Jump to content
SAU Community

Error Code 21 On Bnr34

Alecci

By Alecci,
in General Maintenance

 Share

Recommended Posts

Alecci Apprentice

Alecci

Posted
Posted

I've been rebuilding my R34 GTR following a crash during a track event some two years ago.

I've modified most of the engine, basically only leaving the bottom end standard.

For a complete spec list, please visit this link and scroll down below the pictures. All parts used are brand new.

For some time now we've been trying to start the car. We've run diagnostics on it and gotten some error codes, and we've managed to sort them all out except for code 21 (primary ignition signal).

I've searched the forums for other threads describing the same problem, and while the search turned up a lot of results for error code 21, none of the threads has dealt with problems such as mine (i.e. the car will not start at all).

We have spark on all cylinders, and we have fuel going into the engine. Ignition angle is 16 degrees. The starter turns over quickly and the car sounds like it wants to start, but the closest thing to a running engine we've achieved is a lot of back-firing in the exhaust.

I'm a real newbie when it comes to troubleshooting cars and fixing problems, but my guess is that one of the following are broken or not functioning properly:

- cam-angle sensor

- coilpacks

- AFM's

Any thoughts? I've posted this question on a number of other forums, but I don't seem to get any help. Having spent the last 2 years rebuilding the car, whereof the last 2 months just trying to get it started, I'm close to losing heart and taking a sledgehammer to the car in order to smash it just for the sheer satisfaction of the act. Help is desperatly needed!

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/221889-error-code-21-on-bnr34/
Share on other sites
GeeTR Grand Master

GeeTR

Posted
Posted

I checked the link, nice setup man, looks smooth :blink:

If its complaining about the primary ignition signal, Id assume that to mean the CAS isn't behaving correctly. I'm not too familiar with RB26 CAS's, but id assume its a photodiode and chopper disk setup. 360 (=20) home slots and 6 trigger slots. If "Primary Ignition Signal" isnt refering to the whole CAS, maybe just one of those ouputs is broken, as i didnt think a RB would even fire without a CAS. I guess the obvious question is, have you tried a different CAS?

I'm just just thinking aloud here :(

GoodLuck

Alecci Apprentice

Alecci

Posted
  • Author
Posted
I checked the link, nice setup man, looks smooth :(

If its complaining about the primary ignition signal, Id assume that to mean the CAS isn't behaving correctly. I'm not too familiar with RB26 CAS's, but id assume its a photodiode and chopper disk setup. 360 (=20) home slots and 6 trigger slots. If "Primary Ignition Signal" isnt refering to the whole CAS, maybe just one of those ouputs is broken, as i didnt think a RB would even fire without a CAS. I guess the obvious question is, have you tried a different CAS?

I'm just just thinking aloud here :D

GoodLuck

Hi mate,

I don't have any clue whatsoever as to how the CAS is constructed, nor in which ways it could be broken to the point where the car will not start.

I've not had nor will have any chance of trying a different CAS. There's only about 12 BNR34's in Sweden altogether, and none of them are close to where I live. Being a delicate, rather expensive and crucial component of the engine there's no way I can borrow one either.

The same thing, of course, goes for the coilpacks.

Being a bit low on funds after spending some money on the rebuild of the car, I'd hate buying new stuff that's not really needed.

Many thanks for your reply, I really appreciate it.

Cheers!

blind_elk Grand Master

blind_elk

Posted
Posted

Error codes in Nissan ECUs are persistent, ie they "hang around" for something like 50 start cycles. Try clearing (resetting) the ECU, see if you still have the error code.

If you have spark, then the CAS is working correctly. That also rules out the coil packs. And most engines will start without an AFM.

Do you have fuel "going into the engine" because you have fuel at the rail, or because you have seen the injectors working?

Are you sure the cams are set correctly? You had the crank at TDC when you assembled the cambelt?

Alecci Apprentice

Alecci

Posted
  • Author
Posted
Error codes in Nissan ECUs are persistent, ie they "hang around" for something like 50 start cycles. Try clearing (resetting) the ECU, see if you still have the error code.

If you have spark, then the CAS is working correctly. That also rules out the coil packs. And most engines will start without an AFM.

Do you have fuel "going into the engine" because you have fuel at the rail, or because you have seen the injectors working?

Are you sure the cams are set correctly? You had the crank at TDC when you assembled the cambelt?

