Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

Feel free to flame if this has been made before, but I couldn't really find the answer I'm looking for.

Which would provide better performance and/or sound out of a 3inch 100cell high flow cat or a 2.5inch decat?

I can get my hands on a stock R33 GTS-T cat for free, which I believe is 2.5 inches and turn it into a decat, or I could spend some money on a 3 inch 100cell high flow cat.

Which would you prefer?

Almost forgot to mention I have a 3inch dump/down pipe and 3inch cat back, but a stock cat.

Edited by Dylaan
Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/367255-high-flow-cat-vs-decat/
Share on other sites

  • Replies 49
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

The step down to 2.5" for the gutted stocker would hinder it more than a fairly run of the mill 3" cat.

Obviously you realise no cat is going to flow better than A CAT of any type.. Yet there are nonsense legalities and heavy fines for running no cat.. And making it hard to pick (like putting a 3" pipe into the stocker) is a lot of work for reasonably small gains..

It has been covered, but I think this more than covers it for future and ease of searching. Just get a decent cat, save the hassle. Justjap sell decent highflow items for under $200.

GL

I know a decat is going to have more flow, but the highflow cat might have an advatage from having the bigger size? How about if I put some mesh inside the decat? would that still count as running no cat at all?

Buy a 3" straight pipe

Buy 3" cat shell

Cut ends off cat shell

Stick straight pipe in

Weld flanges onto ends

???

Profit

Could do, but as it is a daily I need it to be at a bit lower volume than a straight pipe. The car is suprisingly quiet at the moment, must be due to having countless mufflers and a stock cat. Could use a few more db before I get in any trouble for it.

Edited by Dylaan

My car is too low for them to see the decat to fine me for it anyway. :unsure:

As said above, I got a nicely made one for a similar price, can't go wrong.

3 advantages for me.

The cat was the lowest point and I was bottoming the f**k out of it. The decat gave me heaps more room.

Bit better flow.

Bit louder and slightly better exhaust note. :D

Edited by -Jimmy-

My car is too low for them to see the decat to fine me for it anyway. :unsure:

As said above, I got a nicely made one for a similar price, can't go wrong.

3 advantages for me.

The cat was the lowest point and I was bottoming the f**k out of it. The decat gave me heaps more room.

Bit better flow.

Bit louder and slightly better exhaust note. :D

your missing the point, a decat looks like a normal catalytic convererter, they can't tell unless the exhaust is dropped off and they look inside and the honeycombe cores are gone, or you get EPA'd and they check for noxious gases.

your missing the point, a decat looks like a normal catalytic convererter, they can't tell unless the exhaust is dropped off and they look inside and the honeycombe cores are gone, or you get EPA'd and they check for noxious gases.

No that would be a gutted cat. A decat is just a straight piece of pipe with flanges on it. Very easy to tell.

i see, in that case couldn't you just run a 'decat' with a catalytic shell? That would be next to impossible to tell.

That is the dilemma its self. The op is trying to decide whether a decat job (2.5 inch stock cat) is better flowing than a hi flow cat (3 inch)

Also, i know the fines for a decat are suppose to be quite hefty, but couldnt you plead innocence and try to pass it off as being damaged? Unless of course you have the 2.5 inch pipe running through the middle of it, in which case its quite obvious.

i see, in that case couldn't you just run a 'decat' with a catalytic shell? That would be next to impossible to tell.

That's what I was planning to do with the stock cat. Probably should have exaplined it better.

That is the dilemma its self. The op is trying to decide whether a decat job (2.5 inch stock cat) is better flowing than a hi flow cat (3 inch)

Also, i know the fines for a decat are suppose to be quite hefty, but couldnt you plead innocence and try to pass it off as being damaged? Unless of course you have the 2.5 inch pipe running through the middle of it, in which case its quite obvious.

Thanks, atleast you understand what I was trying to say :)

I still don't know what to do, if the cops saw a 3inch dump pipe and 3inch cat back but a stock cat, would they just assume it's been raped of it's inside?

That's what I was planning to do with the stock cat. Probably should have exaplined it better.

