Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

The Stig: the five worst cars I’ve driven

Ben Collins

April 29, 2011



alfa-romeo_729-420x0.jpg The Alfa Romeo 8C was the worst supercar Ben Collins ever drove.

Regardless of how you feel about some people, most of the time you can find a redeeming feature if you dig deep enough. After all, Wayne Rooney can kick a football. In the galaxy of motoring, however, there are occasions when the only redemption for a machine lies inside a box of matches. I've danced a few tangos with some beautiful belles over the years but I recall driving some dogs, too.

One brand of car proved so vociferous in its badness that it made me swear out loud and punch the steering wheel whenever I drove it. I'll deal with that one last in my list of ''five worst cars ever''.

I will begin with the worst supercar I ever drove, which was also one of the most beautiful. The Alfa Romeo 8C had the kind of looks that suggested she was wearing a suspender belt underneath that red dress. Her husky V8 voice whispered to you that 450 horsepower (336kW) was ready to tickle your toes with a feather and 100km/h would come in just four seconds.

My date with the 8C took place on the Fluela Pass, a high mountain road that snakes across the Swiss Alps via an endless barrage of hairpin bends and cambered sweepers. You might call it a rite of passage for a car's handling capability, because the constant twisting worked the brakes and suspension hard and the slightest error meant being dispatched into a ravine.

Pressing the brake pedal of the 8C was confusing, because the brakes seemed to operate the steering. The suspension was so unhinged that the weight of the car felt like it stayed on whatever wheel it had been leaning on during the previous corner as you entered the next one. Hitting the brakes, therefore, effected a sudden and perilous weight transfer.

The stiff suspension reacted violently. The ensuing skid as you entered a corner was jaw-dropping, as the 8C lifted its skirt to reveal not the frilly lace it had promised but, rather, a set of wedding tackle.

Next is a car that looked like it was born during a nuclear winter; a cross between a deformed newt and a cement mixer.

The Fiat Multipla broke ground by cramming in two rows of three seats line astern but it made her a big, wide unit. It took 12 seconds to reach 100km/h, whereupon it didn't handle too badly but you looked daft behind the wheel.

Next on the list is a horrible bucket of bling that dares to call itself a 4x4: the Cadillac Escalade SUV. The ''Platinum'' model totes crass 22-inch chromed spoke alloys and tinted windows designed to curry favour with drug dealers. Around town it positively bleeds fuel and if you even suggest taking it off road it fakes injury.

When we did point it at the most modest of trenches, the axle shook like blancmange before the Caddy bottomed out and got stuck. On closer inspection, we found essential-looking wiring had parted company with the vehicle and hung out of the wheel arches, along with the electrical tape that previously held everything together. Truly awful.

The US produced another major disappointment in the new Dodge Charger. We waited 30 years for the Charger to fly back into our lives the way it did in 1968 during the chase scene of Bullitt.

The new Charger appeared in 2005 and underwhelmed with its heavy weight, modest power and woeful automatic gearbox. When it comes to classic remakes, the only manufacturer that seemed to get it right was Chevrolet with the Camaro SS.

The end is nigh. Apocalypse. Three little letters that encapsulate the absolute worst of vehicle design: T-V-R. They were all ghastly, unreliable and held together by craft glue but the standout cataclysm was the TVR Sagaris.

It had no door handles. To open the door you pressed a button under the wing mirror and prayed the electrics worked, because on many TVRs they don't. The seating was invented by Houdini and changing gear required you to dislocate a shoulder.

Meaningless quasi-aerodynamic features on the bodywork shook violently when you reached speed and that happened quickly. Zero to 100km/h took just 3.8 seconds.

It had no ABS or traction control, which would normally attract my praise, but the handling was so beguiling. Human beings have an innate feel for cars, perhaps developed over thousands of years of balancing on horseback.

The Sagaris told porkies to your instincts. In bends, the weight of the engine over the front wheels made it pitch insanely and I spun off countless times with no idea why. If this was the result with a so-called pro at the wheel, I pitied the man who polished it all week before going for a Sunday drive. Worse still, Jeremy Clarkson loved it. I rest my case.

Ben Collins is a racing driver who was Top Gear's The Stig in a previous life.

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/362661-worst-cars-stigs-ever-driven/
Share on other sites

I'll never be in a position to drive an 8C Pat - and I probably wouldn't want to unless it was someone else's, just to see how bad a car can get.

I'd believe Collins though.

I've owned 2 Alfas in my life, and I must say they can be quirky!

