Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

Assume you have 2 IDENTICAL motors with all supporting mods (FMIC, Exhaust, Fuel Pump)

Motor 1 makes 200rwkw @ 16psi, It makes it power by upping the boost.

Motor 2 makes 200rwkw @ 12psi, It makes it power by having adjustable cam gears and cams.

Now these motor are exerting the same amount of force, in this case 200rwkw, but is one motor doing it easier than the other?

I guess what im asking is, is there different ways to make the same power but one way is easier on the motor?

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/244873-how-hard-is-an-engine-working/
Share on other sites

Efficiency is the key, if the motor as a whole is optimised for efficiency then more energy is converted to power instead of emissions and heat. To use your two examples you would have to ask which one is operating more efficiently, which one is using more fuel, generating more heat or creating more emissions etc

Your first example could be the best alternative for that type of motor, it could run cooler, be more fuel efficient and have lower emissions along with a longer engine life.

the more boost, the more you ring the engines neck basically

the higher the boost you cram in, is the higher there is a restriction across the in vs out

you are always better off with less boost in any situation

a knock sensor is a good indication of how hard an engine is working

keep adding timing till it knocks, then back out 2 deg - done :)

the more boost, the more you ring the engines neck basically

the higher the boost you cram in, is the higher there is a restriction across the in vs out

you are always better off with less boost in any situation

a knock sensor is a good indication of how hard an engine is working

keep adding timing till it knocks, then back out 2 deg - done :P

I've seen engines lose torque/power by using that approach - usually large duration camshafts and unreactive chamber shapes cause this.

And generally less boost in spark ignitions engines is better but I have seen cases that are contrary to this as well. Diesel engines are quite the opposite though - the more boost the better. Its really a case of giving the engine what it likes.

In this statement is just so many variables that u cant say

Whats the static compression ratio?

Peak power is a very small part, what about how the engine delivers its power and torque from idle?

But for the sake of this exercise id go with motor 1, reason being option 2 has a smaller time to burn fuel due to wider cam duration and u probably will have the same amount of air getting into the engine

(option 1 less time more boost, option 2 more time less boost) but because the burn time is less u will have to run leaner to get more out of the fuel increasing the heat in the engine raising the risk of predetination breaking a ring land.

My thoughts anyway.

And generally less boost in spark ignitions engines is better but I have seen cases that are contrary to this as well. Diesel engines are quite the opposite though - the more boost the better. Its really a case of giving the engine what it likes.

Boost is only a measurement of the charged air

20psi into an engine with a 11.5 comp ratio = dangerous

20psi into an engine with a 7.5 comp ratio = safe

my cats name is mittens

ROFL!

Imo, Both engines are working just as hard being that there making the same Power figures, But it depends if you have to rev the cammed engine harder due to larger cams, but the engine with cams is the more efficent air pump (e.g sucks and blows easier) But the cylinder pressures whould be ablout the same, Remember boost is just manifold pressure not so much cylinder pressures.

Andrew

there is no real difference. boost is a measure of restriction in the intake. it's a pressure reading, not a flow reading. so it's possible both cars are injesting the same amount of air (almost certainly if they are identical and making the same power). so perhaps changing cam timing has reduced a restriction which allows the car to flow the same amount of air but at a lower pressure. anyway, it's kind of pointless comparison. I'd run the 16psi AND the cam adjustment and make 220kw instead. :P:(

a torque read out is a good indication of how hard an engine is working

keep adding timing till it stops making more torque, then back out 2 deg - done :)

Your right on the money there mate :D

my cats name is mittens

That is an amazing coincidence. I once had a friend with a dog called Rufus. :)

To go off topic - the measure of how hard an engine is working is BMEP - its brake mean effective pressure. Go look that up on Wikipedia. How the air gets to the engine is largely irrelevent.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • Noted. Have noticed BMW are more 'high maintenance' for sure. They've attracted my attention as I think the used car prices seem reasonable vs other options, and the extra quality overall vs a commodore / camry / corolla or similar of the same vintage is appealing, especially the interior, and they are more on the sporty side whereas the others mentioned can be more cruising or economical A-to-B only.
    • Haha yeah I know, this is SAU after all, why are we talking about BMW's of all things!? I hear you on the 'don't have to worry about it' side of things. Having been fortunate enough to be have been able to buy a brand new motorbike or two...never really enjoyed them as much as I'd have liked as you worry so much about where you park it, will it get scratched, stolen, attempted theft, knocked over, etc...and yes dirty. Older less valuable bikes you can just go where you want and park it wherever and not really worry that much in comparison. And who cares if it gets dirty! Never owned a V8, and have had my eyes on VE / VF commodores for years but with their prices climbing so high, the M3 has come into focus more as prices are much closer than I've ever seen...is it a potential contender now?...of course need to factor in the S65 'maintenance' especially and like you said general M car 'tax'. One can dream anyway. But more on the reality front - did read the whole 330i thread as well and was a great read too, both threads enlightening as I've never even driven one of these cars! I do recall 330i didn't seem to have the same amount of issues for almost the same car (turbos and related differences notwithstanding)...perhaps down to getting it earlier in it's life so looked after better than the 335i? Perhaps so as your 130i has been good and quite similar, so finding a car that's been looked after well is the especially-crucial-BMW-first-step.
    • Nice. Dont worry about the time of not running. My current skyline hasn't run since I bought it. About 8 years ago.
    • It's also worth noting that I am heavily and unconditionally biased. I've had a lot of cars including some GTRs a fair while ago. I love my BMW's now a lot. They make no sense a lot of the time and the guys on here remind me regularly that I could get something else that does what I want better and cheaper. If you're going to take on an older BMW it's definitely a commitment. If you bail on it early you'll lose money and also the ability for it to put a smile on your face. Stick with it and it just gets better.  f**k I should get into advertising.  
    • Careful with posts like that around here without the flame suit on @cobo_11! 😂😂 My 330i journal is on here too. That car was so good and super reliable. We still have a 130i in the family which is almost identical to the 330i and easier to find in manual. It has also been almost faultless over the 6 or so years in the family.  I used to want an M car a lot more than I do now but if I'm honest and without trying to sound like a wanker, I can get such good performance and handling out of my 335 without needing to worry about all the crap that goes along with M car ownership. I don't need to worry about my bearings or subframe issues or the cost of replacing brakes or suspension or whether it has been impeccably maintained. And I can leave it places and not get upset when it's always filthy.
×
×
  • Create New...