Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

Hi guys,

I have had a wierd noise in/on/around my RB25DEt for a while but never got around to do anything with it so 1st off ill explain.

Sepc (if it matters)

1998 R33 GTS25t

59,000km

Stock dump > 3" HKS Front > Decat > HKS Hi-Power Silent Catback

R32 10psi Actuator with stock solenoid removed

Apexi Panel filter

Blitz LM FMIC

This noise only EVER occurs at cold idle. And when i say cold, i mean the block has to have no heat in it at all. So its generally an overnight thing. The next time its started it does it.

It does not ever do it once there is a bit of heat in the engine. So to overcome it i generally let the car warm up for a few mins or so before i drive it. Other than this. Everything sounds/runs mint.

Engine runs strong, never misses a beat. Runs great on the track and drag strip.

And when on a long run, apart from the exhaust you would swear it isnt even idling (when stopped) it is so quiet. Sounds amazing.

So heres the noise. Can anyone identify it? Is it "normal"? Does anyone else have the noise?

The noise is clearly obvious. And it does it anywhere from 1200rpm > 1500rpm. Anything more/less its not there.

A friend of mine on this forum, his RB25DEt also does this, but it is very quiet. Still noticeable, but compared to his mine is like a megaphone is attatched to it.

Can anyone recommend anything?

Thanks in advance for the help. As the noise does bother me.

Edited by gotRICE?
Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/253375-sau-lend-me-your-ears-rb25-noise/
Share on other sites

Timing belt

Timing belt bearings

Water pump

Alternator bearing

VCT camshaft pulley dry

Could be any of these things and more. When was the last time the timing belt was done? and if it was supposedly done before you bought it, just say NFI.

hmmmmmmm.. sounds a bit like piston slap (piston slapping against the side of the bore while cold) but that shouldnt happen in a standard internals engine.. could be something at the little end of the rod... it doesnt sound quite like big end knock.

Timing belt

Timing belt bearings

Water pump

Alternator bearing

VCT camshaft pulley dry

Could be any of these things and more. When was the last time the timing belt was done? and if it was supposedly done before you bought it, just say NFI.

NFI, but i would imagine it hasnt been done since i bought it at 48,000km 1st owner in NZ.

I guess it could have done a million KM from Japan, but the overall appearance of the interior/exterior/seats/underbody would suggest its fairly genuine.

Only way to figure what one it could be would be by changing each one i guess... And does this mean that these problems could become less apparent when they are warm?

NFI, but i would imagine it hasnt been done since i bought it at 48,000km 1st owner in NZ.

I guess it could have done a million KM from Japan, but the overall appearance of the interior/exterior/seats/underbody would suggest its fairly genuine.

Only way to figure what one it could be would be by changing each one i guess... And does this mean that these problems could become less apparent when they are warm?

if its internal and as the car gets warm it goes away it would lead me to believe its to do with the cams and oil, i dont think its internals though, internals normally make a bigger sound,

as for mentioned about about the water pump and alternator etc... i think these are on the right line, one way to check, take the belt of alternator and start the car, if there is no sound, its either you water pump or alternator, try those different things

not block noise Dan ?

Yeah, you are right Gervaise.

I had another listen to it and it does seem like a forged piston rattle. Nothing serious if it's forged pistons inside but I would definitely be making sure you have it running for at least 2 mins before you drive it from cold.

You heard mine aye Bevan? Makes a noise of sorts though I think mine is quieter, was it the same thing? Mine has been doing its noise since I can remember (I remember panicking about it in 2005 when I noticed it from the outside of the car) but 4 years, >60,000km and 100kw on its still fine lol.

Edited by Lithium

Thanks guys

I will give the alternator trick a go and see what happens next time its cold cold.

Then i will think about doing the waterpump/cam belt etc..

I use Motul Turbolite oil. Seems to do the trick. But have recently sourced Royal Purple for a pretty good price so might switch to that next.

I wouldnt know if its forged but i highly doubt it as i bought the car stock standard. So hope its not piston slap!

And yup, was yours Dan my man. I mentioned it when we did the coilpacks. :laugh: Will give these things a try.

mate i personally think it sounds like lifters/tappets. the fact that it goes away once u rev it past 1500rpm and also goes away once the motor is warm would suggest to me its lifters/tappets. try using a thicker oil on ur next oil change annd it should hopefully do the trick :laugh:

mate i personally think it sounds like lifters/tappets. the fact that it goes away once u rev it past 1500rpm and also goes away once the motor is warm would suggest to me its lifters/tappets. try using a thicker oil on ur next oil change annd it should hopefully do the trick :(

Yeah still a bit deeper in pitch than a lifter noise. Usually lifters are a higher pitched tapping noise. You could be right though, it's so hard to tell these things when all you have is a youtube video. I hope is something simple. It's never nice when you find gremlins in your car. :(

  • 11 months later...

