Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

Is there much to be gleaned Tim by our Members by having a Tech Night with a Traffic Lawyer?

Maybe I'm presumptuous but I believe there are many who would like 'conflict resolution' questions clarified whilst dealing with traffic laws, defect stations and HWP officers from time to time...

Is there much to be gleaned Tim by our Members by having a Tech Night with a Traffic Lawyer?

Maybe I'm presumptuous but I believe there are many who would like 'conflict resolution' questions clarified whilst dealing with traffic laws, defect stations and HWP officers from time to time...

I would be happy to either give or arrange for a few of these. The first could be on understanding the laws that operate in this space, as there have been some recent developments and then build from there.

kind of off topic but i want a definitive answer as to how much you have to actually submit to when stopped for a "Random breath test"

You can refuse, but the subsequent arrest and charge for refusing to supply a specimen of breath for a breath test is pretty high.

The more salient question is: why would you be drink driving over the limit in the first place? That's the only reason why you'd refuse.

Edited by TREGTR

kind of off topic but i want a definitive answer as to how much you have to actually submit to when stopped for a "Random breath test"

You can refuse, but the subsequent arrest and charge for refusing to supply a specimen of breath for a breath test is pretty high.

The more salient question is: why would you be drink driving over the limit in the first place? That's the only reason why you'd refuse.

i think he is more meaning if the officer goes on a tangent

eg I was stopped coming home from Melbourne literally around the corner from my for an "RBT" at around midnight. It wasnt HWP though, I think he was a detective, had a different uniform, non-HWP unmarked police car, didnt really seem to know what he was doing.

He ended up asking where I was from (around the corner was my actual answer lol), where I had been, why was I driving so late at night, why had I gone to Melbourne, was it my car, looked inside my car in all the windows, was commenting about my camera gear on the back seat (I had been down looking at an S14 to buy so I took photos)

All a bit excessive for an "RBT". Im guessing he had been investigating a crime nearby, saw me drive past when he was on his way back to the station, followed me to almost my door step. I was too tired to give a fark but probably would have ripped into him if he had gone any further as it was late and I was tired and just wanted to get to bed.

What I think Braden means is if something like that happens, do you legally have to do anything other than provide your license and blow in the machine

I would be happy to either give or arrange for a few of these. The first could be on understanding the laws that operate in this space, as there have been some recent developments and then build from there.

Many thanks Tim. :)

Will be in touch for mid 2014 Tech Night :yes:

What I think Braden means is if something like that happens, do you legally have to do anything other than provide your license and blow in the machine

The devil is in the detail and each state is different.

NSW.

You are obliged to carry your licence

You are obliged to stated your name and address and specimen of signature if required.

You are obliged to provide a breath test, or a urine/blood sample if it is so required.

You are obliged to provide your version of events in an accident.

You are obliged to surrender your licence, number plates or car if so directed.

It goes on and on. The Road Transport legislation has some of the widest ranging powers that police have.

Supplying details of your passengers, whereabouts etc are not required, unless it involves an indictable offence.

So if you get stopped for a RBT, it can involve a lot of powers.

The devil is in the detail and each state is different.

NSW.

You are obliged to carry your licence

You are obliged to stated your name and address and specimen of signature if required.

You are obliged to provide a breath test, or a urine/blood sample if it is so required.

You are obliged to provide your version of events in an accident.

You are obliged to surrender your licence, number plates or car if so directed.

It goes on and on. The Road Transport legislation has some of the widest ranging powers that police have.

Supplying details of your passengers, whereabouts etc are not required, unless it involves an indictable offence.

So if you get stopped for a RBT, it can involve a lot of powers.

Correct. There are some arguments that are worth a submission, like blood testing verse religious beliefs. It is really quite involved as you rightly pointed out.

back on topic

what do i have to submit to and what do i not

agreed you have to provide name and licence but as far as getting out of the car and asked to open boot bonnet or allow an officer to search car you don't

as far as i am aware

back on topic

what do i have to submit to and what do i not

agreed you have to provide name and licence but as far as getting out of the car and asked to open boot bonnet or allow an officer to search car you don't

as far as i am aware

Is this in relation to a specific incident you had, or generally?

I'm curious on the powers of "pop the bonnet son"

As I've recently heard in NSW they can only ask, you do t have to oblige.

Pop the bonnet usually results in "have a defect".

