also sickening. This is the 5th version of the game, and that vital part of the car physics still hasnt been corrected.

I am PRAYING the above **** ups are corrected/improved for the full version.

Edited by Dean_HR31
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 49
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Don't forget in the graphics part.... the car will not leave skid marks...

It will not do burnouts starting in 2nd gear (my old R33 GTST could yet a Z06 can't?! Riiiight)

"Catching" power oversteer is VERY VERY HARD... near impossible.

So yeah, I dunno, they've stayed with the arcade style of the game... and the pro style hasn't been done very well.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

spend those 100's of thousands on buying the physics from LFS and work on them, i gave up on GT a long time ago, the physics and sounds are pathetic for such a high budget game which is meant to be a simulator.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

f**k GT5P... i played non stop for like 48 hours.. and it broke my f**kn throttle finger! Serious RSI and swollen joints. I would have though nightly adolescent white tissue moments had strengthened my right hand sufficiently :(>_<

Now i got learn to use my middle finger...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Im very impressed with this game, the sounds are fantastic thru a 5.1 surround system. Maybe u just need to turn it up a a bit or play it thru something quality. If uve seen the making of this game they go to alot of effort to get the sounds etc.

also catching power oversteer is not hard, its just not as easy as your more basic games like nfs, forza, juiced etc

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Blitz R34 sounds nuts 5.1 channel dolby digital yadida in my bedroom... can definitely hear the turbo spools up as its boosting through the high rev range... its nice :D

Edited by typevu
Link to comment
Share on other sites

When I get up today later and its not 130AM I'm gonna crank up the stereo and play it. I want the neighbours to hear the ferrari F430 at 8500rpm, and the mines R34 at full noise.... :D

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I just bought the ps3+gt5p bundle and the only complaint about it is the length. It's a $75 game retail and I'm nearly finished it after a max of 6 hours game play.

Also I can't play on line, it says 'you need to download the latest update' which I did and I still can't sign up to the gaming network?? Probably my own fault just can't figure it out.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

yip i just got it 2day also... only played for a few hours, pretty much over it now.

is there just 6 lowsy tracks or am i missing something ?

I just bought the ps3+gt5p bundle and the only complaint about it is the length. It's a $75 game retail and I'm nearly finished it after a max of 6 hours game play.

Also I can't play on line, it says 'you need to download the latest update' which I did and I still can't sign up to the gaming network?? Probably my own fault just can't figure it out.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ive got the jap only version, is it possible to hire the english version, install it then use my jap version to play it in english, is this possible?

I want to download the english GTR Videos so i can understand what they are saying!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Anyone else find the sound in GT5 poor, im considering getting a ps3 for GT5 but if its as bad as GT4 i will pass on a PS3

Its beyond poor.

You look at the graphics, its like ur actually in the real thing its so f***ing real and then u hear the sound and you just feel like head-butting a concrete wall.

In all honestly the sound is of higher quality/realism in Gran Turismo 2...

I wish i could have forza 2 on the PS3. Only reason why i chose PS3 over xbox+forza was because the logitech steering wheel setup isnt compatible on the xbox and blue ray of course....

Is GTR2 ever gona come out on PS3????

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Its beyond poor.

You look at the graphics, its like ur actually in the real thing its so f***ing real and then u hear the sound and you just feel like head-butting a concrete wall.

In all honestly the sound is of higher quality/realism in Gran Turismo 2...

I wish i could have forza 2 on the PS3. Only reason why i chose PS3 over xbox+forza was because the logitech steering wheel setup isnt compatible on the xbox and blue ray of course....

