Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

ohlins are the best of the best as far as i know, if funds were not an issue its quite easy to spend 10k on suspension settin up a race car using their stuff. my sisters b/f works with tasman motorsports (greg murphy and jason richards) and they use ohlins stuff in their cars.

Nothinng wrong with Ohlins. But jsut remember, you can buy $800 a corner Dunlops, and you can buy $65 a corner Dunlops. You can buy $35 tennis rackets and you can buy $415 tennis rackets.

You can buy $2500 Ohlins and you can buy $15000 Ohlins, just like you can buy $800 Koni and $15000 Koni shocks. Just because Tasmna motorsport use them, doesnt mean these used shocks are going to be out of this world great

top of the range my arse.

to make them usable - you'll need ligher springs ~$500 (cheapest) for a set

so they're now a $1800 proposition.

The SK bilstien kit is looking increasingly better... and will ride heaps better on th street

Hye, Yamaha race bikes, design heads for other ppl. Have designed F1 engines, Yamaha are nto idiots and would surely still do a good enough job of contract manufacturing???? Wouldnt they?

Yamaha owns Ohlins, they bought them some years back to get their GP bike shock technology, Ohlins first came to fame via their brilliant race bike shocks. Yamaha has a shock factory in Japan that builds their road bike shocks and a small range of car shocks and they use the Ohlins name on the road car shocks. All of Yamaha's race bike shocks are still made by Ohlins in Sweden, plus a few of their top end road bikes also have Ohlins. The Ohlins factory in Sweden only makes high end race shocks for cars and bikes, they don't make volume parts numbers. There is obviously some technology transfer between the 2 factories, but having pulled them appart and run them on the shock dyno I can tell you the internals and function are not at all similar. The leads to some problems;

The first problem is the price, you can't make and sell an "Ohlins" quality shock for less than $2K each, the materials, it's piston and valving sophistication and machining quality and tolerances simply wouldn't allow it.

The second problem is the Japanese philosophy in regards to springs and shocks, the Yamaha engineers and factory follow that philosophy, there is no engineering input from Sweden in regards to what rates should be used on a particular car.

The third problem, like 99.9% of the Japanese shock manufacturers, Yamaha doesn't provide spare parts support or service manuals, so you can't repair, service or revalve their shocks. When they wear out you chuck them and buy new ones. I have tried, without any success at all, to get the Australian and New Zealand Ohlins agents to provide spare parts a number of times for the Yamaha made models. In comparison we have obsolutely no problem obtaining genuine Ohlins parts and manuals for the race applications from them, the range of spares and options is almost at Bilstein level, which is very high.

The bottom line, don't think you are getting $10K worth of Ohlins at bargain price.

Cheers

Gary

Good read, thanks for clarifying. But ok they are not brilliant, but are they bad?

I still think a very telling thing about Japanese tuning and approach to car setup is what happens to cars like the EVO 8, R34 GTR M-Spec etc. They go to Europe, European Mitsu and Nissan engineers get their hands on them and throw in Bilsteins etc valved to suit and the cars are a hit in their intended market.

When Japan get their hands on them they often find their way onto local cars with things like the EVO 8 MR etc etc

Good read, thanks for clarifying. But ok they are not brilliant, but are they bad?

I still think a very telling thing about Japanese tuning and approach to car setup is what happens to cars like the EVO 8, R34 GTR M-Spec etc. They go to Europe, European Mitsu and Nissan engineers get their hands on them and throw in Bilsteins etc valved to suit and the cars are a hit in their intended market.

When Japan get their hands on them they often find their way onto local cars with things like the EVO 8 MR etc etc

Add the TRD Supras and of course R35GTR to the Bilstein equiped list list.

Bad, no, they're not bad. They are a bit better than the average Japanese kit, in that they will allow lower spring rates. Many of the others show little or no improvement in ride comfort and/or handling as the valving simply won't tolerate the more sensible rates. The main problem is you can't fix them, I have had at least 10 sets through my hands and I have had to tell the guys the bad news every time.

Cheers

Gary

So how would the yamaha ohlins compare to something like tein monoflex and hks hypermax 3's?

These specific ohlins:

http://www.greenline.jp/catalogue/fullimag...;name=Aluminium (Separate Tank) Complete Kit&car=Nissan Skyline GT-R BNR32 (RB26DETT)

$3900 + shiping

or

http://www.greenline.jp/catalogue/fullimag...32%20(RB26DETT)

$6100 + shiping

So how would the yamaha ohlins compare to something like tein monoflex and hks hypermax 3's?

