Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

Greetings,

After recently purchasing a short shifter for my R33 GTR off ebay, I'd strongly advise not to waste your money.

I thought to myself how hard could it be to make a copy of a short shifter thats not lacking in quality compared to a legit brand. Apparently Hard.

I purchased it off "nottieboy" in a auction like the following:

http://cgi.ebay.com.au/SHORT-SHIFTER-NISSA...1QQcmdZViewItem

I stated to the buyer the application I required it for (R33 GTR). The actual shiftr I received didn't 100% match the picture on the auction. The shifter didn't fit properly, and even after modifying the bottom bush to fit, it was a rather loose fit, it did not fit my standard gear knob, and although the whole point of the product is to make the actual shift smaller (Which it did) the actual stick was that long (high) it was like driving a bus. Also the instructions that came with it were completely wrong and luckily had a link to the DIY section on here for fitting a C's short shifter.

I seeked assistance of the seller "nottieboy" and he consistantly palmed it off saying that I didnt know what I was doing and that it was my problem, and referred me to other buyers of his to get assistance.

Anyways just a heads up for other prospective buyers.

Ciao.

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/230162-ebay-short-shifter-dont-buy-these/
Share on other sites

no doubt this ebay shifter is crap as stated. most ebay knock-offs are.

but i have a question. is a short shifter supposed to be shorter in the shaft height? or is it's only purpose to shorten the throw between gears? or both?

well I thought that the gearbox is not changing the gear stick is so unless I'm missing something I assumed that it would just be shorter, please someone enlighten me.

There arn't any new moving parts added with the replacement stick so I don't see how it would change the throw without just being shorter.

i was under the impression that by using a specific bend in the lower part of the shaft, the throw is shortened.

but i dont know, thats why i asked.

if it doesnt shorten the throw, then whats the point !!!! :sick:

short shifter is supposed to shorten the throw distance between gears by changing the pivot point i think so you could have the height of the shifter the same as the stock as was my case but the throw is substantially shorter. i guess i was lucky when i got my C's copy. the copy shifters also transfer more noise to the cabin cause theyre solid and not insulated.

im so glad i didnt buy 1, i was looking at them for ages and then decided to go with a nismo one from japan, i thought at least nismo will do it right, and the nismo 1's even come with the proper boot to stop oil getting out, and at $200 delivered, and knowing it will be a good product i would happily buy another 1,

JV

i bought one, and went through EVERYTHING you did, exactly same buyer, referred to other buyers about the product, doesnt fit, bush is too small (r32 gtr), lots of loose play, and last week... the bottom fell out, and im sure i tighted it right, thats why i bought a tomei short shifter, ebay = fail

Another ebay thread... and again i have to ask.. honestly, what did you expect for $40?

Something that was perfect and working?

Come on guys, be realistic. $40 isnt going to buy you anything more than a headache when a known branded one retails for what, $250?

Until people stop trying to cut corners and save $200 here, $150 there, these kinds of things will forever continue to happen.

I cant even think of the last time i had an issue with a part... but then, i dont shop on ebay buying imitation parts

Greetings,

After recently purchasing a short shifter for my R33 GTR off ebay, I'd strongly advise not to waste your money.

I thought to myself how hard could it be to make a copy of a short shifter thats not lacking in quality compared to a legit brand. Apparently Hard.

I purchased it off "nottieboy" in a auction like the following:

http://cgi.ebay.com.au/SHORT-SHIFTER-NISSA...1QQcmdZViewItem

I stated to the buyer the application I required it for (R33 GTR). The actual shiftr I received didn't 100% match the picture on the auction. The shifter didn't fit properly, and even after modifying the bottom bush to fit, it was a rather loose fit, it did not fit my standard gear knob, and although the whole point of the product is to make the actual shift smaller (Which it did) the actual stick was that long (high) it was like driving a bus. Also the instructions that came with it were completely wrong and luckily had a link to the DIY section on here for fitting a C's short shifter.

I seeked assistance of the seller "nottieboy" and he consistantly palmed it off saying that I didnt know what I was doing and that it was my problem, and referred me to other buyers of his to get assistance.

Anyways just a heads up for other prospective buyers.

Ciao.

The same goes for the rest of ebay stuff. On ebay buy only real brand items. No-name knock-offs either wont work or can even cause damage to your car.

In regards to the copy shifters being solid and transmitting noise into the cabin. Even a genuine C's shifter is solid and transmits noise.

Ebay is fine if you only buy known brands from reputable sellers. I got a TiAl gate and 044 pump off ebay, haven't run the gate yet but it's definately a legit TiAl item and the 044 has been in my car for over 6 months with no problems.

i bought one.. for my 32gtst.. works fine.. no installation hassles.. shifts fine.. was a bit noisy.. but made a rubber gasket so to speak.. im not sure who i got it off on ebay.. and it was alot more expensive.. but definately wasnt a known brand item. i love it, and so does everybody else who drives my car.

