Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

Another of my posts refers to noise the front upper portion of the engine is producing.

I thought it was the lifters but after seeing how the cam will move while the gear and VCT housing does not, indicates that something is not correct. I checked for similar cam movement on a spare engine and its quite solid and will not move in relation to the VCT housing.

I'm curious to its internal workings to help me discern what went wrong with it. I plan on tearing off the front of the engine to swap the VCT system starting tomorrow.

When you are referring to the VCT housing moving seperate to the camshaft, if you are saying that the VCT cam pulley moves while the cam remains still...that is not supposed to happen. Check to make sure you don't have a snapped cam first by removing the cam covers and then check the locking bolts in the back of the VCT cam pulley. There is adjustment there and if the locking bolts have loosened, it will be able to move 10 degrees or so but that's about it.

I removed the timing cover to check condition and tension of the belt, which is Nismo and has about 12000Km on it. I also pulled the cam covers to verify the torque on the bearing caps and to look for obvious wear indicators. Everything looks normal.

The cam will move and the gear/VCT does not because it is being held in place by the belt. I tried to reproduce the "failure" on the spare engine (VCT is still attached and cam in the engine) by holding the gear/VCT with a strap wrench and trying to move the cam. It appears to be locked and solid.

I don't know exactly how the VCT mechanism works so I can't fathom what is malfunctioning. Based on the picture, the return spring, helical gear or piston may be broken.

After the swap, I will disassemble and post pictures of the suspected bad VCT.

if the cams moves then there is something wrong with the cam....the VCT doesnt hold the cam in....it only keeps it only tells the computer the degree of the cam, and changes it a small amount through the rpm range.

as Elite man said remove the cam cover and check the cam.

With the timing and cam/valve/rocker covers off, I can physically rotate the camshaft (advance/retard a few degrees) while both cam gears, belt, exhaust cam and crank do not rotate.

The engine starts, runs and boosts just fine. I have oil pressure and knock readings are within normal operating parameters.

Based on grinding noise when cold, tapping noise upon VCT actuation when hot and a spare engine not exhibiting the advance/retard movements, unless the intake cam knock pin/keyway broke, I suspect the VCT device is defective.

Pulled off the suspected bad VCT unit, the cam is not damaged.

No visual external damage to the VCT and the 4 bolts holding the gear were tight.

The VCT appears to be a sealed unit, but I didn't have much time to look at it because the shop closed.

I will finish installing the known good VCT this afternoon.

As for the mechanics, 3 certified ones work at the auto hobby shop where I built the engine and do all the work. They agree with my diagnosis.

I'll try to gain access to the VCT internals. I may call in a favor and have the unit X-rayed.

Original VCT was malfunctioning. Known good VCT installed, bad noises stopped and engine runs smoother.

I will cut apart or x-ray the old one and post the pictures in the near future.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • Ye good idea , would have never thought of something like that. Might aswell do it to every pulley and the balancer while I’m there 
    • Use an LS1 or similar, via kit like Frenchy's. But.... It's probably not the alternator. It sounds like belt squeal, which would be because the pulleys are glazed. Rub every groove on the pulleys with 120 grit paper. Report back. Oh, and new belts afterwards too. The old new ones will be shitted up already.
    • Hello all I have 2 r34 sedans , one turbo one na, only recently aquired the na 34.  Man what is with these things.... My turbo 34 started sounding like a super charger, it was screaming at anything above 4000rpm , I took the alternator apart and replaced the front bearing which is the only one I think you can access and it did not fix the issue so presumably the bearing in the rear of the alternator is gone. ( diagnosed it was the alternator by taking off the aux belts one by one to figure out which pulley or bearing it was )  My friend gave me one he had lying around, Installed it , it did not squeal for maybe 500kms and now its started to squeal again briefly on startup  Recently got an na r34 and I replaced the timing belt, water pump + all the auxillirary belts. Runs amazing but it suddenly developed the same squeaking problem but significantly worse, Ive had my neighbour come down screaming at me because it was waking her up everytime I moved the car. It takes a good 2 minutes before it quietens down.  Im yet to diagnose where its coming from but im fairly sure its coming from the alternator aswell. My question isnt about how to fix it but rather where can you get a new alternator for an rb25 neo??? Ive searched everywhere but I havent been able to find a direct fit oem type replacement thats not genuine. All the automotive stores sell an oex one - BXA035 - which I picked up for cheap through a friend with staff discount , got it home only to find the connector is completelty different.... As far as im aware bxa035 is for rb20/30's and after a bit of figuring out the bxa035 has an ev14 type connector, which is tiny compared to the rb25 connector. I actually had an ev14 connector lying around which I was considering just replacing the bigger plug with to get the alternator working but the bxa035 is rated for 70amp vs the rb25 alternators are 90amp ( or so ive been told ? ) That paired along with the fact im about to install an amp + sub in the back and I have the stock sized small battery Im not sure itll do the job unless anyone has another opinion?  I know and have seen all the websites selling the ls1 alternator conversion kit but I am not going down that route, nor do I have the money to. Hopefully I can figure out how to get 2 brand new alternators for both cars. I would buy second hand which there seems to be many of but considering how common this seems to be im sure If I installed a second hand one it would start squealing in no time  Or even better if anyone knows how to fix the issue directly with the alternator itself... Any input appreciated Thank you     Link for bxa035 connector picture
    • As above, replace as many as you can afford. If anything, due to old age.
    • Can confirm previous shop that built my motor had no fking clue about oil control and caused my motor to shit itself after two track days. Current shop, Birrong Automotive, has managed to build me a motor, not to mention, has also let me tune it myself and it has yet to blow up after 7 track days. Great oiling success, yashimash.
×
×
  • Create New...