These specific ohlins:

http://www.greenline.jp/catalogue/fullimag...;name=Aluminium (Separate Tank) Complete Kit&car=Nissan Skyline GT-R BNR32 (RB26DETT)

$3900 + shiping

or

http://www.greenline.jp/catalogue/fullimag...32%20(RB26DETT)

$6100 + shiping

1. Swedish Ohlins

2. Daylght

3. Yamahas (like those), the spring rates are too high on the ones I have seen, there are options so it would pay to check them first.

4. Daylight

5. Tein Monoflex

6. HKS Hypermax

Cheers

Gary

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • Rotisserie is fully assembled apart from centre connector which obviously isn't required until the car is on it. It packs away fairly neatly and doesn't take up too much room. (Now that I actually have some room after my clean up!) Overall very happy with the quality of it.  Assembly was a piece of piss.  The only thing I didn't like was that the pins that lock the rotation lock wheels in place were a bit of a dick in a bucket scenario. It allowed the arms to rotate a significant amount even when locked in place.  To fix that i measured up the hole and went and grabbed a couple of 18mm fully threaded bolts and a thread tap to suit. I ran the tap through top and bottom so it was threaded both ends.  Then just threaded the bolt through both sides.  It has made a massive difference which hopefully you can tell in the before and after video how much difference it made. 20250207_161431.mp4   20250207_161431.mp4 Hopefully back working on the car over the next few weeks.   20250207_162801.mp4
    • I think my main complaint with your idea is that there is a veneer of idealism spread across it. You want the simple numbers to make it easier, but all they will do is make it easier for someone to come to the wrong conclusion because the fine details will kick them in the nuts. As it is right now, the tiny bit of arithmetic is NOT the obstacle to understanding what will fit and what will not fit. The reality of trying it is what determines whether it will fit. If you had a "standard rule" that R34 GTT guards have that magic 100mm space from the hub face to whichever side you were worried about, and someone said "excellent, this wheel is only 98mm in that direction, I'll just go spend $4k on them and jam them on my sick ride".....they would just as likely find out that the "standard rule" is not true because the rear subframe is offset to one side by a fairly typical (but variable) 8mm on their car and they only have 92mm on one side and 108 on the other.
    • It still combines inches with mm, especially when you have .5 inches involved, and mm and inches that can go in either direction. This would give a clear idea on both sides of the rim, right away, with no arithmetic. Even better if somebody gives you the dimensions of the arch of multiple cars. i.e GTR may be 125mm, a A80 Supra may be 117mm, or something along those lines. Yes, you can 'know' that going from a 10in rim to a 10.5in rim with the same offset moves both sides about 6mm, but you still have to 'know' that and do the math. Often it's combined. People are going from 9.5 +27 to 10.5 +15. You may do the math to know it, but if it was going from (I had to go look it up to be sure) 241mm/2 - 27 - 93.5mm from the center line to (more math) 266/2 - 15 (118mm) from the center line. Versus 93mm vs 118mm. It's right there. If you know you have a GTT with 100mm guards you can see right away that one is close to flush and the other absolutely won't work. And when someone says "Oh the GTR is 120mm" suddenly you see that the 10.5 +15 is about perfect. (or you go and buy rims with approximately 118mm outward guard space) I think it's safe to say that given one of the most common questions in all modified cars is "How do offsets work" and "How do I know if wheels will fit on my car" that this would be much simpler... Of course, nothing will really change and nobody is going to remanufacture wheels and ditch inches and offset based on this conversation :p We'll all go "18x9+30 will line up pretty close to the guards for a R34 GTT (84mm)" but 'pretty close' is still not really defined (it is now!) and if you really care you still have go measure. Yes it depends on camber and height and dynamic movement, but so do all wheels no matter what you measure it for.
    • But offsets are simple numbers. 8" wheel? Call it 200mm, near enough. +35 offset? OK, so that means the hub face is that far out from the wheel centreline. Which is 2s of mental arithmetic to get to 65mm to outer edge and 135mm to inner. It's hardly any more effort for any other wheel width or offset. As I said, I just close my eyes and can see a picture of the wheel when given the width and offset. That wouldn't help me trust that a marginal fitment would actually go in and clear everything, any more than the supposedly simple numbers you're talking about. I dunno. Maybe I just automatically do numbers.
×
×
  • Create New...