Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

Hi,

Just wondering what some peoples fc commanders read as peak knock when driving hard? What level should it stay under and what would be high enough to cause damage (shortened engine life etc..)? I have noticed mine has read up to 23 but more recently on fresh optimax only 13. What is acceptable as it has been tuned by a well known and reputable dyno tuner.

Thanks

Jamie

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/27516-knock-sensor-on-power-fc/
Share on other sites

Originally posted by «Cyph3r»

Hi,

Just wondering what some peoples fc commanders read as peak knock when driving hard? What level should it stay under and what would be high enough to cause damage (shortened engine life etc..)? I have noticed mine has read up to 23 but more recently on fresh optimax only 13. What is acceptable as it has been tuned by a well known and reputable dyno tuner.

Thanks

Jamie

i think you're sweet as long as it stays under around 50-60

The fact is you'll get lot's of different answers from lots of different people about this. If the tuner has done a good job there should be no pinging, check what the highest level you get under hard driving conditions, add a bit of a buffer, and you will have a reasonably safe knock level. If 23 is the highest you've achieved while driving hard, then it shouldn't go much past 30 unless something has changed, so might be worth backing off to check.

The knock sensor picks up all engine noises, not just pinging, so the level will be different between cars.

the check engine light flashes when it hits 60, as mentioned I dont think there is too much of a problem if it is under that, personnaly as GTSt has suggested, I keep an eye on it and if it increases much over any period of time it tells me perhaps I need to be careful - dirty plugs, changes in humidity or temperature etc.

I believe it is a guide only. I have had a tune where it regularly went up to 50-60, and no damage was done. The lowest I have seen is now, where it pretty much always sits below 20.

The highest I have seen is 98, no apparent damage, BUT I always back off when the check engine light flashes.

I hope that helps.

  • 7 months later...
Hi,

Just wondering what some peoples fc commanders read as peak knock when driving hard? What level should it stay under and what would be high enough to cause damage (shortened engine life etc..)? I have noticed mine has read up to 23 but more recently on fresh optimax only 13. What is acceptable as it has been tuned by a well known and reputable dyno tuner.

Thanks

Jamie

How do you know what the maximum reading is ? I have PFC and data logit but dont know how to retrieve things like max rpm, max knock etc ???

SK, you out there ?

Hmmmm, It's been said before, but the knock reading on the PFC is an arbitrary value. It is an indication of knock only not a scientific measurement.

The differences between sensors and each particualr engine is enough to make so many differences in tolerance that you can only ever use it a s a rule of thumb.

I know that when my car was tuned previously the dyno op insisted that he could hear no knock from the engine even though the PFC readout was displaying upwards of 60. I have occasionaly seen in excess of 90 (but like Steve I would always lift off in this situation) and having recently stripped my engine found absolutely no det related damage.

My new build shows less than 30 even at more than 1 bar of boost :rant:

  • 5 months later...

I got 84 knock last night 2nd gear came out of a corner sideways not reving hard with 4 people in the car... engine light flashed quickly then dispeared....

Would this have done much damamge if any??? it hasnt effected the knock levels since... I just shit myself when it happened.

My usualy knock level for casual driving with a few squirts is around 10-22 knock on PFC

  • 2 months later...

nah no way dude. I occasionaly get get 2 on start up... When the engine is cold i get read outs of up to 15( i drive slow when im warming up... ie. shift <3000rpm)

on hard open throttle on a cold night i get about 15-25 knock which is good... You arent too far off the mark in regards to wide open throttle but if you are getting 10-15 when starting you might want to get things checked out. Bear in mind knock sensors pick up mechanical noise aswell so it may be even the starter motor.

Take it to Benny at Race pace. i think many people will agree that BENNY IS THE KING OFF SKYLINE

I normally have a readout of 2 or 4 on start up.

I took note of my max readouts the other day in a controlled environment.

duty- 32.0%

timing - 44 deg.

A/F - 3810mv

revs - 4520

speed - 167kmh

water temp - 81

knock - 69

These were taken at night time at a cooler temp and I always use ultimate.

Are these the max readouts? Is this the info to use to see how its runnin?

On hot days I have had knock readouts of up to 90 and once I got a 120! Of course I always keep an eye on it and I back off when it does start knockin.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • Very decent bit of kit. Definitely black it out I reckon.  
    • Because people who want that are buying euros. The people with the money to buy the aftermarket heads and blocks aren’t interested in efficiency or making -7 power, they’re making well over 1,000hp and pretty much only drive them at full throttle  best way to way make money is know your customer base and what they want and don’t spend money making things they don’t want. 
    • It's not, but it does feel like a bit of a missed opportunity regardless. For example, what if the cylinder head was redesigned to fit a GDI fuel system? It's worth like two full points of compression ratio when looking at modern GDI turbo vs PFI turbo. I'm pretty reliably surprised at how much less turbo it takes to make similar power out of a modern engine vs something like an RB26. Something with roughly the same dimensions as a -7 on an S55 is making absolutely silly power numbers compared to an RB26. I know there's a ton of power loss from things like high tension rings, high viscosity oil, clutch fan, AWD standby loss, etc but it's something like 700 whp in an F80 M3 vs 400 whp in an R33 GTR. The stock TF035HL4W turbos in an F80 M3 are really rather dinky little things and that's enough to get 400 whp at 18 psi. This just seems unwise no? I thought the general approach is if you aren't knock limited the MFB50 should be held constant through the RPM range. So more timing with RPM, but less timing with more cylinder filling. A VE-based table should accordingly inverse the VE curve of the engine.
    • I've seen tunes from big name workshops with cars making in excess of 700kW and one thing that stood out to me, is that noone is bothering with torque management. Everyone is throwing in as much timing as the motor can take for a pull. Sure that yields pretty numbers on a dyno, but it's not keeping these motors together for more than a few squirts down the straight without blowing coolant or head gaskets. If tuners, paid a bit more attention and took timing out in the mid range, managed boost a bit better, you'll probably see less motors grenading. Not to name names, or anything like that, but I've seen a tune, from a pretty wild GT-R from a big name tuner and I was but perplexed on the amount of timing jammed into it. You would have expected a quite a bit less timing at peak torque versus near the limiter, but there was literally 3 degrees of difference. Sure you want to make as much as possible throughout the RPM range, but why? At the expense of blowing motors? Anyhow I think we've gone off topic enough once again lol.
    • Because that’s not what any of them are building these heads or blocks for. It’s to hold over over 1000hp at the wheels without breaking and none of that stuff is required to make power 
×
×
  • Create New...