Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

  • 3 weeks later...
  • Replies 63
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

http://forum.nistune...&t=2135&p=15305

I asked the nistune guys, from their bench testing this is what Pete has seen.

All SR20DET (except RNN14) and 16-bit Z32 are batch fire at all times.

All ECU's go batch fire if they go into limp-home mode.

CA18DET is sequential at low loads and goes batch fire at high loads.

All others are sequential all the time.

Edited by Rolls

Pete replied with:

Yeah, over on SAU they think a lot of things...

It's been awhile since I took a detailed look but I'm pretty sure they use injector driver chips with 4 drivers each. So a 6 would use 4 elements from one and 2 from the other.

There's sure to be somebody who knows the ECU circuitry better than me but I'm pretty sure that was the deal.

I can definitely tell you the RB20/VG30 is sequential cos I've got 6 injectors hooked up to my test rig and you can distinctly tell that they're firing sequentially.

PL

edit: I think it is the type 1 board that has only two injector drivers, eg the redtop ECU in the R31s

Edited by Rolls

I noticed you specified the 16 bit z32 from what I have read the 16 bit has issues with Nistune but the older 8 bit is fine (I read that on the Nistune forums of he wants to take another shot at sau) so im assuming the 8 bit is batch fire?

Injector pin out between the rb20 and rb25 ecu's are slightly different, 2 pins are swapped

I was advised by Nistune there is no need to swap then as the injectors are fired in 2 batches of 3. The 2 injectors were on the same batch.

I will be pretty pissed if this is not the case as this would probably be the cause of my car constantly running like crap.

Will wait for Pete to reply. If he has a bench setup it is VERY easy to tell if it is fully sequential. Another test is to pull your cas out and spin it by hand, can you hear the injectors fire one by one, or in banks?

haha too late for me, sick and tired of my car running like crap so I finally took the plunge and bought an adaptronic plug in ecu.

Not a bad word against the Nistune chip i set a Z32 ecu up in my mates r33 and it ran like a stock car.

This pin swap may have fixed my constant misfire at idle and low loads.(Issue was not there with stock ecu)

Pete is going to pull apart an ECU and get to the bottom of it.

Curious what the case is, I am not sure if I am running a rb20 or rb25 injector loom so will be curious about this pin swap as well as I also have an idle misfire.

I understand that...but if you have to swap ecu pins etc...It just seems like there are a lot of hassles with poor running, missfiring etc

whether that is the people fitting it boards or whether swapping the pins and potentially firing an injector into an open intake valve which is creating the issues is a whole other matter.

I understand that...but if you have to swap ecu pins etc...It just seems like there are a lot of hassles with poor running, missfiring etc

whether that is the people fitting it boards or whether swapping the pins and potentially firing an injector into an open intake valve which is creating the issues is a whole other matter.

Which is what is being investigated now. The pin swap is only relevant to RB25 owners running RB20 ECUs and it does (or at least did) say to do it in the manual, it is only relevant if it is fully sequential though.

Time will tell. Not really sure what you are getting at.

Edited by Rolls

Its kinda hard to explain what Im getting at lol....if the 25ECU is batch fire and using a Sequential ecu, and have to swap a pin so all 6 injectors fire instead of 5 or 4 or what ever the case may be, is that the wiring may not quite be right.

As an example on the EF falcon 4L they run batch injection and wasted spark...runs perfectly fine as standard as the intake valves are closed when the injector and wasted spark fires on the exhaust stroke...when you fit larger cams with more over lap the valve is slightly open and fresh fuel gets into the chamber + the wasted spark was igniting the fuel as it entered the chamber with the intake valve open, only happened at low load/idle though, but the cars never ran right even at WOT

Only option was to run a funky cam profile or fit an ECU with 6 injector drivers.

Thats my basis for thinking what I'm thinking about the funny little missfire that some guys get.

I maybe completely wrong in this instance, especially with the RBs running coil on plug...but it maybe fuel is being squirted at the wrong time into the chamber on 1 cylinder.

Not that its really important as most owners dont report problems....It could also be that there are a couple of different types of ECU's...I know RB25's have 2 types maybe Silvertop RB20s are the same??

They run fully sequential ignition so that wouldn't happen. However mixing the injectors up would mean one ran slightly leaner and one slightly richer as some of the fuel would pool on the valve vs less on the other cylinder.

So if this has been mixed up then it would quite possibly still mean worse idle/low load running as 2 cylinders would be running slightly out of sync AFR wise.

Yeah :)

Or its electrical interference half firing an injector at some random time or setting off one of the coils...could be anything really

An Oscilloscope would come in handy at times like this lol

Are RB20 and RB25 CAS' the same internally?

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now



  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • Hi Rob It's a nistune ecu. Yes same shop, good reputation. Apparently the computer on the dyno is compensated for temperature.    Chris was saying that the lean or richness of the mixture would be covered in the actual tune, but he's already picking up in advance that it's under what it should be. Regards the dyno, it's also noticeable on the road. But I just want to add something that has just come in, it appears there might be something in the setup of the external wastegate. In the exhaust manifold there is a centre divider between the front three and rear three cylinders. The external wastegate has a pipe from each side that join at the wastegate. Theory is those two pipes just might be pypassing that divider and introducing a problem somehow. Is anyone familiar with the divider in the exhaust manifold and the effects if the two wastegate pipes were to create a bypass path? Thanks for your questions Rob, interested in your thoughts on this external wastegate bypass theory. Regards Rob
    • Meh, At 60 years old, I have been doing dumb stuff for much longer than you mate, I am the true King And unfortunately I cannot be a maroon, as I am not brownish red As for not getting ITB's, the plenum intake will apparently show typical gains across the board and increase induction noise a bit, but, have all over less dort than ITB's Cost difference for the extra ITB dorts was significant though, the total parts for the plenum set up is "around" $2kAUD plus shipping, the ITB's were $4kAUD plus shipping, I was contemplating really hard about paying the extra $2k for all of the dorts, but weirdly, some form of common sense, from listening to the platform experts prevailed  As for the NA mod hate by some, I've had a few boosted cars, with all their inherent issues, I'm now looking at simplicity and legalities for a street car, maybe I'm just getting old, and I'm quite happy to spend some of the kids inheritance, 5kw at a time 🤣 And think of all the money I'll be saving on consumables that something with boost needs, like engines, gearboxes, diffs, clutches,  tilt trays... etc. etc. etc. 🤪
    • Haha.  I wouldn't say I am either but I've definitely been around it plenty.  I'm guessing you know the dial in is basically to make a handicap to level the playing field between racers.  The car with the slower dial in goes first and in theory if they run their dial in time and the faster car also does then they cross the finish time if they also have exactly the same reaction time - if you go faster than the dial in them you lose, but if you are too slow there's a good chance the other person will get to the finish line first. I'm normally supporting other cars but they were all pretty dialled and were egging me on to race as well, here's one of the cars I tune (Starlet) which ran within like 1 hundredth of its dial in through the competition: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=inEBu-d9Gn4&t=69s
    • Where ever the fuel reg gets it reference is what I use to T into for map reference been a very long time so where it goes to plenum/runners I have no idea but never had issues. 
    • What ecu? Same shop every time? Same ambient temperature? If timing is correct then pull plugs and see if lean or rich. Dyno can also read different if they have changed ramp rate or not set tacho/speed properly  
×
×
  • Create New...