Diagnostics tool and ECU has been reset/cleared between starts. We also removed the cable to the CAS, and then we would only get error code 11 (cam angle sensor). When CAS was reconnected, we once again only get error code 21.

Fuel is going into the cylinders, the spark plugs got very wet prior to lowering the fuel pressure. The injectors still open 8.0 ms when cranking the engine, some people guess the reason for that is choke (fuel enrichment for cold starts). Fuel is still going into the cylinders after lowering the fuel pressure. If I'm not mistaken, the car would not be back-firing if there's no fuel present?

Crank was at TDC and we double, triple and quadruple checked the position of the cams prior to assembing the cambelt.

GeeTR Grand Master

GeeTR

Posted
Posted (edited)

The fact its spitting code 11 when the CAS isn't present, and a 21 when it is... I got my money on the CAS. Have you got access to a oscilloscope to check its output maybe? Could the loom be damaged between CAS and ECU?

Edited by GeeTR
Alecci Apprentice

Alecci

Posted
  • Author
Posted
The fact its spitting code 11 when the CAS isn't present, and a 21 when it is... I got my money on the CAS. Have you got access to a oscilloscope to check its output maybe? Could the loom be damaged between CAS and ECU?

Just like you said, the fact that a non-present CAS gives code 11 and a present one gives code 21 is what also made me suspect that it may be the CAS that's malfunctioning. Otherwise I think the first error code would still show up, right?

The wiring could be damaged I guess, but it's nothing that meets the eye at least.

I'll check access to an oscilloscope.

I'm very grateful for your input!

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share
Go to topic listing


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • GabsReDeal
      R32 GTS (RB20DE) Injectors Replacement

      By GabsReDeal · Posted

      I refreshed the OEM injectors with the kit and connected it up. It now ideals okay even with the IACV removed. Driving still has the same cutoff issue like the 550cc injectors so the issue is somewhere else. I bought FPG's Fuel Pump Hanger. I will be installing it next, but it is not as straightforward as I thought it was with my limited wiring knowledge and no instruction on the specific model I purchased (FPG-089). I also got the incorrect billet clamp as I could not find info on the OEM sizing.
    • MBS206
      Leaking Rear Subframe Bushing?

      By MBS206 · Posted

      Stop looking at the garage floor, and turn the radio up a bit louder if there's any strange noises...
    • GTSBoy
      Unknown sound similar to BOV on positive boost with partial throttle RB26

      By GTSBoy · Posted

      No. Turbo shuffle and surge/flutter are not the same thing. Specifically, on a GTR, turbo shuffle has a definite meaning. On a GTR, the twin turbos are assumed to be the same thing and to operate the same way, exactly. In reality, they do not. Their exhaust sides are fed and exhaust a little differently, to each other. Their inlet sides are fed and exhausted a little differently, to each other. Consequently, when they are "working" they are often at slightly different points on the compressor map compared to each other. What this means, particularly when coming on boost, is that one of them will spool up and start producing extra flow compared to the other, which will put back pressure on that other compressor, which will push the operating point on that other compressor up (vertically). This will generally result in it bumping up against the surge line on the map, but even if it doesn't, it upsets the compressor and you get this surging shuffle back and forth between them That is "turbo shuffle" on a GTR. It is related to other flutter effects heard on other turbo systems, but it is a particular feature of the somewhat crappy outlet piping arrangement on RB26s. There are plenty of mods that have been attempted with varying levels of success. People have ground out and/or welded more material into the twin turbo pipe to try to prevent it. Extending the divider inside it works, removing material doesn't. There are aftermarket replacement twin turbo pipes available, and these exist pretty mush purely because of this shuffle problem.
    • Duncan
      Leaking Rear Subframe Bushing?

      By Duncan · Posted

      You can temporarily* use lock collars to keep it in place until you can do the bushes, back the nuts off, slide them in, snug back up. *temporarily is often for ever
    • nouveau_poor
      Unknown sound similar to BOV on positive boost with partial throttle RB26

      By nouveau_poor · Posted

      Thanks for the quick reply. To be clear, when you say turbo shuffle do you mean turbo flutter "stustustu" or referring to something else? I had thought they were the same thing. When I wrote the post my intention was to say it wasn't a flutter/compression surge sound. My understanding was that a flutter sound would be occurring when throttle is released, whereas I can keep the throttle in the same position for this noise
×
×
  • Create New...