1) Brand New 1979 Alfetta GTV which all the girls (and some guys) thought was s*x on wheels

* It could out-corner just about anything except an XU-1 or a Lotus in that price range

* The exhaust manifold had a way of breaking away from the block via bolts unscrewing themselves

* Air cond > oil leaks from the crank

* Front seats were an Italian state of art rather than robust

* The sound of the exhaust was the best of any 4 cyl car

* Hoses were never made for Aussie conditions and kept on perishing

* No rust because I had the car "ENDRUST" treated the 1st week

* Through hairpin bends, tailshaft universal joints (made of rubber) kept on breaking to the extent that the Alfa Service Dept asked me to take them for a drive, so that I could prove I wasn't some asian crackpot driver LOL

2) Used 1989 164Q (1 of 50 in Oz)

* Front strut towers started to crack

* Rear gas strut hinges started to wear through the rear quarter panel

* Rear quarter panel recesses contained bags of sand for I don't the f**k what for

* Front seat surrounds made of plastic would crack

* Centre console near the handbrake would crack

* It'd only corner decently with plenty of turn-in after I had a front tower brace fabricated > smile on my face all the way home (- yes the change was that dramatic)

* The Alfa sound on a six cyl. car was just as good as above with its triangular centre soundbox.

Would I buy one again?

Hmmm... I might be a slow learner - but I'm not a masochist - LOL

how did you find the sandbags anyway? maybe Clarkson had it once and tried to bulletproof the car with them ala the mid-east special.

it doesnt work but still worth a shot (no pun intended)

I knew Alfas were unreliable but jesus it sounds like you got the short end of a very short stick twice in a row..

Well Pat and others, I was smitten with this design > http://www.alfetta-gtv.ch/

It was an early 70s design by Bertone and it cornered better than its nearest rival, the Lancia Beta Coupe and I thought it attracted a better class of girls than an XU-1 - LOL

I knew these things were prone to rust > Terry gives the Italian lady the ENDRUST treatment.

There were no car forums or even computers back then. You had to join a car club (to find out about pitfalls), but I was too shy.

Like Clarkson, I was willing to overlook oil leaks and breakages to hear the sound of this thing. It sounded better than a Miura. imho - lol

By the time I was ready for a fast 4 door sports sedan and this rare 164 Quadrifoglio (4 leaf clover) came up, my heart overtook my head once again.

I just loved all the firm thick leather, I liked the way it could drag off a VN V8 or a 3000GT (until 3rd gear); but I didn't realise that it couldn't corner and got quite a shock at how torque steer could send me into weird angles hehe...

Now for the sand bags...

The rear boot hinge was wearing through the right quarter panel > I tried to bend the hinges back to some semblance of vertical > reached down into a cavity > thought...

"WTF is this???"

Thank you guys for sharing my Alfa story.

I never did have the heart to tell admiring ladies what can go wrong with an Alfa Romeo :P

And BTW...

Alfa Romeo still has the best badge!

lol

  • 2 weeks later...

I use to own a 84 ( I think) GTV4.

looked hot, Sounded hot (despite only running on 3 cylinders) Brakes where HORRIBLE, 1st ,2nd, 3rd & 4th gears crunched if above 3k RPM (every time) it was rusted through to shit but oh was it fun to drive!!!!!

not "the" car. but same model

L3N2K7Z4G9D8Y1O3_medium.jpg

Edited by ianjb

Sorry Pat, but this is srsly turning into an Alfetta Thread LOL

Our Alfettas were designed under the Bertone banner...

Which means what??

And who cares??

Well, as my son informs me, the designer was Giorgetto Giugiaro.

And he designed all of these...

http://en.wikipedia....uence_on_design

A true master! :thumbsup:

Design Credits include...

* Lotus Esprit '72

* BMW M1 Homage Concept '08

* BMW M1 '77

* De Lorean DMC-12

* Ducati 860GT '75

* Seiko Speedmaster '86

* Lamborghini Cala '95

* Maserati Merak '72

* Maserati Spyder '02

* Maserati 4200 Coupe '02

* De Tomaso Mangusta '66

* Ferrari 250 GT Bertone

* Ferrari GG50 '05

* Ford Mustang Concept '66

* Subaru SVX '91

* Alfa Romeo Brera '02

and of course our beloved Alfetta GT/GTV '74 onwards... :thumbsup:

