Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

Heres my advice, BTW I got the PM you sent me..

Go trash the shit out of your car I bet you wont see knock over 30-40.. I found it strange to be doing this... Its obviously something funny in some cars.

You'll notice knock, it sounds like a shitbox trying to climb a hill in 5th. Mine eventually went away - I have no idea how! I think it was the lifters making noise after I put the cams in and the standard knock system freaking out a little. I did put a thicker oil in and dont look at the knock sensor any more. It has no blown up yet. :yes:

Edited by DECIM8
  • Replies 66
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted Images

Guilt toy, Im not trying to undermine you or anything, so dont go psycho on me, but what lead you to believe that a "tuned" engine will knock at a different frequency to a stock engine. From what most ppl say here, their knock happens not under foll boost at 6000RPM but under slight load in a high gear at about 2000-3000RPM going up a hill on a hot day.

Ie what im trying to say is that under that scenraio a tuned engine and a stock engine wouldn't be performing materially differently.

Also, if as you say the knock of a highly tuned engine would sound different to a stock engine, this doesnt explain why the knock value is still coming up on the PFC. Perhaps the "real knock" is a different frequency to what the PFC is showing but i would still be concerned that a large noise (consistent with stock engine knock) was coming out of my tuned engine consistently for a certain situation (ie above).

Before u reply Guitl-toy, know that I am not saying u r wrong or ur thery is flawed, I'm just trying to understand the underlying reasons behind ur theory and to answer some of the scepticism that others may have about what ur saying.

Cheers

Guilt toy, Im not trying to undermine you or anything, so dont go psycho on me, but what lead you to believe that a "tuned" engine will knock at a different frequency to a stock engine. From what most ppl say here, their knock happens not under foll boost at 6000RPM but under slight load in a high gear at about 2000-3000RPM going up a hill on a hot day.

Ie what im trying to say is that under that scenraio a tuned engine and a stock engine wouldn't be performing materially differently.

Also, if as you say the knock of a highly tuned engine would sound different to a stock engine, this doesnt explain why the knock value is still coming up on the PFC. Perhaps the "real knock" is a different frequency to what the PFC is showing but i would still be concerned that a large noise (consistent with stock engine knock) was coming out of my tuned engine consistently for a certain situation (ie above).

Before u reply Guitl-toy, know that I am not saying u r wrong or ur thery is flawed, I'm just trying to understand the underlying reasons behind ur theory and to answer some of the scepticism that others may have about what ur saying.

Cheers

Usually when a tuner tunes your car he is not going to tune it in 5th gear labouring the shit out of the engine at 2000rpm is he? thats why it knocks. If he did tune it in 5th gear he could get rid of that knocking but you would lose response in other gears at the same part of the map because timing would be retarded and you would have shitloads less mid range and possibly top end as well.

the reason why this happens is because you are in 5th gear the ecu is hovering over that part of the map for a long period of time, after a second or so it will start to heat up and make some noise, If it is only reading 30 - 50 knock at those load levels then it would be nothing to worry about, if you see over 100 every time you go there then try avoid those areas and get your tuner to listen to the car on the dyno to see if he can hear anything, if nothing could be heard then you should ignore the knock readings.

this is a whole different issue then what we are talking about ? i thought we were talking about knocking on boost at mid to high rpm. Every tune i have had back before i started tuning has experienced this low rpm high load knock. Sometimes it can be removed with just a few deg of timing being trimmed other times you cannot remove it at all.

why would you want to hit boost in 5th gear going up a hill and labour your engine ? probly not the best idea anyway.

If you are confused about what this thread is about then here is a quote from the thread starter - 1st post

hey all recently had a pfc installed in my 33 gtst, now wen my car is at full boost and usually around 6200rpm the engine light will flash on and off which i kno is the power fc sensing a knock over 60, it doesnt always do it tho. I took it back to the tuner and he said that he has done a real safe tune (191rwkw) and did a couple more power runs to make sure, and sed coz my car has done round the 170,oookm that is prob just something elses knockin/loose in engine and engine is not at detenation. oh and i hav seen the knock go over 100. Car mods: pfc, fmic, 3.5cat back, walbro pump, pod filter, platnium plugs. Any help would be appreciated cheers jarad
  • 3 weeks later...
  • 2 weeks later...
  • 1 month later...
Guilt toy, are you still coming to melbourne? Wouldnt mind bookink myself in for a knock check on ur gizzmo thing

ohhh crap sorry I missed his. No I aint going to Melbourne. you should call Trent @ Status and he will be able to check it out for you.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now



