Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

hey guys i'm torn between the castrol edge 5w-30 and the motul turbolight 4100 10w-40 for my next service. would like to know pros and cons for both and past experiences. i've read the oil thread and i know the motul gets heaps of good praise but i want to know about castrol edge more from the people that use it especially with the hotter months closing in.

another question i wanted to know is if castrol vmx 80 will be fine for my gearbox and if not what other alternative around that price range would be better? also what can i put into my diff?

i have a daily r33 gtst series II with 105,000kms. thanks

5w-30 will protect better when cold, but depending on the condition on the motor the hot rating might be too thin, you'll only know you have blowby issues is by going ahead and trying it.

5w-30 will protect better when cold, but depending on the condition on the motor the hot rating might be too thin, you'll only know you have blowby issues is by going ahead and trying it.

hi there guys, i'm facing the same problem choosing the correct oil for my v35 ,engine model vq25dd, hope one of you may be able to advise me of a suitable oil. I live in botswana and it's a similar climate, very hot, i have a choice of shell 25w-60w,15w-40w, castrol magnatic, havoline semi synthetic? which do you think i should use

hi there guys, i'm facing the same problem choosing the correct oil for my v35 ,engine model vq25dd, hope one of you may be able to advise me of a suitable oil. I live in botswana and it's a similar climate, very hot, i have a choice of shell 25w-60w,15w-40w, castrol magnatic, havoline semi synthetic? which do you think i should use

No other choices than the above 3 (I'd probably chooce Shell or Havoline, hate lowspec Castrol oil)?

If 25w-60 and 15w40 are the only options, then 15w-40 I would choose, 25w is just too thick when cold.

thanks for your input guys. ended up getting the motul.

been recommended vmx m and not the vmx 80. does anyone know the difference? also would like to know if the nulon 75w-90 semi synth smooth shift gear oil would be suitable. nulon suggests their 75w-85 100% synthetic but would liek to know if the semi synth will do fine?

Castrol Transmax M is used for automatics

Castrol Transmax M

A mineral oil based, general purpose, automatic transmission fluid for use in a wide range of automatic transmission applications

thanks for your input guys. ended up getting the motul.

been recommended vmx m and not the vmx 80. does anyone know the difference? also would like to know if the nulon 75w-90 semi synth smooth shift gear oil would be suitable. nulon suggests their 75w-85 100% synthetic but would liek to know if the semi synth will do fine?

its been proven before and if your gbox is in good nick stick to vmx80 and you will be fine

In a good condition RB25 I HIGHLY recommend Fuchs 10w30, Bursons stock it, Have been running it in the Stagea for 40k km, motor is cleaner, smoother, more economical than when i first got it, i have run motul once, wasnt a fan.

Their 10w40 is another option. Motul 300v I understand, but the lower end stuff I dont get the hype. Chuckie has had his oil regularly tested up to 20k km and the fuchs doesn't deteriorate.

Same, smells nice too.. :(

Had a workshop replace the transfer case for me, they put in decent gearbox oil but it doesn't like it, 4th and 5th synchros are a bitch. Going to dump it and go back to the vmx80 that I was running before without an issue.

Ive never had a problem with castrol edge, and ive been using it for about 1.5yrs now, I use 10w60tho. I believe some drift teams are sponsored by it and havent lost an engine.

I haven't had any probs with Castrol Edge 5w-30 for the 3.5yrs I've had my car. it's the only decent 5w-30 readily available off the shelf that i've found and it's the recommended weight in my manual.

my car is NA though.

it would be interesting to know how many of the above mentioned oils are actually certified as meeting there advertised spec. And viscosity as in the thickness is not the spec either. Should be running a SL spec oil or higher which is commonly a semi-synthetic at the very least. Check on the back of the packaging. If its not got the API stamp, then you dont actually know what you are getting and 80% of oils retailed off the shelf havent as it costs big dollars to have a product certified.

Repsol oils are what i used in my shop for 5 years for this reason.

post-20078-1257710244_thumb.jpg

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Latest Posts

    • Very nice - I also have a 92 GTST and hardly see any others around these days
    • When I need something else to edit, I use Movavi. A friend who does video editing on a daily basis recommended me) it's an easy video cutter to use for beginners
    • I need to edit some videos for work but I'm not good at all this. Which video editor can you recommend?
    • I think you're really missing the point. The spec is just the minimum spec that the fuel has to meet. The additive packages can, and do, go above that minimum if the fuel brand feels they need/want to. And so you get BP Ultimate or Shell Ultra (or whatever they call it) making promises to clean your engine better than the standard stuff....simply because they do actually put better additive packages in there. They do not waste special sauce on the plebian fuel if they can avoid it. I didn't say "energy density". I just said "density". That's right, the specific gravity (if you want to use a really shit old imperial description for mass per unit volume). The density being higher indicates a number of things, from reduces oxygen content, to increased numbers of double bonds or cyclic components. That then just happens to flow on to the calorific value on a volume basis being correspondingly higher. The calorific value on a mass basis barely changes, because almost all hydrocarbon materials have a very similar CV per kg. But whatever - the end result is that you do get a bit more energy per litre, which helps to offset some of the sting of the massive price bump over 91. I can go you one better than "I used to work at a fuel station". I had uni lecturers who worked at the Pt Stanvac refinery (at the time they were lecturing, as industry specialist lecturers) who were quite candid about the business. And granted, that was 30+ years ago, and you might note that I have stated above that I think the industry has since collected together near the bottom (quite like ISPs, when you think about it). Oh, did I mention that I am quite literally a combustion engineer? I'm designing (well, actually, trying to avoid designing and trying to make the junior engineer do it) a heavy fuel oil firing system for a cement plant in fricking Iraq, this week. Last week it was natural gas fired this-that. The week before it was LPG fired anode furnaces for a copper smelter (well, the burners for them, not the actual furnaces, which are just big dumb steel). I'm kinda all over fuels.
    • Well my freshly rebuilt RB25DET Neo went bang 1000kms in, completely fried big end bearing in cylinder 1 so bad my engine seized. No knocking or oil pressure issue prior to this happening, all happened within less than a second. Had Nitto oil pump, 8L baffled sump, head drain, oil restrictors, the lot put in to prevent me spinning a bearing like i did to need the rebuild. Mechanic that looked after the works has no idea what caused it. Reckoned it may have been bearing clearance wrong in cylinder 1 we have no idea. Machinist who did the work reckoned it was something on the mechanic. Anyway thats between them, i had no part in it, just paid the money Curiosity question, does the oil system on RB’s go sump > oil pump > filter > around engine? If so, if you had a leak on an oil filter relocation plate, say sump > oil pump > filter > LEAK > around engine would this cause a low oil pressure reading if the sensors was before the filter?   TIA
×
×
  • Create New...