Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

The primary need is to atomise the water as fine as possible, and I use the Spraying systems nozzle as identified in the autospeed article for both applications. I have the intake spray after the intercooler in the line where the air velocity is higher so there is less chance the water might settle out to pool. Before the IC it could settle out as the velocities reduce, much like an oil catch can or dry sump, although I doubt it with the heat. It is on a rising pipe as well so any overspraying or activation when the engine is not running will have the water run down to the intercooler. Just worried about hydrostatic lock. It is really a worthy upgrade.

  • Replies 70
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

What water does is raise the detonation threshold.

To understand what this is, you need to understand detonation. What happens with detonation is that the trapped mixture is ignited by the spark and begins to burn in the area immediately around the plug. This burning causes the (mostly)nitrogen in the air to expand from the heat and increase the chamber pressure.

Now the burning continues until all the mixture is burned and pressure and temperature reach a maximum, usually at about 20 degrees ATDC. The ignition timing is early enough to always get the maximum at around 20 degrees ATDC.

What can happen though, is that the pressure and temperature in the chamber can get high enough to cause not burning but a spontaneous EXPLOSION. The whole lot detonates like a bomb creating a huge shock wave that breaks things.

So it is temperature and pressure that causes detonation. So you must lower the temperature and pressure reached DURING ACTUAL COMBUSTION(or use a less detonation prone fuel).

One way is to inject water. It does not have to be fully vaporised before it reaches the engine. Even a solid jet of water is going to flash into steam either during the compression stroke, or actual combustion. It is the high latent heat of water that lowers the peak combustion temperature and reduces detonation.

Another interesting feature is that the steam expands along with the nitrogen in the air to act as the working fluid that pushes down the piston. So although peak temperatures are much reduced, the pressures are not, and you lose no power by adding water, in fact you gain a bit.

A lot of people do not realise that it is the nitrogen in the air that does not burn which actually pushes the piston down. And steam works even better.

The reason I suggested fuel injectors is because they can meter in precise small quantities into every cylinder, and the fine spray is going to assist vaporisation.

Spraying water into the turbo inlet also works, but like fuel distribution, you have no way of knowing if that water is going to find its way into all cylinders in equal quantity. It will if it is fully vaporised, but it may not be.

Warpspeed

I like your explanation, saved me from digging through my archives although I would suggest that the nitrogen is not the only working fluid, even though it takes up some 70% of the atmosphere. This was the reason for oxygen injecting the Lynx 1.8 with stock exhaust and pod filter to achieve low 7 second 0-100 times. Also used an extra injector and water injection off a throttle switch to activate it all and activated it at over 3000rpm for a huge push from the little machine.

Anyway, have to go look for some new pistons. Time to go to that forged piston thread after the bearings went west and scored #3 big end journal and cracked 2 pistons prior to the water injection.

Yes you are right. The other gasses and fuel do not just disappear, but the nitrogen working fluid is something that fascinated me when I first learned of it.

It is also why nitrous oxide works so well, it is mostly nitrogen (N2O). I believe pure oxygen will increase combustion temperatures and can lead you up the dreaded detonation path, so be careful.

One way is to inject water. It does not have to be fully vaporised before it reaches the engine. Even a solid jet of water is going to flash into steam either during the compression stroke, or actual combustion. It is the high latent heat of water that lowers the peak combustion temperature and reduces detonation.

Yes, everything you said is true, but I still stand by my claim that injecting the water further up the intake piping will give it more time to effect it's intake charge temperature drop, rather than an instantaneous conversion from liquid -> gas if you were to squirt it down the runners.

Also atomised water will absorb a lot more heat than a "solid jet of water", as it has a lot more surface area. Using fuel injectors will not achieve this at all.

You are right, early complete vaporisation WILL remove heat from the intake charge, and lower induction temperatures. No argument there. Also lower charge temperatures mean more density, and this is extremely important for power production. So I agree.

But reducing detonation is a completely different thing to producing power. Detonation is only due to the peak temperature and pressure reached during actual combustion. Provided a certain mass of water is totally turned to vapor (boiled) the specific heat will reduce the final combustion temperature, and combustion will remain controlled.

