Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

Also we can install a big 32mm disc and machine 30mm internal gates @ $100 for who ever wants to get it done.

r33turbinehousing2.jpg

Hi Tao,

What is the advantage of doing this? Will it help run 18-20psi flat without your wastegate controller?

I think that the boost drop issues with the high flows, is more to do with the comp housing rather than the turbine housing.

I remember that slides high flows use to do it aswel and so do the older GCG units.

I dont think the little Nissan comp housing can flow enough air for the target power level.

Have you guys checked on the dyno if its the gate that's creeping open...its easy enough to see.

I still think that its intake side related rather than the hot side of it all.

The thing is Hypergear use an extra fitting called a 'wastegate controller' which limits the wastegate from opening past a certain point. And this does fix the issue, so it is a hot side issue. Tao explained it as the actuator spring cannot handle the force involved. I dont understand why a stronger spring cant be fitted to compensate.

I saw that "wastegate controller" but it looks a bit dodge..what happens on a cold night and the gate needs to open further, etc etc, Stao offered to fit one to mine, but being that its a track car i cant risk having epic boost spike issues etc

Exactly right! This is my point as well.

It looks very dodge. A stronger actuator would fix everything! And be the proper way of doing it.

My previous car I ran straight off a 17psi actuator. It controlled boost very well and the cops couldnt see any form of boost control. Yes I could increase how hard the boost hit with an aftermarket boost controller but it was already very hard and it wasnt worth it to me for the extra defect risk.

Edited by Harey

if a $4k HKS kit of very similar size can't hold boost flat to redline, what exactly are you expecting from a similar sized highflow unit at a quarter of the cost????????

.63 does NOT hold boost to redline. Simple as that, end of story. And that is by no means a slight on Stao's turbo's, they're great units. But ANY manufacturer, or similar specs, will get very similar boost curves. I don't see what the problem is really. Go out and buy a HKS 2835 ProS (or more like a GTRS which is comparable to most of the highflows we'd be buying) if you really want to try something different... it'll be pretty much the same story.

if a $4k HKS kit of very similar size can't hold boost flat to redline, what exactly are you expecting from a similar sized highflow unit at a quarter of the cost????????

.63 does NOT hold boost to redline. Simple as that, end of story. And that is by no means a slight on Stao's turbo's, they're great units. But ANY manufacturer, or similar specs, will get very similar boost curves. I don't see what the problem is really. Go out and buy a HKS 2835 ProS (or more like a GTRS which is comparable to most of the highflows we'd be buying) if you really want to try something different... it'll be pretty much the same story.

That pretty much sums it up, and as most people say an external gate really is the only option...no point on a highflow imo because that defeats the purpose, best option is to tune around it...ie add more timing as the boost drops off.

if a $4k HKS kit of very similar size can't hold boost flat to redline, what exactly are you expecting from a similar sized highflow unit at a quarter of the cost????????

.63 does NOT hold boost to redline. Simple as that, end of story. And that is by no means a slight on Stao's turbo's, they're great units. But ANY manufacturer, or similar specs, will get very similar boost curves. I don't see what the problem is really. Go out and buy a HKS 2835 ProS (or more like a GTRS which is comparable to most of the highflows we'd be buying) if you really want to try something different... it'll be pretty much the same story.

For a start we are talking about a PU hi flow which has the standard front but an aftermarket 0.82 rear. So not a 0.63.

He can get it to hold 20+psi to redline with his wastegate controller!! This means it is possible, its just the actuator is not strong enough to hold it on its own. By limiting the movement of the actuator arm, it does hold 20+psi to redline.

If it wasnt possible, no problem, its just I havent seen a reason from Hypergear and it seems they are designing there own modifications instead of sticking with the standard operation of an internally wastegated turbo.

sorry, thought we were talking about .63's.... think i got confused between this thread and Ruffels thread..

never tried a .82 myself unfortunately.

The thing is Hypergear use an extra fitting called a 'wastegate controller' which limits the wastegate from opening past a certain point. And this does fix the issue, so it is a hot side issue. Tao explained it as the actuator spring cannot handle the force involved. I dont understand why a stronger spring cant be fitted to compensate.