Is GTR2 ever gona come out on PS3????

wtf?

the sound quality is very good, alot of improvements over gt4. each car sounds like it should. Also the sound difference between view is good. from the incar view to the rear view the sounds changes alot.

the mines gtr sounds very real. i love the f430 it sounds like it does in real life, really shitty on idle (like a boat) but when its on full song its sounds awsome.

i love pulling up next to a f430 under braking and u can hear it slap it back into a lower gear its sounds very good :thumbsup:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think we will have to wait and see the full version to make a full decision im sure the full version will be different it better have tonnes more cars upgrades tracks etc.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think we will have to wait and see the full version to make a full decision im sure the full version will be different it better have tonnes more cars upgrades tracks etc.

this is just a prologue ... prologue has never had many cars or tracks

Link to comment
Share on other sites

wtf?

the sound quality is very good, alot of improvements over gt4. each car sounds like it should. Also the sound difference between view is good. from the incar view to the rear view the sounds changes alot.

the mines gtr sounds very real. i love the f430 it sounds like it does in real life, really shitty on idle (like a boat) but when its on full song its sounds awsome.

i love pulling up next to a f430 under braking and u can hear it slap it back into a lower gear its sounds very good :D

lol. 2 words mate... Play Forza 2. THAT is REALISTIC sound. You know what... no dont bother. I'm going to show u a link. Listen to this! (below)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GvdxJZi3T-8

I got goosebumps the first time i saw that. I just could not f**n believe it. Car games of this gen should sound like that! Gran Turismo sound is still stuck 8 years ago in technology.

If i was to close my eyes i would've thought that was a real life youtube video of a gtr and a ferrari.

Edited by Dean_HR31
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share




  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • we can only guess exactly what happened from our keyboards, but to me it looks like they were targeting 27 but the wastegate was too small or poorly controlled and the boost crept up, that is quite common
    • Good points!  Took those for granted - though I *did* actually give an example of winding boost up more than it had been before where I wasn't actually specifically looking for more peak power.  The Toyota Starlet dyno plot that I shared and mentioned showed an overlay from the previous tune it had and the one I'd redone, I left the boost targetting the same as the old tune but then after peak power I ramped boost up by a good 5psi or so over what the old tune had at the same rpm. The reason I felt comfortable with this (though the owner of the car had a "are you sure?" moment when I suggested it) is that the setup wasn't turbo limited, it was largely head sealing limited and the owner was a bit concerned as for the last few seasons he'd had issues with head lifting - sometimes not completing an event without having some headgasket issue, so he didn't want to run any more boost than it was. The reasons I was ok with raising the boost a good 5+psi MORE than that was that I left it where it was in the middle, and only increased it where VE (and therefore cylinder pressure vs psi) were dropping hard and I didn't stop the torque from dropping, just reduced the drop.  Well, there is that and the fact that the previous tuner had it overtimed by near 7degrees at peak torque - but that's another story haha.    I didn't really go into detail about that "turning it up more" thing but now you've mentioned the "not detuning", sometimes the boost *can* be turned up higher than you'd expect if the setup allows for it and you do it smartly.  I've tuned things to run 30psi on BP98 "safely" that a few years ago (or still?) people would cry that it was a stupid idea - but given they were well intercooled, low EMAP turbos and only doing that kind of boost where VE is dropping etc I was pretty confident it wasn't as cowboy as it sounded at face value and we never ended up with issues as a result of it.     
    • they choose the number of psi (27) around 4200? Could it produce more at this engine speed with the same turbo?
    • one thing escapes me, if the turbo spool provides the maximum boost and we can't control anything before that, how can the boost be higher by it alone.   here around 27 psi at 4200 then up to 32 psi at 6500 rpm   how does the tuner do this
    • I'm still not sure what you are trying to acheive, but I wanted to clarify something about Lithium's response to your question...   Only within certain limits. All of the examples Lithium gave were of detuning for a particular reason. Before the engine/turbo/wastegate combination has hit full boost, you can't increase it....the wastegate is shut and the turbo is pushing as hard as it can Once the combination has hit the target (controlled) boost, you generally have full control over whether it makes more or less boost, because it is being limited/reduced from its potential. This is generally done by controlling the wastegate In the top end, with an undersized turbo, it is possible you won't get to your target boost anymore if the turbo is choking up. In this case you cannot increase boost any more without changing the setup. No change in cost compared to any decent build, other than tuning time to get the engine to make less power than it is able to at a certain point
×
×
  • Create New...