Jump to content
SAU Community

Claiming Damage Through Vic Roads.


ashneel
 Share

Recommended Posts

hey guys just wanted your input/opinions and experiance in this.

was driving on the monash freeway heading city bound and a piece, well a chunk of tyre that was on the road was flung up by another car and hit the car i was driving. damage cause was a smashed bonnet guard, a fairly large dint on the bonnet and scratch marks up the bonnet and on the edge where the roof meets the windscreen.

question is can this be "claimed" through vic roads for damage? or is it more of a suck it up and go through insurance company?

reading the vic roads web site its states that "A person who has suffered personal injury or property damage due to the condition of a road or road infrastructure may be entitled to compensation from the responsible road authority"

road contidion was fine as in no pot holes or lose stones/rubbles on the road but there was shreaded tyres on a road where cars are travelling at high speed. so it would be their duty to make sure its clean of everything wouldnt it be?

so is it worth me putting in a claim or just go through insurance for it?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Put in a claim mate, worst case scenario they tell you where to go and you wind up going through private insurance anyway. Will help if you can give them the time and exact location of where it happened.

It's shit when that happens. I've had sizeable rocks come off trucks before and there's no recourse for some of it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

hmmm ye. just reading though search results that popped up in Google, most ppl have been waiting 6 months + to hear back only to get their claim rejected.

it’s pretty much a brand new car with just over 10000ks on it. don’t want it sitting there or driving it around with damage while i hear from vic roads.

it happened just after warrigal road exit. I’m pretty sure there is a "safety cam" monitoring the freeway. I’m sure they should have some footage. but i have all the details written down except for the rego of the car that drove over the piece of rubber/tire

Link to comment
Share on other sites

could you possibly have it fixed by your insurance, then a claim to VIC roads to reimburse the cost and a formal government letter to your insurance company asking to adjust the claim incase your rating changes?

its much better to have stat dec's and receipts with this.. and lodging it with insurance would be a statement as you explain the situation to them.

good luck mate

Link to comment
Share on other sites

i reckon you would have zero chance

imho go through your insurance and get it fixed then see if vicroads respond but i doubt it

if there was a massive hole in the road and they didnt fix it or they were vicroads contractors onsite and they left placards or something on the road then i would say so for sure

Link to comment
Share on other sites

is there any chance a bump on the road will make the accelerator pedal/cable getting stuck ??

on the way to work i have to go over atleast 12 speedhumps and obviously the same on the way home, and it's doing a good job HUMPING my suspension... soooo what i was thinking was that i ream my car into one of the poles on the that street wiping out the car and the pole and blame it on the speedhumps with an excuse like 'it caused my accel. cable/pedal to be stuck....will i have a case?

i guess only one way to find : )

Link to comment
Share on other sites

errrrrr anyways

called vic roads. they were in the usual "pole up the ass" mood. told the dude what happened and all he said was "well thats unfortunate isnt it?"

called insuarance company and put through a claim. lady at insurance company did say to put a claim through vic roads anyways and see how that goes.

if ppl are interested i will update this thread.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I tried to claim damages from VicRoads when their contractors instructed me to drive over wet asphalt, which ruined my tyres. I provided all the details precisely, time and date etc. I heard back a few months later - VicRoads said there were no works going on at that time in that place. So either I made the whole thing up (including photo evidence), or they are conniving pricks.

TL; DR - I don't rate your chances of getting a cent from VicRoads

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ash u remember the shit I went thru for 4 months after a pothole on a freeway did a 10k job on all my steering, suspension components and wheels. And that WAS their responsibility. It's like squeezing blood from a stone. U will have to call insurance. U will have to accept fault as u didn't get the other cars details. U will have to pay the excess. And take the car to their choice of repairer like a common criminal...

f**k I hate insurance.

f**k I hate vicroads...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Only person that I know who managed to get money out was my brother. But that was vicroads shifting blame on the company that was doing roadworks that left a massie hole on the rd that wrecked his front bar. We managed to get $3500 out of them

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Only person that I know who managed to get money out was my brother. But that was vicroads shifting blame on the company that was doing roadworks that left a massie hole on the rd that wrecked his front bar. We managed to get $3500 out of them

for a front bar? nice.. full respray!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ash u remember the shit I went thru for 4 months after a pothole on a freeway did a 10k job on all my steering, suspension components and wheels. And that WAS their responsibility. It's like squeezing blood from a stone. U will have to call insurance. U will have to accept fault as u didn't get the other cars details. U will have to pay the excess. And take the car to their choice of repairer like a common criminal...

f**k I hate insurance.

f**k I hate vicroads...

