Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

wen i break an slow down to a certain point...my car makes a funny noise coming from the front and the car rattles a tiny bit...it sounds like scraping [kinda]

is it my pads that need changing....or a rotor skim??..

if so where can i get it checked out and fixed, and how much

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/232596-my-brakes/
Share on other sites

so when braking does the steering wheel shake or does the pedal just pulsate?

well if its steering wheel... front brakes/rotor. and pedal is rears...

oh yeah reminds me. Sumies rolla does this really bad.. so if you see her inform her about it.

Edited by lunjiaow
Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/232596-my-brakes/#findComment-4082404
Share on other sites

I'd say brake rotors causing pulsation? Ian Diffen etc do cheap skimming.

No they dont, they take it off and give it to us :P

My front rotors were badly warped a while back, shaking when braking from 80km/h!! Skimmed them 8 times before they flattened out, took about 1mm+ off them. When you consider most disks need 0.02mm taken off, you can see how bad they really were!!

Take it into a mechanic Andrew, they'de be able to tell you. Soooo hard to diagnose without actually hearing/driving it.

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/232596-my-brakes/#findComment-4082580
Share on other sites

Internet mechanics diagnosing brake problems.....scary thought....

btw

'breaks' is what happens when you drop a glass...'brakes' are what you use to stop...

'disk' is interchangeable with 'disc' however disc is more commonly accepted

Can't sleep so I have chosen to become the spelling police...sorry

Morale of my post is do somebody elses rear bumper a favour and get a mechanic to look at you brakes...

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/232596-my-brakes/#findComment-4082597
Share on other sites

Internet mechanics diagnosing brake problems.....scary thought....

btw

'breaks' is what happens when you drop a glass...'brakes' are what you use to stop...

'disk' is interchangeable with 'disc' however disc is more commonly accepted

Can't sleep so I have chosen to become the spelling police...sorry

Moral of my post is do somebody elses rear bumper a favour and get a mechanic to look at you brakes...

Fixed.

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/232596-my-brakes/#findComment-4083612
Share on other sites

No they dont, they take it off and give it to us :D

My front rotors were badly warped a while back, shaking when braking from 80km/h!! Skimmed them 8 times before they flattened out, took about 1mm+ off them. When you consider most disks need 0.02mm taken off, you can see how bad they really were!!

Take it into a mechanic Andrew, they'de be able to tell you. Soooo hard to diagnose without actually hearing/driving it.

Something else that can happen with discs is fat spots. Basically brake discs are cast steel that is subsequently heat treated to achieve a harder surface for better wear life...What can happen is that if the heat treatment is not uniform around the disc, the depth of the harder skin varies and so once the disc starts to wear, softer spots get exposed. They then in turn wear faster. This produces fat and thin spots around the disc and causes the bad brake shake...

OEM Ford Falcon discs are notorious for this...Sometimes they do it within 20,000km from new. Machining fixes it for a while but the fact is non-uniform hardness around the disc..They do it again in another 20,000km..Solution- DONT BUY A FORD!!

Disc warp is mainly caused by non-uniform cooling of the disc. ie if the discs is very hot and you dont cool down your brakes, when you stop, the disc area exposed to air cools much faster than the disc underneath the brake pad. This induces high temperature differential and therefore thermo-stress in the disc and you get plastic deformation (cooler metal gets stretched and hotter gets compressed) around the disc which can warp them....

Warped discs can cause brake shudder but also bad for calipers. In opposing piston calipers the pistons will shuttle in and out to suit the disc warp at the wheel rotation frequency..This will accelerate caliper seal wear no end. In floating single and dual piston calipers the floating pins cop it...

anyway back to work...

cheers

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/232596-my-brakes/#findComment-4085034
Share on other sites

Something else that can happen with discs is fat spots. Basically brake discs are cast steel that is subsequently heat treated to achieve a harder surface for better wear life...What can happen is that if the heat treatment is not uniform around the disc, the depth of the harder skin varies and so once the disc starts to wear, softer spots get exposed. They then in turn wear faster. This produces fat and thin spots around the disc and causes the bad brake shake...

OEM Ford Falcon discs are notorious for this...Sometimes they do it within 20,000km from new. Machining fixes it for a while but the fact is non-uniform hardness around the disc..They do it again in another 20,000km..Solution- DONT BUY A FORD!!

Disc warp is mainly caused by non-uniform cooling of the disc. ie if the discs is very hot and you dont cool down your brakes, when you stop, the disc area exposed to air cools much faster than the disc underneath the brake pad. This induces high temperature differential and therefore thermo-stress in the disc and you get plastic deformation (cooler metal gets stretched and hotter gets compressed) around the disc which can warp them....

Warped discs can cause brake shudder but also bad for calipers. In opposing piston calipers the pistons will shuttle in and out to suit the disc warp at the wheel rotation frequency..This will accelerate caliper seal wear no end. In floating single and dual piston calipers the floating pins cop it...

anyway back to work...

cheers

So basically, heavy braking makes them hot, they warp and cool, and therefore shake with heavy braking?