If a stronger spring, say a 25psi spring was fitted then the boost will spike to 25psi(Alot more than you obviously want to run) and then slowly taper off to say 18psi. External gate, Stoa's gate controller or deal with the drop off are your only options

Please focus some attention here:

The boost drop issues mentioned was based on a .63 housing. Not .82 turbine housing.

The wastegate controller is a ideal solution to actuator not been able to hold boost. and believe me I've tried the strongest Garrett Big can actuator that fits. It picked up more boost in mid range but doing the exact same thing towards red line.

Lets put it in this way. I installed a 20psi actautor on a .63 turbine housing with a GT3076 CHRA. It will hold boost fine till exhaust manifold pressure reaches certain level. So you will have 18psi by 4500RPM and have 15psi by 7000RPM.

Forget about the 20psi actuator. I will install a 60psi actuator out of a tractor. You will get uncontrollable boost creep reaching 60psi by 4500RPM and have a boost drop to maybe 30psi at 7000RPM.

People need to understand the pressure inside a turbine housing is NOT FIXED. and can not be controlled with a fixed Variable actuator spring. and Whats going to creep boost?? The stronger actuator you install the greater boost spike through out mid range you will have.

We have an example here. SSGOhan here's running a high flow with a OP6 housing with a 20psi actuator. See what’s happening here? his getting 18psi with no boost controller and experience a boost drop to 16psi at red line.

This is not due to cold side. Which is why people running .82 turbine housings experience none of very little boost drop compare to people running .63 housings, even thou the CHRA are in same size. and I'm the person implanted this theory as seeing HKS2530 have issues holding boost, This might be the case as its only running a 60mm comp wheel which we are not.

Wastegate controller.

I'm not interested in what it looks. I'm only interested to solve a problem. or realistically every one should be running an external gates.

Engine size and RPM is directly linked to manifold pressure. Wastegate controller is only made to act from 6000RPMs and on wards. Meaning I'm using a actuator to control my boost level pre 5000RPM and using the wastegate controller to act against a some how more fixed pressure range.

Also if it has been dyno adjusted to get a constant boost level with bonnet fully opened sitting on front of a massive cooling fan. Then its unlikely to get boost creep once bonnet shuts with engine bay temp 5 times higher then what it was.

Once again, people do not have to run the wastegate controller if they don't support my idea. I’m not charging extra for it and it can be taken off to create none affect.

Has it been tested. Yes it has been tested, Please refer to the 290rwkws high flow running 19psi to red line.

Stao, where could i obtain one of these 20psi actuators that SSgohan has?

also if you have tested proof of your wastegate controller, i should be free this week end to install it

Just a quick question, im thinking of building a RB25/30 for a GU patrol, i have a blown R33 turbo allready. With this highflowed would it be a good match for a 25/30? Im not after massive power as i will only be using stock injectors etc, im more after torque being its going into a 4wd. I just dont want to choke the engine.

Thanks.

Just a quick question, im thinking of building a RB25/30 for a GU patrol, i have a blown R33 turbo allready. With this highflowed would it be a good match for a 25/30? Im not after massive power as i will only be using stock injectors etc, im more after torque being its going into a 4wd. I just dont want to choke the engine.

Thanks.

Stock R33 turbo is too small for a RB30det. We can do a PU high flow for it running .82 rear with ATR43G1 profile. will do about 450HP with excellent street response and plenty of torque for tolling.

Please focus some attention here:

The boost drop issues mentioned was based on a .63 housing. Not .82 turbine housing.

We have an example here. SSGOhan here's running a high flow with a OP6 housing with a 20psi actuator. See what’s happening here? his getting 18psi with no boost controller and experience a boost drop to 16psi at red line.

Wastegate controller.

Has it been tested. Yes it has been tested, Please refer to the 290rwkws high flow running 19psi to red line.

Thanks Tao for the detailed response. This is great info.

You mentioned at the start that the boost drop issues were only with a 0.63 housing and yet the tested example you use is the 290rwkw hiflow which I understand runs the 0.82 housing??

If there are no boost drop issues with the 0.82 housing why would you still use the wastegate controller with them?