That must have been some pothole.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

i reckon you would have zero chance

imho go through your insurance and get it fixed then see if vicroads respond but i doubt it

if there was a massive hole in the road and they didnt fix it or they were vicroads contractors onsite and they left placards or something on the road then i would say so for sure

+1 re zero chance

I ran into an unprotected pothole that was 4" deep and bent two rims and damaged suspension.

Initially they told me to get lost but then said I can claim if the damage is a minimum of around $1,280 or thereabouts.

The $1280 is an excess which I would have to pay and they would possible think about the rest If I'm lucky.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

That must have been some pothole.

Fairly massive, similar to the guy above. Broke my steering rack, buckled a rim, damaged control arms, ball joints, bent one of my ohlins branded coilovers...and so on. Remembering it was also a freeway with a speed limit of 110 kmh. It was night and raining heavily so i couldnt see until i hit it. Vicroads fixed the pothole and claimed they'd fulfilled their responsibility and that they were 'not liable for any proprty damage in part or wholly caused by road conditions' citing a document which I read cover to cover which said that they were. I wrote a letter of complaint with a copy of all my documentation and evidence...all I got back was 'but we did send you a road condition reprot, it's not our fault if u didn't get it but call us if u want it sent again'. In response to a THREE PAGE letter of complaint with about 10 seperate points of complaint they addressed only one point and told me to bugger off. In the end I ran out of time and patience. I needed my car back. So I paid my 2k excess and lost a rating. But at least the cars fixed now...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share



  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • Oh, yeah, no arguing that the duty cycle is different. And a circuit car will go to those speeds for more distance and longer times. But, I suspect that if a tailshaft has a harmonic problem, that it would cause damage and shit itself maybe even on the first pass. A second or two of running at the resonant/harmonic problem speed is already a couple hundred revolutions.
    • Shaft speed would be the same, however it's how long they hold it there for and repeated conditions. FWIW half way down the main straight at SMSP I'm bouncing off 4th with a 8600RPM limiter. That shaft would be spinning at 8600RPM for a few seconds before I need to smash the brakes, by T2 it's getting close to that speed again. Now a drag car/roll race car would see that shaft speed for a 1 to 2 secs then they would coast, hit the brakes and that's it.
    • With same diff ratio, tyre diameter and road speed, the tailshaft rpm is the same regardless of the gearbag's ratio. Given that very quick drag cars are probably doing similar road speeds to the fastest circuit cars (circa 300 km/h), and there will be many of either category that can't go that fast and so you'd have inummerable matchups between drag and circuit car speeds at smaller numbers, and given that they are probably using rather similar tyre diameters and probably using similar diff ratios, and...where any of those numbers were different they could quite easily be in opposite directions thus cancelling out.... I think you'd find that there'd be more similarity than difference in tailshaft speed between these two use cases, no?
    • they might see those prop shaft speeds for 1 to 2 secs only 
    • A year of slogging through this bearing issue and finally fixed. What a nightmare. The oil pressure increase did not fix the problem. If you would like to read all the details in case you ever run into a similar issue visit my thread on Yellow Bullet. https://www.yellowbullet.com/threads/continuous-rod-bearing-issues.2689569/?post_id=74193031&nested_view=1&sortby=oldest#post-74193031 In the end the rod bearings themselves were the issue. I had switched from ACL (first engine) to King because that was all we could get at the time and I thought nothing of it. Put the ACL's back in after a year of taking the pan off multiple times to change many things. Issue resolved. Can't believe it was just the bearings themselves all along. It has now been about two years since I drove the car on the street or had it at the track. At some point I had installed all solid and spherical bushings in the rear but had never aligned it since it just went on and off the dyno. Alignment was the first thing to do. (Old photo but same concept) Then I took the transmission out and went through it. This was my first gearset install and I've done about 15 since this one and learned a lot and wanted to apply some of these tweaks to mine. The aftermarket shift forks take very well to some modification and I wanted to make that change. Shifts are now super smooth and no having to find the gear. I also recut the 5th and reverse shift sleeves - always wanted to try this and see how well it works. It works very well! No grinds or having to do a second attempt going into reverse and 5th is perfect. Before During After Going back in In rummaging through my spare trans parts box I found the only parts I've ever broke on a stock trans; the 3-4 shift fork - twice!  
×
×
  • Create New...