So purely from detonation point of view it does not really matter where the water is introduced, or where along the chain of events it all finally boils off. During combustion it most certainly will all boil because the temperatures are so high.

Once again you are getting to the crux of the discussion. The cooler air is good, but the volume of water to cool the air is a tradeoff that sees no benefit from the cooler, denser charge. It is the detonation suppression that is the real benefit in introducing water to the cylinders.

I agree with Warpspeed, I think the water would flash into steam due to the heat.

Hydrolic lock is the big fear, thats why you have a safety solonoid valve in the system that stops the engine drawing water down the tube when not in boost cycle. Also stops dribbling etc.

I'm going down the path of an individual fogging nozzle in each runner with a computer controlled pump (inputs: RPM, Boost, Water Pressure).

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now



  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • Don't use "gasless MIG" (FCAW) you want to use proper MIG. FCAW burns a few hundred degrees hotter than MIG will for mild steel. It is a true ball ache for sheet metal. New MIG / TIG machines even have features like "Spot Weld" as well as "Automatic" settings. Plenty of people say for DIY home hobby, the auto machines are pretty good for 95% of welding. I personally, I'm a sucker for punishment and wanting to dial it in, and be able to adjust the machine. Mainly because I used to MIG weld for a living, and being able to tweak and tune things ever so slightly was my preference. Hence when I bought my ACDC TIG, it has all the adjustments for everything and no "easy" mode. Ha ha I have stick, MIG, "gaslessMIG" and ACDC TIG at home. Out of them, if you're doing mild steel sheet metal repair, and want to do mild steel exhausts, go MIG. If you're thinking you'll want to get into doing some aluminium stuff, or stainless steel, get an ACDC TIG with HF start. If you can, get one with a foot pedal too. My MIG machine is a UniMIG, and my Stick/TIG is CigWeld. If I were buying another machine, I'd buy another CIGWeld. Lots of people having issues with UniMIG, and them not wanting to cover warranty. Everything has to go back to UNIMig themselves. CIGWeld, I've had to use their warranty on my machine for a gas leak, they have repair centres everywhere, (contracted authorised repair centres). First repair place I used were hopeless, but the second place were amazing. Warranty process itself super easy, and second repair place was telling me CigWeld actually cover in their warranty, upto an hour of techs time to help you with your machine, and going through the settings and helping teach you the machine. UniMIG keep trying to get out of replacing motherboards on 12 month old machines.   TLDR, mild steel sheet welding, buy a MIG. my vote is CigWeld for brand.
    • I guess that's what happens when someone can't convert metric to freedom units to machine something. 😛
    • I've watched some vids and the technique seems to be to butt the sheets up to one another and use MIG to spot weld and slowly fill in the spots until its eventually all sealed. No runs as you would normally do, as there's too much heat generated that way. Yeah my stick welds are terrible these days because its been so long since i've done any of it. I expect to be spending many hours practicing
    • I have personally seen a Tomei USA RB26 cam that didn't even fit the head. Kind of nuts to me that it was even possible for that to happen but such is life.  There's two UP Garages in the US. One is a US branch of the Japanese company which sells things they brought over at tremendous markup. The other is University Place Garage/Fairlady Motors which is a shop best known for putting VCAM in RBs and trying to convince people to stop putting in 800hp of turbo on a 2.5L motor.
    • Gasless MIG is not exactly suited to what I would call "delicate" or "attractive" welding. So I would rule it out for sheet metal rust repair type stuff, unless you're only doing it in hidden places. I'm thinking about getting myself a gasless MIG for "hack together" type work. Noting that my welding experience is very very low, and quite a long time ago. So I'm also looking for "simple", but I'm not expecting "excellent". I'm not even sure that proper MIG is the best for sheet metal work. I get the feeling that the degree of control and the minimisation of heat input that you get from TIG is probably what you really want. And then you have to get good at doing it before the welds won't look like a monkey flinging a handful of shit anyway. You're probably SOL for an easy and cheap way to get from where you are to where you want to be. Much like myself.
×
×
  • Create New...