It would be good if everyone could be well informed. Are there specific places we can read the rules as written by the law?

I'm curious on the powers of "pop the bonnet son"

As I've recently heard in NSW they can only ask, you do t have to oblige.

Pop the bonnet usually results in "have a defect".

It would be good if everyone could be well informed. Are there specific places we can read the rules as written by the law?

The law is pretty complicated in this area. NSW only and high level answer found in LEPRA Division 5.

The Road Transport Act 2013 and other statutes interact with it though, so it's not just what's found in the above. Also the tricks and interpretations are in the supporting common law. We challenge what's written based on these.

I'm curious on the powers of "pop the bonnet son"

As I've recently heard in NSW they can only ask, you do t have to oblige.

Pop the bonnet usually results in "have a defect".

It would be good if everyone could be well informed. Are there specific places we can read the rules as written by the law?

Cop friend of mine in SA said that in that state you don't have to oblige. But lets face it, if you don't do it you're going to get a letter in the mail asking you to front up anyway.

If you need to dispute a photograph that wrongly implicates you to be at fault of an infringement whether it be relating to ..

a) speed

b) parking

c) accident

...you can contact this guy to have the photograph forensically assessed.

Dr Glenn Porter at UWS

[email protected]

Mob: 0403227453

Ph: (02)98525222 Ext:1739

Addy: K12.G.62 College Dr Richmond

Keep this as a reference > If he's away on sabbatical, ask if there's a 2IC.

I have worked with him on a couple of big matters before while at Norton Rose. He's a very good forensic photographer.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now



  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • Very nice - I also have a 92 GTST and hardly see any others around these days
    • When I need something else to edit, I use Movavi. A friend who does video editing on a daily basis recommended me) it's an easy video cutter to use for beginners
    • I need to edit some videos for work but I'm not good at all this. Which video editor can you recommend?
    • I think you're really missing the point. The spec is just the minimum spec that the fuel has to meet. The additive packages can, and do, go above that minimum if the fuel brand feels they need/want to. And so you get BP Ultimate or Shell Ultra (or whatever they call it) making promises to clean your engine better than the standard stuff....simply because they do actually put better additive packages in there. They do not waste special sauce on the plebian fuel if they can avoid it. I didn't say "energy density". I just said "density". That's right, the specific gravity (if you want to use a really shit old imperial description for mass per unit volume). The density being higher indicates a number of things, from reduces oxygen content, to increased numbers of double bonds or cyclic components. That then just happens to flow on to the calorific value on a volume basis being correspondingly higher. The calorific value on a mass basis barely changes, because almost all hydrocarbon materials have a very similar CV per kg. But whatever - the end result is that you do get a bit more energy per litre, which helps to offset some of the sting of the massive price bump over 91. I can go you one better than "I used to work at a fuel station". I had uni lecturers who worked at the Pt Stanvac refinery (at the time they were lecturing, as industry specialist lecturers) who were quite candid about the business. And granted, that was 30+ years ago, and you might note that I have stated above that I think the industry has since collected together near the bottom (quite like ISPs, when you think about it). Oh, did I mention that I am quite literally a combustion engineer? I'm designing (well, actually, trying to avoid designing and trying to make the junior engineer do it) a heavy fuel oil firing system for a cement plant in fricking Iraq, this week. Last week it was natural gas fired this-that. The week before it was LPG fired anode furnaces for a copper smelter (well, the burners for them, not the actual furnaces, which are just big dumb steel). I'm kinda all over fuels.
    • Well my freshly rebuilt RB25DET Neo went bang 1000kms in, completely fried big end bearing in cylinder 1 so bad my engine seized. No knocking or oil pressure issue prior to this happening, all happened within less than a second. Had Nitto oil pump, 8L baffled sump, head drain, oil restrictors, the lot put in to prevent me spinning a bearing like i did to need the rebuild. Mechanic that looked after the works has no idea what caused it. Reckoned it may have been bearing clearance wrong in cylinder 1 we have no idea. Machinist who did the work reckoned it was something on the mechanic. Anyway thats between them, i had no part in it, just paid the money Curiosity question, does the oil system on RB’s go sump > oil pump > filter > around engine? If so, if you had a leak on an oil filter relocation plate, say sump > oil pump > filter > LEAK > around engine would this cause a low oil pressure reading if the sensors was before the filter?   TIA
×
×
  • Create New...