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • I like mine. Much better than stock. Like i said before the reverse/parking cameras look even worse than normal, still useable. When you buy one make sure it's the latest version. Heaps of cheap ones that run the old hardware and software. Got mine from AliExpress. Mine is quick no lag, boots up 1-2 sec. Menu is fast. Netflix is fine and so is YouTube. Android Auto is random taking 3sec to 15sec. Most of the time it's quick. Very rare it doesn't connect. But that could be a phone thing.   Now I think they use a Pixel 3XL to run this whole thing which i guess is fine, but the problem is that some apps will not work on old hardware like Disney Plus  Maybe Prime Video too 🤔. they will not update. Iv'e tried getting the APK Disney + but i still couldn't get it working. I have a Data sim installed so i have internet all the time. You can't Hotspot off your phone and connect Android Auto at the same time. Not that you need too, if you want you can hotspot off your phone and run any internet map app (google maps) and you can run the Spotify app on it's own (the app runs better than android auto) You can still access the INFINITI intouch system for all the o.g stuff    P.S i got new non Polarization Sunglasses too 😎 
    • I also don't mean to rain on your parade. But with a 5-10k budget for road only? I'd want to check confirmation that everything IS working correctly and I'm with @GTSBoy for a plan of action here. I'd be checking subframes, bushes, exhaust hangers, interior bits and generally QOL things and CONFIRMING they are working right before thinking about motor. You can get 250KW+ on stock RB26 hardware by simply removing the built in restrictors and tuning the stock ECU. If you want purity that's as far to take it, which I would be worried to do and won't think the budget would allow for when earnestly checking for 30+ year old car stuff.
    • I specifically said buy new performance car because of the use case here (i.e, no track use and fun livable everything/do it all easily if not especially amazing as a drivers car). Tracking an 80K Skyline and an 80K M2 makes the BMW the obviously more risky purchase WHEN something goes wrong you suddenly can't easily fix it with hand tools and readily available parts that you may have a community of people you know available, or years of your own knowledge on the platform to apply. There's reasons you see Hondas and Vettes and RB's and Miatas and such at tracks, you can easily hand-tool repair 99.9% of it in a shed, usually with the tools and the skillset of the owner to apply to it. An i30N is not going to beat a R chassis unless it's got massive problems either. The old cars can, and still do work great. The problem is - and always has been - social media would have you believe it's simple and easy to achieve the results you see online.  People want their car to be like "one of those cool JDM cars" which is the default image people have when they think of  "cool JDM cars" You are paying 25 years of catchup R&D to achieve. Or the knowledge somebody else has to do it for you, which is big dollar restomod stuff.  The bar has been moved and every R chassis that people see/like/enjoy has 25 years of R&D thrown at it, or is owned by someone who did all that work and has that knowledge over the past 25 years. All the survivors have been progressively resto-modded the entire time. OR you slowly bring it back to how it was stock. Which is also prohibitively expensive, done for the love of it. This is what the JDM community is now. This is fine, but "Where do I start?" is either: 1) Don't 2) Take your own slow journey but you cannot compare your progress with others who have had 25 years of R&D and experience building their own cars unless you pay for it.
    • Yep, with the crazy inflation of the value of our cars these past couple of years this became a problem for me too... My solution is to transition to bikes. Everything feels so cheap compared to tracking the skyline lol
    • So, I've been a little busy on this car. I replaced the bonnet struts which is always satisfying but very confusing that nobody else on the planet seems to do this. Its just my routine first thing I do on any car I buy. The boot struts for both the tailgate and the separately opening glass window was a bastard. And, I found a fair bit of rust in the strut cavity. I filled it with rust converter and cleaned up as much of the dirt as I could. There was so much dirt. One piece of the trim was barely hanging on and so I've left it off. I'll try to get a replacement. You can see how disgusting and dirty it all was in this thread; I had to remove the little clips that hold the struts on the ball. The ones I took off had no clips and it was impossible to get them on with them in place. Fingers crossed they stay put. So, I turned my attention to the headlights, they were in a bad way and likely would stop rego. I took the headlights out and found the adjusters were all just loose. So, I fixed those and unclipped the lenses to clean them up. Couldn't believe how easy it was to take all this apart compared to the E90.   I also cleaned up the stockies which was awesome, these are super cool with lug nut covers. They're in good nic but the tyres are shot. I was going to use these for rego but in the end got a fresh pair of rubber for the 17's on the front of the car instead. The front bar of this car is from a late(r) model one. I don't think it's quite LCI but who knows. I'll need to find out. Anyway, the bar was missing the fog lights and the wiring and plugs were for the original ones so I got new plugs and some cheap fogs. I wasn't sure if missing original equipment would hamper my blue slip attempts. Had a couple of these little fellas helping out. But not Ben who got stuck behind the pool heater .... How embarressment.  I ordered new speed sensors for all corners because I knew one was out. I just got cheapies and will replace them with Bosch items when I can find Bosch items. Again, this was just for rego. Alas, it seems the blue speed sensors are not the same as the grey ones. Back they went and replacements ordered. In the end, with my new scan tool, it was just rear left that was shot. Replaced it and cleared the codes. All good now. Lastly, my aux (thermo) fan is being a bit odd. Its powering up at strange times and NOT powering up when I think it should (100C). While this can be caused by a few things, the most likely (for me) is the ambient temp sensor. Given mine reads -40.0C regardless of the temp, I figured it would be good to replace it. In the end, the sensor wiring was abysmal with (terrible) attempts made by somebody to fix it.   I fixed this all up but the sensor is only attached using pins into the wires. The plug is not there. Despite trying and trying to connect it securely it wouldn't work so a replacement sensor and plug is on the way. Oh, I also ordered a replacement piece of trim for the part missing here at the bottom. Ordered from Latvia for $70 delivered. I took a bit of a leap of faith because I didn't have the exact part number and, as usual, there were eleventy billion pieces of trim that looked to fit. Nailed it. Well, its not totally perfect but I think its more a 28 y/o car problem than a trim problem. And, as of today ..... I have bought the workshop manuals 2nd hand off a guy in tassie. 1000+ pages of E39 goodness, hopefully it helps me with the fan. I also have a new temp switch on the way incase its the problem. Stoked.
×
×
  • Create New...