Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

hi all,

i know that when a stock turbo fails on the gtr, the ceramic dust gets sucked into the engine and kills the engine. However i have only heard of this happening to r32's and r33's , mostly r32's. Has anyone heard of this happening to r34's . I know for sure that all r32, r33 and r34's (except the n1 and nurs )

have ceramic wheels so the potential is their. But i still haven't heard of any r34's doing this. Does anyone know of any r34 gtr's who have had their engine killed by the ceramic dust.

regards

mike

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/221039-turbo-failure-on-rb26/
Share on other sites

Ceramic dust??? How does dust from the exhaust turbine get into your engine?

I was under the impression that when the turbo's fail it's the ceramic exhust wheel that delaminates from the shaft due to the glue/bonding agent can't cope with the additional heat generated by extra boost. If you continue to run the engine after the exhust wheel has delaminated then the whole rotating assembly will be horribly out of balance, causing the metal compressor wheel to scrape the compressor housing and sending fine shavings of metal through your engine.

Ceramic dust??? How does dust from the exhaust turbine get into your engine?

I was under the impression that when the turbo's fail it's the ceramic exhust wheel that delaminates from the shaft due to the glue/bonding agent can't cope with the additional heat generated by extra boost. If you continue to run the engine after the exhust wheel has delaminated then the whole rotating assembly will be horribly out of balance, causing the metal compressor wheel to scrape the compressor housing and sending fine shavings of metal through your engine.

The shafts in turbo chargers spin at speeds in excess of 100,000rpm. So there is no point hypothesizing about where the bits of turbine wheel, shaft & housing are going to end up because the answer is everwhere. Including in your precious RB26.

I wouldnt be worried about turbo pieces going in your engine mate, most turbos fail at the exhaust side of the scope, I had a twin turbo engine previously and blew 6 turbos on it, never had any drams with engines, you see when one turbo fails the other turbo can not produce enough boost to even read 3 psi (read from gauge) , because pressure will always take the easiest option out, meaning that one turbo has failed and the other will just basically push air in to the other one because its closer (pressure follows path of least resistance) so i would imagine that as soon as the turbo fails there wouldnt be enough pressure to even push it through your FMIC etc . . correct me if im wrong just a thought!

you know, that is the reasonable answer.

But I have seen so many GTR engines killed by ceramic turbine failure (including my first, virgin rebuild) that it is just not true. when the gtr turbs let go you can end up with material in the bore that stuff it, badly. no difference in the 32-34 except for its age

I wouldnt be worried about turbo pieces going in your engine mate, most turbos fail at the exhaust side of the scope, I had a twin turbo engine previously and blew 6 turbos on it, never had any drams with engines, you see when one turbo fails the other turbo can not produce enough boost to even read 3 psi (read from gauge) , because pressure will always take the easiest option out, meaning that one turbo has failed and the other will just basically push air in to the other one because its closer (pressure follows path of least resistance) so i would imagine that as soon as the turbo fails there wouldnt be enough pressure to even push it through your FMIC etc . . correct me if im wrong just a thought!

Use the search button and you will find plenty on this topic . I even posted pics a few years ago for the none believers to see what happens to the engine . It is the exhaust wheel that lets go and becomes dust, gets sucked in via open exhaust valves and the rest is history....

My theory is that it is due to cam shaft overlap. The exhaust valves don't shut completely before the induction cycle starts. There is therefore some return of exhaust gasses from the manifold which now contains the ceramic particles that used to be your exhaust terbine.

  • 7 months later...

Thought I'd bump this thread since I couldn't find anything rb25 specific, and I suppose my question doesn't differ much anyway. Short story is my turbo went, compression came back as 125psi on each cylinder, dry test (r32 rb25de-t) Now I'm in the process of getting the new turbo put in and uprated injectors. Turbo was a slide hi flow

Now the compressor wheel did lunch itself, the mechanic found light metal shavings behind the pod, and some small bits near the IM. Now since my compression test came back ok, is there anything else to watch out for, or is it probable that the engine is ok if the compression tests consistent? Only idled the car once or twice after the turbo went, and tried to boost it twice 30 secs or so after the turbo went. Pretty much figured the turbo was stuffed when it didn't boost.

