Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

hey guys just wondering what is the better option. I know people say that there is minimal if any top end hp difference but ive also herd that cats also help with the exhaust flow through turbulence etc. Is this true? and if it were wouldnt a high flow cat be alot better for the car all round rather than a de-cat? Just wondering because ive just purchased a decat and wondering whether it was the right choice to go for a straight through 3" pipe (not counting the high flow muff before the cannon at the back)?

Cheers

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/317509-decats-vs-catpipes/
Share on other sites

Remember exhaust characteristics are different for an N/A and a turbo car. A dump pipe on a turbo car should theoretically be as big as possible, you want the best flow possible period. However, on an N/A car it is different, it is more complex, an exhaust restriction can help with down low power but reduce top end and vice versa.

Whereas a nice large dump pipe on a turbo will give better response and top end, its a win win. Up to a point obviously where any increase in flow doesnt make any difference.

In summary to your question, the decat pipe will be better performance wise on your turbo car.

Your cat must be very restrictive to cause such a change, most cars would barely notice a difference. When you remove it, the exhaust is flowing a lot better meaning more boost, meaning more air for the engine causing it to run lean.

Define running like shit? loss of power? If its extremely lean you will loose power.

Edited by Harey
so explain why my car runs like shit when i run open dump pipe but runs tops when i put a cat on?

soz 4 highjacking ur thread

probably coz it hasnt been tuned for that set up.

yeah exactly right,

when i had my cat taken off and a decat put on the tune was very lean and the car made 260rwkw on the same boost, which was down from 285rwkw with the cat, but with a little tweaking of the Nistune to correct the mixtures. the car was able to make 320rwkw with an extra pound of boost.

i went to a decat because my cat was restricting flow because the guts of it had come loose and was moving around in there.

if you got an aftermarket ECU get it retuned, if its stock. then maybe the extra flow is just too much for the ecu to handle?

A good high flow cat will be quite expensive, around the $500~+ range. Metalcat comes to mind but the postives outweigh the negatives, probably a small 10-15rwhp possibly to be made by running straight through but the legality of being found out with no cat and having your car slapped with a major defect and towed away makes up for that.

I was running a decat. I put my cat back in, and did feel the car seemed to run better or soother with it on. It was down a little in power....but the car felt better to drive.

Yup it could do that. Are you running the standard ecu?

All you are doing is improving your exhaust flow, which has to be a good thing, it just means sometimes the ecu is not ready for it and needs to be adjusted.

Had my car around three years now and when I first got it I used a holesaw with extension to core out my cat and the whole insides disintegrated and just simply fell out (alot easier than trying to bash it out. that’s if it’s in pretty good condition like mine was). I found that when I first did it my exhaust note changed ever so slightly (more aggressive but probably more due to gaskets constantly blowing out at the time) and boost response is slightly better and went to rev limiter fine on stock boost. HOWEVER since I have now fit FMIC and played with the boost a bit it definitely starts to lean out around 5000-5500 and above.

(I’m only running 8-8.5psi due to R&R as I have a massive CAI which was causing compressor surge and R&R. Its now partially blocked until I get Haltech and tune. And yes I have cleaned my AFM, gasket gooed, taped and cleaned my coils and re-gapped to .8.)

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Latest Posts

    • Out of curiosity, what's the reason for converting? I think @R3N3 might have the Frenchy's kit in the R33? I somehow think of you as the ambassador for realistic and clean street-driven setups nowadays  
    • careful when running the car after a boil over. Ive heard you can lose enough coolant that it won't show the right temps because of too much air in the system (or something like that). Make sure the levels are good before trying again.  Maybe a mobile mechanic can come have a look with their scan tool ?
    • OK, just for some extra clarity - there is more than one option at Frenchy's. 1. You can buy the whole kit - with or without the actual compressor. The whole kit includes mounts, hoses, condensor, etc. That's either ~$2200 or ~$2800. No surgery required with this option. 2. You can buy just the bracket (~$600), or the bracket with the compressor (~$1200). Either of this or the above option "without the compressor" is if you already have an Echo comp or you are able to source one locally. Whatever the case, in this option, you will need surgery done on your hoses to adapt to the new compressor. When I said "the Frenchy's kit", I meant the whole kit in option 1. It is obviously somewhat more $$ than a $1500 OEM compressor. But if I had to spend $1500 on an OEM compressor, I would certainly consider spending double that to renew and significantly update everything forward of the firewall. Another option is to rebuild your original compressor. My R34 comp is currently dead and I will be most likely doing that to it if the spare one in the shed is also leaky.
    • I’m thinking that’s the route I’ll  go, thanks for the input!
    • Hey all, my 2004 Nissan Skyline 350GT overheated the other day with coolant boiling and leaking out of the coolant reservoir when I was parking. So today, I started it up again just to see if it was a thermostat/head gasket issue. After about 20 mins of running, temps were normal again, no coolant was leaking out and the upper reservoir hose was warm but my engine suddenly cut off. I checked the oil dipstick and cap when it was running and there was no white foamy residue and the exhaust did not have white smoke. I tried starting up the car again but it would only crank, similar to when I had a camshaft sensor issue just that now there’s no check engine light on the dash. Any ideas? Unfortunately I don’t have an OBD2 that can read the Nissan's programme.
×
×
  • Create New...