Thanks, atleast you understand what I was trying to say :)

I still don't know what to do, if the cops saw a 3inch dump pipe and 3inch cat back but a stock cat, would they just assume it's been raped of it's inside?

Tbh, i think it would come down to the officer. I have had mine sent to the epa (for noise) and the tester didnt even notice the dump pipe (it had factory front pipe though) He did however notice alot of other things lol. In my experience most cops arent too concerned until you have done something stupid in front of them (me, with my foor to the floor) or if you start being a smart arse, then they will without a doubt look for reasons. Their is however exceptions, where they will pull you over and look for anything they can. Most of the time though, the worst they can do is suspect modifications and send you out an epa notice, in which you just swap the parts back over. Also police will look for things like cannon mufflers and front mount coolers, so they can be a magnet for attention.

your missing the point, a decat looks like a normal catalytic convererter, they can't tell unless the exhaust is dropped off and they look inside and the honeycombe cores are gone, or you get EPA'd and they check for noxious gases.

Not true. A cat that is working stores a lot of heat compared to a gutted cat so all the epa need is an infra-red thermometer to check it's temp compared to the rest of the exhaust.

yeah >< i see now, had it in my head that turning it into the cat into a 'decat' was just taking out the honeycomb, not also welding in a straight 2.5/3 inch pipe though it.

Plenty of people just bash it out too mate.. Although im under the impression the pipe through the middle is the better option.

It's been said by others that driving behind someone with a decat/gutted cat is obvious because your eyes can get watery from those noxious gases

This is why i bought a hiflow- i heard stories like that too. Plus i had heard the fine is huge.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now



  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • Oof, I will forevermore have those shredded gears in mind whenever someone talks about showing mechanical sympathy towards their car. Thanks for the photos, fascinating stuff!
    • Curious to see how the SpeedTek stuff holds up
    • The holdups last year were drivetrain related. I had the car out right after getting the bearing issue resolved. Third launch and the car didn't move after releasing the clutch. It had sheared all the engagement teeth off the 1st gear.    Thankfully no other damage was done. I set an aftermarket gear beside an OEM gear and found that the engagement teeth on the OEM gear were much larger and better supported. Looking through my bin of spare transmission gears I found that there are two types of tooth on the OEM first gears - the larger tooth and the smaller tooth. It looks like most aftermarket gearset manufacturers base their design on the smaller tooth. OEM large tooth left - Speedtek, OS Giken, etc or OEM small tooth right Decided to give that larger engagement tooth a try. Pressed the ring off an OEM gear and sent it to a transmission manufacturer here in the States. They did their "faceplating" operation with my synchro ring on the Speedtek gear.   I reassembled it, took it back to the track and promptly destroyed the gear itself.  I'll rebuild this and use it as a spare - thankfully just first gear and the countershaft are damaged beyond repair. Definitely disheartening but my welded on engagement tooth ring held up!  Moved to Speedtek's dog engagement design as the gears appear to be much stronger. So far they have taken much more abuse at the track. Also scored a Stillway lockout from the Netherands for super cheap. It's for some other RB transmission so it took a bit of fabrication to fit but honestly a very easy job. I also had to heavily modify the gates as they were very different.   Then for some reason at the last test and tune a silicon coupler below the throttle blew off and took out the radiator and fan. Thankfully it was in the burnout box and not down track. This car is really beating me up - I still haven't made a pass in it. Ran it through the gears many times on the street but it keeps biting me at the track.  Currently in the process of replacing the radiator and remaking the throttle pipe to remove the coupler and use a cast 90 and a vband. I WILL get this thing down the track...
    • Covers most of the above points really. There's a few exceptions but most just see driving as an irritating but necessary task they must complete if they want to get anywhere on time. Also see it as a good time to show their awesome multi-tasking abilities on their mobile and/or doing their makeup.  
    • I don't believe I posted pictures of the second oil pump pickup I added so here they are. Data shows it gets oil pressure up to the relief pressure much earlier in the RPM. Is that important? Not likely... This was just another attempt to fix the bearing issues.   I also heavily opened up the inlet to the pump since it now had to flow oil from two pickups. I believe the diameter increased about 1/8".
×
×
  • Create New...