Brke warp for dummies... Like me :)

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/232596-my-brakes/#findComment-4086333
Share on other sites

So basically, heavy braking makes them hot, they warp and cool, and therefore shake with heavy braking?

Brke warp for dummies... Like me :(

Basically the harder you brake the hotter the discs get...A moving car has kinetic energy...Energy is always conserved and the brakes absorb the kinetic energy of the car and converts it mainly into heat. Harder braking leads to higher rate of energy transfer into the brakes. The brakes dispate the energy in the form of heat...And if you put energy into the brakes at a much faster rate than what can be disipated they will get much hotter. Bigger brakes have more surface area to dissipate heat plus larger thermal mass...So they can absorb more heat...

Discs buckle due to the following reason...When steel gets hot it expands...If the temperature throughout the disc is even, it expands evenly...so there is no problem with high temperature until the steel starts to soften..Discs will glow before this happens...

The problems occurs when the disc cools unevenly. The disc cools down as soon the brakes release...(because they are no longer absorbing energy). If the disc cools evenly there is no problem as the disc contracts consistently ie Everything shrinks at the same rate (or close enough to the same)

If the disc cools very unevenly some of the steel is trying to shrink more than the neighbouring steel it is connected to...The differnce in shrinkage is directly proportional to the temperature differential...In discs the difference can be 1/100ths to 1/10ths of millimetres at a guess for normal, slightly uneven cooling. Steel is elastic (will recover after being stretch or compressed to a certain point) but if you try and stretch it too much, it becomes plastic. ie stretches or compresses in permanent way..

So if you start with a very hot disc at say 500-600degC and stop the car suddenly, the section of disc under brake pad will not cool nearly as fast as the rest of the disc which is exposed to air...'Newtons law of cooling' comes in here...maybe you could Google that cos I wont explain it here

Therefore the section of disc under the pad in the caliper will remain larger or more expanded than the rest of the disc whcih is cooler. If the difference in shrinkage between the hotter and cooler steel is too great, the stress in the steel will exceed the elastic limit of the steel, and permanent deformation will result. Even when the discs cools down to ambient temperature it will remain deformed and buckled...

The morale of the story is if your brakes are very hot don't stop the car straight away...The idea is too cool the brakes (while they are still rotating) down enough so that when the car is stopped, the difference in rate of cooling of the entire disc is uniform enough such that difference in expansion across entire disc doesn't permanently deform it.

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/232596-my-brakes/#findComment-4086943
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • Pretty much what you'd expect at that power level. Hypergear turbo, long list of supporting mods, full Haltech catalogue, etc.  I'd say this goes for most drivers, suspension is still a dark art for most people. And it's really hard to convince someone how much better their setup could be...  
    • They are what I will be installing. 640s for me.
    • Hmm... From my experience you get about 0.25° camber change per mm of RUCA length change. So, to correct from -2.5 up to less than -1° (or, more than -1° if you look at the world as a mathematician does) then you'd be making 6-8mm of length change on the RUCA. From a stock length of 308mm, that's 2-2.5% difference in RUCA length. My RUCAs are currently very close to stock length - certainly only 2-3mm different from stock. I had to adjust my tension arms by 6mm to minimise the bump steer. That's 6mm out of 210, which is 2.8%. That's a 2.8% change on those, compared to a <1% change on the RUCAs. So the stock geometry already has worse bump steer than is possible - you can improve it even if you don't change the RUCA length. If you lengthen the RUCAs at all, then you will definitely be adding bump steer. Again, with my car, I recently had an unpleasant amount of bump steer, stemming from a number of things that happened one after another without me having an opportunity to correct for them. I only had to change the tension arm lengths by 1mm to minimise the resulting bump steer. (Granted, I also had to dial out a lot of extra toe-in in the rear, and excessive rear toe-in will make bump steer behaviour worse). Relatively tiny little adjustments having been made - the car is now completely different. Was horrifying how much it wanted to steer from the rear on any significant single wheel bump/dip. And it was even bad on expansion joints on long sweepers on freeway entry/exits, which are notionally hitting both rear wheels at the same time. My point is, the crappy Nissan multilink is quite sensitive to these things (unlike the very nice Toyota suspension!). And I think 99.75% of Skyline owners are blissfully ignorant of what they are driving around on. Sadly, it is a non-trivial exercise to set up to measure and correct bump steer. I am happy to show my rig, which involves nasty chunks of wood bolted to the hub, mirrors, lasers, graph paper targets and other horrors. Just in case anyone wants to see how it is done. I'll just have to set it up to take the photos.
    • What do you have in that bad boy ? Ill go with the 725cc since I'll be going with Nistune ( would definitely like more engine protection but Haltech is too far out of reach at the moment... plus, Ill probably have a pretty safe tune as its a daily, not gonna be chasing peak power 24/7 ahahah ). Are Xspurt a safe choice?  Pete's great. He didnt mention anything about traction arm length so I reckon it may be good. When I get some new wheels/tire later down the road I'll ask him about it and get his opinion on em. I heard from Gary that you've got the bilsteins too, are you running the sway bars too? and what other suspension goodies do you have installed or would recommend?
    • In true Gregging style...  
×
×
  • Create New...