  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • Well, after the full circus this week (new gearbag, 14 psi actuator on, injectors and AFM upgraded, and.....turbo repair) the diagnosis on the wastegate is in. It was broken. It was broken in a really strange way. The weld that holds the lever arm onto the wastegate flapper shaft broke. Broke completely, but broke in such a way that it could go back together in the "correct" position, or it could rearrange itself somewhere else along the fracture plane and sit with the flapper not parallel to the lever. So, who knows how and when exactly what happened? No-one will ever know. Was it broken like this the first time it spat the circlip and wedged itself deep into the dump? Or was it only broken when I tried to pry it back into place? (I didn't try that hard, but who knows?). Or did it break first? Or did it break between the first and second event of wierdness? Meh. It doesn't matter now. It is welded back together. And it is now held closed by a 14 psi actuator, so...the car has been tuned with the supporting mods (and the order of operations there is that the supporting mods and dyno needed to be able to be done first before adding boost, because it was pinging on <<14 psi with the new turbo with only a 6 psi actuator). And then tuned up a bit, and with the boost controller turned off throughout that process. So it was only running WG pressure and so only hit about 15-16 psi. The turbo is still ever so slightly lazier than might be preferred - like it is still a bit on the big side for the engine. I haven't tested it on the road properly in any way - just driven it around in traffic for a half hour or so. But it is like chalk and cheese compared to what it was. Between dyno numbers and driving feedback: It makes 100 kW at 3k rpm, which is OK, could be better. That's stock 2JZ territory, or RB20 with G series 550. It actually starts building boost from 2k, which is certainly better than it did recently (with all the WG flapper bullshit). Although it's hard to remember what it was like prior to all that - it certainly seems much, much better. And that makes sense, given the WG was probably starting to blow open at anything above about 3 psi anyway (with the 6 psi actuator). It doesn't really get to "full boost" (say 16 psi) until >>4k rpm. I am hopeful that this is a feature of the lack of boost controller keeping boost pressure off the actuator, because it was turned off for the dyno and off for the drives afterward. There's more to be found here, I'm sure. It made 230 rwkW at not a lot more than 6k and held it to over 7k, so there seems to be plenty of potential to get it up to 250-260rwkW with 18 psi or so, which would be a decent effort, considering the stock sized turbo inlet pipework and AFM, and the return flow cooler. According to Tao, those things should definitely put a bit of a limit on it by that sort of number. I must stress that I have not opened the throttle 100% on the road yet - well, at least not 100% and allowed it to wind all the way up. It'll have to wait until some reasonable opportunity. I'm quite looking forward to that - it feels massively better than it has in a loooong time. It's back to its old self, plus about 20% extra powers over the best it ever did before. I'm going to get the boost controller set up to maximise spool and settle at no more than ~17 psi (for now) and then go back on the dyno to see what we can squeeze out of it. There is other interesting news too. I put together a replacement tube to fit the R35 AFM in the stock location. This is the first time the tuner has worked with one, because anyone else he has tuned for has gone from Z32 territory to aftermarket ECU. No-one has ever wanted to stay Nistuned and do what I've done. Anyway, his feedback is that the R35 AFM is super super super responsive. Tiny little changes in throttle position or load turn up immediately as a cell change on the maps. Way, way more responsive than any of the old skool AFMs. Makes it quite diffifult to tune as you have to stay right on top of that so you don't wander off the cell you wanted to tune. But it certainly seems to help with real world throttle response. That's hard to separate from all the other things that changed, but the "pedal feel" is certainly crisp.
    • I'm a bit confused by this post, so I'll address the bit I understand lol.  Use an air compressor and blow away the guide coat sanding residue. All the better if you have a moisture trap for your compressor. You'd want to do this a few times as you sand the area, you wouldn't for example sand the entire area till you think its perfect and then 'confirm' that is it by blowing away the guide coat residue.  Sand the area, blow away the guide coat residue, inspect the panel, back to sanding... rinse and repeat. 
    • The detail level is about right for the money they charge for the full kit... AU$21.00 each issue, 110 issues for a total of $2,300 (I mentioned $2.2K in the first post when the exchange rate was better). $20/week is doable... 馃槓
    • If planning on joining us for the day(s) please indicate by filling in this form. https://forms.gle/Ma8Nn4DzYVA8uDHg7
  • Create New...