Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

Hi All

Two months ago i purchased a 1999 S2 RS Four S

When my car comes on boost and holds boost (keep foot planted) the turbo has a whine to it, as the revs build engine noise takes over and you cant hear it. It is most obvious at 2500-3000 RPM under acceleration. Is this a normal sound?? can anyone suggest where to take it in Adelaide to get an expert opinion as i want to find the problem (if it has one) before my 3 month warranty runs out.

Any advice would be appreciated

Ps Car is completely stock 90,000km

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/301666-turbo-whine/
Share on other sites

mine does that . same car . slightly more kays . i dont drive my car much and some days it puts the shits up me but then i remember it always does that . even with stock intake with sound deadining(teabag) in airbox its still quite loud .

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/301666-turbo-whine/#findComment-5006972
Share on other sites

Hi All

Two months ago i purchased a 1999 S2 RS Four S

When my car comes on boost and holds boost (keep foot planted) the turbo has a whine to it, as the revs build engine noise takes over and you cant hear it. It is most obvious at 2500-3000 RPM under acceleration. Is this a normal sound?? can anyone suggest where to take it in Adelaide to get an expert opinion as i want to find the problem (if it has one) before my 3 month warranty runs out.

Any advice would be appreciated

Ps Car is completely stock 90,000km

If you want to take it to a workshop, then there are plenty that provide professional opinions - ATS, BoostWorx, APE, Turbo Tune etc.

Another option is post on the SA section, there are plenty of SA Stag owners that can lend you their ears (and other body parts...) if needed.

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/301666-turbo-whine/#findComment-5007307
Share on other sites

Hey guys, I've taken a very short video that hopefully demonstrates the kind of whining noise being discussed here. Our RS4 "S" has a similar whine noise ever since day one when we picked it up, I was once concerned with the sound as well until I discovered this thread. Further comments are appreciated.

Cheers guys.

YouTube Link: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q4vH7_lUw9A

(video might take a few moments to appear on youtube's server as its only new tonight)

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/301666-turbo-whine/#findComment-5007451
Share on other sites

had my s1 for about 5yrs always had a spool whine but when i put a ces split front dump on passengers go wtf it sounds like a jet taking off (wish it would go like one),way louder.

lol, i get that comment heaps and i've yet to do the dump, i think its the intake side that makes the noise tho

just to clear some things up, series 2 c34's run neo motor and turbo, the neo turbo has a larger rear housing compared to an r33 rb25 turbo, the compressor (inlet) wheel is also nylon on neo turbos to reduce spool time

i would say that its the nylon wheel that makes them sound different to previous rb's

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/301666-turbo-whine/#findComment-5008446
Share on other sites

the noise in that video is f**k all . get some more tea bags for your stock air box . was funny the other night pulled the air box out of mates u 13 sss blue bird and the whole inside of the box on turbo side of air filter was lined with teabags . like 6 0r 7 all shaped to fit

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/301666-turbo-whine/#findComment-5008504
Share on other sites

That sound's nought more than the turbo just starting to think about doing some magic with your engine's volumetric efficiency.

:P

You'll find that it is more pronounced with an SS dump - the OEM cast iron absorbs more db.

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/301666-turbo-whine/#findComment-5008549
Share on other sites

Hi All

Two months ago i purchased a 1999 S2 RS Four S

When my car comes on boost and holds boost (keep foot planted) the turbo has a whine to it, as the revs build engine noise takes over and you cant hear it. It is most obvious at 2500-3000 RPM under acceleration. Is this a normal sound?? can anyone suggest where to take it in Adelaide to get an expert opinion as i want to find the problem (if it has one) before my 3 month warranty runs out.