At the end of the day IW even 0.82 experince boost drop of some kind of maybe 1 or 2 psi the most reliable way to hold it is external but if you dont want that then just put up with the slight drop as said before it is not the wrost thing to be dropping a few psi from 18 on a stock engine at redline and if stao has a solution with as he has said and it works well then use it but normal acutor and IW your always likely to drop abit of boost off at top

Why is it not possible to hold boost to redline using an internally gated 0.82 housing??

See below thread:

http://www.skylinesaustralia.com/forums/Gt...ge+can+actuator

Conan7772 has the classic problem of dropping a few psi to redline, he resolves this by fitting a higher pressure large can actuator. He manages to hold 22psi flat as f*ck I think was how he put it :).

See dyno sheet (post 26 on page 2):

http://www.skylinesaustralia.com/forums/post-a257703-

Edited by Harey

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now



  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • In a few years from now, you'll regret that. It'll eat away at you, knowing the truth of the ugly hiding beneath the beautiful exterior... 😛
    • I don't think the G2 profile is particularly dangerous for the engine per se, more just are you actually ok with the turbo lag trade-offs? If the answer is yes then go for it. I personally don't think I'd be ok with it because I spend so much time at lower RPMs and I really enjoy the feeling of being able to stay in 5th gear on the highway and just roll into the throttle to get boost. Or staying in 3rd gear on "gentle canyon cruises" without feeling the turbo lag too badly. The 525 pump should be able to run flat out on factory lines but I would bet the pressure drop from pump to regulator is quite impressive. I don't know how much it would be exactly but I've seen figures like 30 psi thrown around.
    • It's interesting seeing everyone talk about what level of risk they are happy to tolerate.  Building a GTR always has a level of risk, you could be that lucky guy that drops 20k on the engine build alone and still has the thing go pop on the dyno. Life is fun like that.  The way I see it, the thing is a toy to be enjoyed. I'd be happy to turn up the power on stock motor and limit the risk with sensible tuning and engine protection. If it still goes pop, it is what it is. The car isn't a daily driver so it can happily sit while a plan is made to sort it out.  Given this thing will be a street car only, I really feel it's worth the (relatively small if managed well) risk to turn the power up to around 350KW on e85.  I don't think anyone getting into the skyline game now is doing it out of logic. Surely it is a purely emotional decision so I'm not sure how important it is to think about the engine build logically. The heart wants what it wants.  @joshuaho96 little note for Josh, I run my 525 pump flat out all the time and through the factory lines without any issues. (excluding the melting connectors, that's sorted now. we'll pretend it never happened lol)
    • But the Nexus S3 is very expensive and won't be as purpose-built for the application as a separate electronic boost controller :^) More seriously my pet issue here would be that the Walbro 525 running at 100% duty cycle is going to require more FPR than the stock setup can handle. I'm also pretty sure from what I've seen elsewhere you might want to slow down the pump regardless unless you're going to come up with some way of upsizing the fuel lines coming from the fuel tank. Factory 8mm fuel line doesn't actually flow very much if you want to keep pressure drop down between the fuel pump outlet and FPR. If you really want to "keep it simple" I would run only as much pump as you need and source a fuel pump controller to slow down the pump in the vain hope of being able to run stock-style FPRs which are pretty dinky. Or just use the HICAS lines and it should be mostly fine. OP should also really think hard about what profile they'd want out of the turbo. My pet choice here would be the G1 profile rather than anything higher power but YMMV. I already think ~stock turbo lag is pretty bad so I don't want to make it worse. In "gentle canyon cruising" I found that I spent a lot of time around 4-4.5k RPM. I also recommend DIYing labor if you're detail-oriented enough. Costs are high for labor + if you do it yourself you can be your own quality control.
    • GTSBoy is again on the money. My actual advice? Sell the car. (really). For what it's worth as is, you can sidegrade into something much better. If you care about function then this is the actual move. If you want a Skyline to perform, set aside about $100K to do it. This is NOT a typo. You will see right away these are two very different mindsets. Realistically we're talking full restomod for any Skyline still kicking around. Have an honest think about which one you are.. and what you want to do, and how much you want to invest in this (with no return).
×
×
  • Create New...