Getting the FMIC and all the intercooler piping flushed out as a matter of course. Also new engine oil and filter, since the turbo was leaking oil when I shut it off.

This is a known fact.

ceramic particles traveling that fast aren't going to be stopped by exhaust gas.

Imagine shooting an bullet (even if very small) into your exhaust port against the gas flow.

Slaughter and others;

* the damage occurs through the exhaust port . Not the intake.

Compressor side failures while being bad arent as bad as an exhaust side failure on a GTR. A compressor side failure still blows its air through your intercooler which does filter it a little. Compressor side failures will probably never happen on a gtr with stock turbo's anyway unless the intake injests foreign particles that cause the compressor wheel to break.

Like Rev210 says with his bullet theory. Consider the inertia energy of a wheel spinning at 100,000 rpm. Its going to go wherever it wants to go when it comes off the shaft. No amount of gas flow is going to changed the direction the wheel wants to go.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • How's everyone going? Just a shout-out introducing myself. I'm James, I live on the north side of Brisbane. I bought an R33 that had been left to rot in someone's front yard for 14 years. Apparently, it has immobiliser/fuel issues. Long story short, it's suffering from a seized engine, plus whatever else turns up once it runs. The car is pretty good considering it sat for so long. It pretty much died after being imported. It has a bunch of Jap parts and a full Top Secret body kit. It's painted Fiat Turchese Festival, or aqua blue if you're not French. Another project to throw money at!
    • So the clockspring is responsible for the indicators cancelling on their own? I thought that was the function of that white thing in the center (any idea what it's called?)
    • Can you log IAT? Whilst WTA coolers have their place, doing any sort of sustained run is not one of them There are fixes that slow down the heat soak, like ice boxes, which don't last that long, and interchillers, which are fairly expensive, up grades to the WTA cooling radiator, which may require a bigger pump, and upgrades to the reservoir size,  and upgrades to the cooling fans, but, it all still heat soaks, and takes ages to come down in hot weather  For a turbo, that isn't locked into WTA like my PD blower is, can you not possibly swap to a nice air to air intercooler????, it would be better for sustained runs then, and have alot less things that could go wrong in my opinion 
    • So, the other thing I've sorted is a baseline dyno run up at Unigroup's new location. The auto trans was a little unco-operative by both shifting down when the throttle was floored on the dyno (so Mark had to ramp it up more slowly than in a manual) and also by shifting up at 6,000 even in sports mode instead of the indicated redline of 7,000 Still, on a hot day it made 240rwkw at 16psi which seems about right for 300kw (400hp) through an auto at the wheels.  The shape of the curve is not quite right because it was not full throttle to about 4,500 to stop it kicking down, but until I can get a tune on the auto trans control this was the best we could do.....full boost will be well below 5,000 once that is sorted, I'll get some data logs when I can to confirm For comparison, the R32 made 255 at 12psi (at 4,500) on the same dyno with tune, n1 turbos, cam gears, big exhaust but otherwise all standard so the v37 is likely a little better out of the box. One thing that is very clear is that the standard water to air intercoolers are not up to sustained use at full throttle in warm ambient temps. After about 5 runs (so only a few minutes full throttle), it was pulling boost and timing and dropping 10-15% power. Unfortunately I didn't get that printout and the Unigroup guys are away at the moment, will try and get hold of it on their return. So, looks like a healthy engine to start modifying and the only real area of concern is the w2a heat exchangers which the aftermarket has plenty of solutions for    
    • I maintain it actually looked really nice in person. So much so that I thought "No, this is illegal" but there it was, clear as day. I think we can easily call the wing and wheels/height to be transformative. Not saying it's better than the GR Whatever, or the 86, or the WRX STI or anything of that sort (the internet says it all bolts up so you can buy best of all worlds?) but it's still at least a thing and not nearly AS bad as people say.
×
×
  • Create New...