Any advice would be appreciated

Ps Car is completely stock 90,000km

When i got may S2 Stagea with 85000km had some turbo whine, i didnt care as i got it cheap so i didnt mind if i needed to put a turbo on it. I have had plenty of turbo cars before and family races turbo cars. The whine was not really that bad was the same as a old VL turbo my old man use to race back in the 90's

After a month of owning it i wanted the change the timming belt and just service every thing on the car as i use it to tow my race car and need it reliable, i have read on the forums before its common the turbo gaskets leak so i changed it, when i took it out there was a very small hair line crack in the turbo gasket. Since that day i have no more whine at all, did nothing else to the car but timming belt turbo gaskets and oil filters, i even reused the air filter as it was so clean when i bought it.

Just somthing you could check if you have any concerns with turbo whine.

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/301666-turbo-whine/#findComment-5011730
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • Dang. I love the little 'oil used' bingo card on the side.   🤣  Well, now they can use a box and an oil-filled goon.
    • Many many moons ago, I was chatting with Andy Wyatt, about his auto ignition tuning. One of the HUGE things he said to me, when tuning for power, right where you hit peak ignition timing for your max torque, dramatically increases NOx emissions. He was finding in testing, particularly on engines you could advance timing beyond peak torque, that backing the ignition timing off a couple of degrees only made for a small drop in torque (compared to if you keep backing it off further the same amount of degrees) but dramatically reduced NOx emissions. I'd say targetting for 14.7, and he's even mentioned in some scenarios going slightly leaner, and pulling a few degrees of IGN timing will help pass for emissions quite a lot. However, who tunes an RB for emissions
    • The main stuff from.Vibrant I see is more their intercooler piping, and everyone raving about their clamps, but when I looked it was about $150 per clamp... I was a bit   I also thought the public price SP had up was high. As Mark said, a normal exhaust shop can fab them. It was many years ago that I had a full exhaust built, but for a full turbo back exhaust, and 2 custom built mufflers, plus a high flow cat, was about $1,100, and that was fully installed, drive in, drive out. I believe SP was about $900 for 2 mufflers, just supplied   These days, I just buy the material and built it myself, because I need to stretch my $$$
    • I'm pretty sure if it's considered a gasoline powered vehicle you have to do certification against a fixed, very expensive certification fuel.  If you add two precats and then replace the main cat with two cats back to back you can get an RB26 to do 0.24 g/mi HC, 1.6 g/mi CO, and 0.3 g/mi NOx on the FTP-75 drive cycle. Found this out courtesy of California's laws at great expense. Divide by 1.61 to get g/km. So even with extra cats + precats you're blowing past the NOx limit by probably 2.3x. Probably the only way to get an RB25 or RB26 to meet euro 4 purely from an emissions per km standpoint and not durability/OBD2 requirements is retrofit at least intake side VVT, clearance the pistons to allow the full 50 degrees of advance so part throttle EGR can be maximized, and change the wastegate control from conventional 7 psi spring for example to one that is always fully open if the wastegate line is at 1 atm or higher and only close it in response to vacuum. See BMW's N54 engine as a reference for how this works. You would need to find space for a vacuum tank to function as an accumulator in this system. That way you can avoid any heat loss to the turbine as much as possible during cold start to heat the catalyst faster. Then find some way to eliminate as much as possible cold start enrichment to light off the catalyst rapidly. Maybe secondary air injection if there's no way to avoid cold start enrichment. Close coupled catalysts in the downpipe are probably necessary. I would also probably swap to EV14s, pick something with the correct spray targeting + dual cone pattern for the intake manifold you're using. EV1 style injectors to pass anything resembling modern emissions requires a very annoying air assisted injector system to break up the droplets at part throttle/idle which still doesn't work that great compared to just having smaller droplets from the injector to begin with. Realistically, you're probably going to be financially ahead if you just pay the fines instead. Or don't drive it into the city center. There's a reason why Nissan never bothered to even attempt certifying an RB for CA/US emissions. The VG30 needed external EGR on top of NVCS to pass in the 90s. Doing all of this work is also distinctly expensive and you're going to struggle to find anyone who is remotely interested in helping. 
    • I remember those, people use to steal them to make bongs.....
×
×
  • Create New...