Had the exact same thing with nottieboy, also palmed me off i reported him to ebay as they are not For gtrs and he is a tard. They are only meant for rb20s silivais, the smaller boxes as these have the smaller bush and are a tad longer,

im a gearbox builder of 6 years and he told me i had no idea to ,

lol hes just another scammer, that doesnt actually know what his products fit,

Had the exact same thing with nottieboy, also palmed me off i reported him to ebay as they are not For gtrs and he is a tard. They are only meant for rb20s silivais, the smaller boxes as these have the smaller bush and are a tad longer,

im a gearbox builder of 6 years and he told me i had no idea to ,

lol hes just another scammer, that doesnt actually know what his products fit,

bingo! it cannot suit all of the applications he has stated. From some of the above posts it seems it is an rb20/sr20 box style shifter which is not compatible with rb25 and 26 boxes

he is a scammer. report him to ebay and hopefully if there are enough reports he gets proper f**ked.

alot of ebayers send the wrong gear to suit the correct application.

quite some time ago i got one to suit my 33 GTS-T, they sent me one for an S13. i then returned it (my own money), got in contact with them and they sent me out one for a civic!. once again contacted the seller, they asked me to return it as i did the S13 shifter. i let him know i was i need of it in a hurry so they would send it to me before the got there civic shifter returned to them.

in the end i got what i was after, and i held onto the civic shifter as i did not recieve a refund on the return postage of the S13 shifter.

the design of the shifter was a copy of the nismo shifter, the construction of the shifter seemed sturdy but only use of it will determine how good the quality is especially the bushes etc....

Another ebay thread... and again i have to ask.. honestly, what did you expect for $40?

Something that was perfect and working?

Come on guys, be realistic. $40 isnt going to buy you anything more than a headache when a known branded one retails for what, $250?

Until people stop trying to cut corners and save $200 here, $150 there, these kinds of things will forever continue to happen.

I cant even think of the last time i had an issue with a part... but then, i dont shop on ebay buying imitation parts

Unfortunately it was more than $40! Im not one to buy cheap shit, but I thought a shifter would be a hard thing to f**k up, but as the posts above say, I guess its not suited to a GTR as some people have no problems with the cheap ones.

I rkn just the fact you shop on ebay for parts for your GTR is pretty bad itself.

You should be ashamed putting ebay parts in your GTR...unless they are genuine japshit as previously stated...!

If items are less than half price theres usually a good reason :down: but cheers for warning us fellow SAUers.

I rkn just the fact you shop on ebay for parts for your GTR is pretty bad itself.

You should be ashamed putting ebay parts in your GTR...unless they are genuine japshit as previously stated...!

If items are less than half price theres usually a good reason :cool: but cheers for warning us fellow SAUers.

As I said, I don't usually settle for cheap shit but I wouldn't have thought it would be hard to f**k up. I don't think the item should have ever been sold to suit a GTR. Either way the guys a flamin mongrel, don't buy off him :P

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • Oh, that's grim. Something bad has been happening there.
    • Put an endoscope down the hole and saw this. Not quite all around the bore but a good 60% at least. Chin to the chest and towards further disappointments I guess.
    • 2 does "sort of" applies, maybe......but looking at what parts would be needed for the swap to get engineered, registered, and insured, and basically that's everything under the car, the modifications the make it legal would be problematic and horrendously expensive, all for a street car that just cruises around and hits a few twisty roads on the weekends Also, from looking at the NSW rules and Regs, with all modifications that is required just to make the car safe and not twist itself to pieces, and then actually get registered for street use, may still be impossible nowadays As for 1, when you add in a fresh engine, fresh transmission, rear cradle and diff, tailshaft, suspension, brakes, cooling, and all the other fabrication required, your probably looking at up to $100k to do it right, all for a 20 year old MX5 that is over engineered and you would never be able to actually use the power it has on the street, much like your beastie, which I love, but you actually track that thing and can use all of its powers in anger, in a safe environment  Hell, the old Bogan Cruise Ship had more power than I could use on the street, and in hindsight, I went a bit silly on that thing, it didn't really need the 500hp it had for what I actually used the car for, it was fun, but basically unusable on the street if you value your licence  As for cams, yeah, I'll probably book it in for them to get installed and tuned soonish, like next month after MX5 Mania are back at work....... and yes, I've already sent a email to bin the turbo quote and quote instead to install cams and a new Fluidampr balancer that will suit the 2.5 better than the OEM 2.0 balancer that is swapped over for the 2.5 install, as the balancer needs to get pulled to time the cams it's a while your in there sort of thing I did think a bit about flex fuel for a laugh, but being na, and no where really around locally anymore to get E85, I've binned that idea, so no sweet sweet corn smells are set for the car I wish E85 was more of a standard fuel, it's better for the environment, better for tuning, plus that sweet sweet smell we all love As for fitting in the family, that's not needed, as everyone in the family already owns a car that can seat 5 humans comfortably enough, the MX5 is "my toy" As for buying a car that is already built, nah, I would rather pick and choose my parts, I enjoy the process, and in the big picture, the additional cost is well worth the enjoyment, and the occasional frustration, I get out of doing it, albeit with other people spinning the spanners, and me, just paying the invoice 🤣
    • Excuse me, but 2) does apply 1) Would also apply if you consider how much is spent in the alternatives. Also there's the option of 3), buy one pre-built that you can put your family in (it's me, it's my car)   That said, I went on a ~500km drive the other day. I didn't use anything more adventurous than 3rd/4th gear at about ~3000RPM and 50% throttle and I was going as fast as anyone has any sense doing on a public road, with enough grip to the point where I didn't want to go any faster. I was obviously under the limit of the current car etc etc. MX5 with 2.5 N/A to achieve the same speed would be more fun for any road scenario. Maybe consider cams. I wouldn't boost it. The use case is just not there and it won't actually make the car more enjoyable unless you really do plan on wringing gears from 1st to 3rd (at least) at 100% WOT on a public road to 150+kmh.
    • Great if: 1. You had all of the money for everything else that is required  2. Lived in a country where you could actually do this and drive it legally on the road Sadly, neither applies to me As for the turbo, I am having second thoughts, mainly for engineering/registration legality reasons and insurance  Not saying I've finished doing stupid things that I probably should do to the MX5, but boost, and V8 engine swaps isn't on the cards Strange, but true 
×
×
  • Create New...