Im still stumped.

Noise is still there at the same interval, Cold start, around 1500rpm. And still stops as soon as it starts to warm.

Car still makes fantastic power, and is regularly tracked/drag raced. Drives perfectly...

Switched to Royal Purple Oil/filter's last change and no effect.

Still have my stock pile of waterpump/belts/ tensioners etc. Just havnt got around to getting it done yet ha. Fingers crossed its still one of these.

If not... i guess one day it will go boom.

Mine has done it for a good 70,000kms so far - maybe more... I lose track. I am pretty sure I first noticed it in 2005. Since then its seen track time, god knows how many drag runs (a good number of which reasonably into the 12s) , dyno runs, street driving, compression tests (with good results), 3 different turbos, up to 20psi of boost, a new cam belt and it seems no louder than it was when I first noticed it.

I have no idea what it is, but am pretty sure that if it was bearing noise or a damaged piston skirt I'd have known about it by now!

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • My take on gg2 48mm, 54mm, 58mm, and 62mm compressor map for same size compressor vs gg1 : All gg2 only outflow gg1 above 20 psi. As all g gen 2 surge line at lower left of comp map move to the right, all gg2 sacrifice spool vs same size gg1, surge line move to the right worst for 54mm gg2. So for same size compressor if you want best response, use gg1, if you want max hp at >20psi use gg2 but you will be laggier vs same size gg1. Max compressor efficiency drops to max 75% on all gg2 vs max 76%-80% of same size gg1. Iirc lower efficiency means hotter iat less dense air so lower hp at same operating point of comp map. Also curious why gg2 is mapped to lower max rpm vs same size gg1 (only 48mm size both gg1 gg2 mapped to same rpm) : 54mm gg1 165,000 rpm  vs  gg2 160,000 rpm. 58mm gg1 150,000 rpm vs gg2 140,000rpm. 62mm gg1 145,000 rpm vs gg2 140,000 rpm. If gg2 can safely spin to gg1 rpm then they can flow a bit more than as mapped. Good thing that all gg 2 interchange compressor and turbine housings with same size gg 1. So gg1 owners can buy gg2 chra only if planning to boost >20psi.
    • My stuff is all with Shannon's, granted, I don't really have imports I'm driving on the road, however, I've had multiple cars at the same time with them. Presently we have the Landcruiser on laid up cover, Sarah's Kluger on full cover, and the house insured. About 18 months ago Sarah wrote her Subaru Liberty GTB off, insured with Shannon's, and the payout, and buy back of the wreck was super quick. In 2020 we had the VF Commodore totalled in a major hailstorm. Storm was on the Saturday, I called on the Sunday and lodged it, vehicle was towed on Tuesday night, assessment team called on Wednesday to say it was a total loss and get payout details, money was in the bank on Thursday morning. Have had a few other claims both at fault, and not at fault, over the years, and never had an issue with them.   Funnily enough, they're also the cheapest insurer I find for things like Sarah's Kluger.   I will say I'm less impressed dealing with them lately around "the experience", as a lot of their staff that you deal with aren't car enthusiasts. Shannon's has a much more main stream feel ever since they decided to become "big corporate", laid a heap of staff off, and then hired a bunch of non enthusiasts. At the same time they've been making a push to be less "call us and we'll personally have someone who cares help" to "hey, this computer can do stuff for you" and are trying to get more square pegs to fit round holes. (That's just the vibe I get from them). Again, have had no issues with claims with them, but get a bit of a "less personal" feel from them.
    • A thing I wasn’t happy with with enthusiast was during the initial phone call they told me they’d insure it for 130k but needed photos.   I then sent them photos and they told me $80k as there were other cars either similar modifications available for around that price, I told them to send me the links to said cars so that I can buy them. i then sent the modification list with prices of the parts (no labor) and the price then came to 115k, which is still shy of the 130 that was agreed in the initial phone call 
    • Ask me a bit later this week before payday
    • I agree that delayed payment probably isn't the most suitable solution. It seems a solid complete transaction would be best. As I wouldn't be using this sale as a line of credit that would typically earn interest, we can probably arrange a much cleaner single transaction deal. I can do $92.52 today. Would you prefer EFT, or Cash on Pickup?  😛
×
×
  • Create New...