Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 55
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted Images

For me protection qualities far outweigh a few kw...

in any case the variables could not be kept constant enough not to allow for slight variations...diff oil temp,gearbox oil temp,boost pressure,ambient air temp,the list goes on...vince is a nice bloke but this test means sh1t to me .

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/278212-top-5-oil-test/#findComment-4703417
Share on other sites

Not really into it cos they missed a few things like whether they warmed the cars up to operating temp e.g 80+ degrees for the oil and the rpms can never be accurate as your controlling them by foot so each run could be up to 100rpm off.

im glad motul did well though as thats the brand im sticking with and i run castrol edge in my beema.

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/278212-top-5-oil-test/#findComment-4704396
Share on other sites

i ran Repsol sythetic oil in my w/shop for over 5 years, also run it in my go-karts, have found it to be excellent. At the end of the day people all have their favourite, just make sure when you buy an engine oil that it has been API tested which is an independent testing proceedure that tests that the oil meets or exceeds the specs specified. Alot of oils on the shelf at your local auto part store have not had this testing, therefore might not meet the specs specified....it is a round stamp on the back of the container that will have API SJ/SL for example. It costs the oil company a pretty penny to have this testing, probably why they all dont do it. Also dont mix up oil grade with oil viscosity which is a common mistake. Running the incorrect viscosity oil could see you loose performance. while the incorrect grade could cause damage and or blockages in late model common rail diesels.

im not surprised the Castrol performed poorly. Castrol was a swear word in my shop lol.

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/278212-top-5-oil-test/#findComment-4704629
Share on other sites

I did a similar test on an STI once but never released it because the the STI was so in-consistant due to the " self learning" ECU it has.

Even with identical oil temp, air temps and same oil, it couldnt even do a back to back run that was similar ( it had a front mount so heat soak wasnt an issue)

Thats why I dont pay too much attention to these sort of tests. i look at oil pressure under various circumstances, engine wear and the oils condition after track days etc.

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/278212-top-5-oil-test/#findComment-4704751
Share on other sites

These tests are pretty useless, as has been said there are way too many variables that can't be controlled - one of the less obvious (but most impacting) variables being the climate / ambient temperature of the place where your car is driven/stored. Start up and cool down is where a great deal of engine wear occurs.

I use GW Sougi 6000 myself, but I sell the stuff so that's only natural :(

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/278212-top-5-oil-test/#findComment-4704838
Share on other sites

aside from the question mark of the fan being much closer in the nulon test, i'd also want a separate test of each oil run for 5,000km in normal driving and then a UOA done on it. I care more about protecting my engine than 5kw.

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/278212-top-5-oil-test/#findComment-4705431
Share on other sites

What up.

I should be here more, I'm a GTR fan that got lost and bought 3 Silvias

but you love them all :)

ive seen your ns sig

something along the lines of

my family is complete s13 daily, jet200 track and s15 missus car
Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/278212-top-5-oil-test/#findComment-4706763
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now



  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • Yeah its bad eh. Ey! Watch your mouth. Yep, spot on. The rear's are always gone too though from brake checking. I had them perilously close to a tree that we had taken down. I think the tree peeps may have taken it. Either for a trophy, or accidentally.  
    • f**kin' yikes! That insulation is the shittest stuff I have ever seen. You need to do an insurance job on that f**ker, pronto. WRT to the washer cover, I would have said that there'd have to be some at a wrecker, then remembered that it's a BMW, and reasoned that every single wrecked one would have been tailgating and so the front end would be trashed.
    • Oh and I lost my headlight washer jet cover!
    • Ok, so I got myself some X1 wheels really cheap to try out, they're a bit different and I like them but they're really narrow (18x8) they are available in staggered 18x8/9 also but really hard to find.  I kinda dig them, but not as much as the F10 19's I usually run, so these go into the wheel pile.         As I mentioned in another thread, I got a new exhaust. It's an off-the-shelf stainless one that fits OH-KAY. I don't love the tips size and how far they come out the back, I think I might cut the tips off and replace with some smaller (~3") ones that don't extend as far. It sounds really good though, I'm not sure if its just in my head but the car feels a little quicker, more responsive.      I fitted an eBay special front lip. Surprisingly it fit perfectly and all holes lined up. Its a little rickety but I haven't put any double sided tape on yet, I want to clean the front bar up where it has scraped the road a lot and fil in the number plate holes (or, get body coloured wrap to cover them - is this a thing?  I'm not sure if I'll leave it gloss or pain it matte. I really like it though, I don't particularly like the front bar without it, I don't really like the M-Sport and to get anything else is just too expensive. That said, I might need a new one now anyway as I dropped the car onto the jack after forgetting to put ramps under the front wheels. It bent a lot and while it did go back to normal after I got the car off the jack, I do fear I have not done it any favours.    Lastly, my headlights died. Different problems in each. They have gotten much dimmer over the past year or so, I put new (uber expensive) OSRAM bulbs in them but to no avail. One of them pointed at the ground and the other just kinda did its own thing with light working sometimes. Yeah, check this 18 year old BMW headlight wire. I reckon I know why they were stuffed.            BTW, the yellow and black is the power to the Xenons. Yikes. I hunted around an researched my options here. I would have loved to just get a replacement harness but not a thing. My car has adaptive headlights, that is they rotate left and right with the steering wheel. Good condition used adaptive xenons were over $700 each, non adaptive were around $400 each, but I couldn't help but think that they're all around 18 years old now, surely they'd have the same problems. So I looked at newer LCI headlights but they were even more expensive and I couldn't confirm that they'd be plug and play with lots of people having lots of opinions so not worth the risk.  I ended up getting brand new Chinese headlights from MARS. They're very close to OEM with only the angel eyes being a bit different. I didnt want crazy turn signals or sharp DRL's or anything. Not my bag.  They're not adaptive, I thought thats a feature I wouldn't really miss. So I coded that out.  The lights are awesome, they look so nice and they take so many years off the car. The angel eyes look great and the headlight brightness is ridiculous. I was so used to the old ones, I didn't realise just how bad they were. The new ones use the OEM bulbs, Xenon ballast and leveller motor which I was happier with. The only issue with them is that the rear cover is held on by SEVEN screws. This will be a nightmare to get to and open when I need to change bulbs.   
×
×
  • Create New...