Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 69
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Pretty much what my number 6 looked like when it let go....

it had standard pistons running 285rwkw.

what generally causes the piston to break away like that... is it just cause they're weak? or is there other contributing factors?

Detonation/pinging. It smashes the ring lands off pistons, and gives the rod bearings a good hammering at the same time. A look at the piston crowns and rod bearings, and the crank rod journels may reveal more.

Detonation/pinging. It smashes the ring lands off pistons, and gives the rod bearings a good hammering at the same time. A look at the piston crowns and rod bearings, and the crank rod journels may reveal more.

hmmm interesting thanks for the reply...

it was my number six cylinder and all the rest were fine

im assuming because that cylinder is at the back of the engine it gets alot hotter causing it to detonate/ping

Also just before i noticed the car blowing blue smoke i took the car on a long drive from sydney to Wagga,

the car was loaded up pretty heavy, id say it would have been carrying an extra 350-400 kg then it usually would.

could this cause the engine to detonate/ping due to the extra load?

Yes I have....although I think it was load, not boost. I spun a big end bearing shortly after. seriously.

I get the points. Wait until the big ends are checked.

f**ked bearings/clearances = low oil pressure under load.

hmmm interesting thanks for the reply...

it was my number six cylinder and all the rest were fine

im assuming because that cylinder is at the back of the engine it gets alot hotter causing it to detonate/ping

Also just before i noticed the car blowing blue smoke i took the car on a long drive from sydney to Wagga,

the car was loaded up pretty heavy, id say it would have been carrying an extra 350-400 kg then it usually would.

could this cause the engine to detonate/ping due to the extra load?

A lot of things cause detonation. Perhaps it was running a tune on the razor edge of safety vs death. An especially cold day or a little blow by oil in the intake could have been all it would take to push it over the edge.

The blue smoke you saw most likely happened after the damage was done. The rod bearings will tell the rest of the story.

what generally causes the piston to break away like that... is it just cause they're weak? or is there other contributing factors?

They can withstand 400rwkw if tuned correctly. The issue is heat and detonation. At those kind of power levels all you need is it to go slightly lean, or you be running it really hot and on the edge of detonation, hard corner and surge = lean, or putting it under load that it hasn't been tuned for and the tuner didn't richen/retard those cells making the motor detonate.

Basically down to tuning/fueling/cooling issue.

in that case i would be suspicious of the extra load the car was carrying on that long trip a week or two before it let go....

ive been informed that the PFC doesnt retard timing when knock levels become high,

so i guess what ever load the tuner puts the car on the dyno is what the tune is made for

cheers for the reply mate

A good tuner will tune the cells above what is being used extremely rich and retarded, much like what nissan did from the factory, hence the R&R feature everyone sooks about, at least their engines don't blow up though.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now



  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • Speaking of diverting threads, my second ever NISMO purchase…. I think they look pretty classy and just wanted to share 😅   PS: 1st was the oil drain plug 😂  
    • R12 has not been not available for....decades now. Propane is not a great replacement. (I mean, it's a great replacement, but it is a bit too flammable). R134a being the only way to go forward with an R12 system. The design pressures etc, are close enough to R12's to work. The ability to move heat around is close enough to R12's to work.
    • Out of curiosity, what's the reason for converting? I think @R3N3 might have the Frenchy's kit in the R33? I somehow think of you as the ambassador for realistic and clean street-driven setups nowadays  
    • careful when running the car after a boil over. Ive heard you can lose enough coolant that it won't show the right temps because of too much air in the system (or something like that). Make sure the levels are good before trying again.  Maybe a mobile mechanic can come have a look with their scan tool ?
    • OK, just for some extra clarity - there is more than one option at Frenchy's. 1. You can buy the whole kit - with or without the actual compressor. The whole kit includes mounts, hoses, condensor, etc. That's either ~$2200 or ~$2800. No surgery required with this option. 2. You can buy just the bracket (~$600), or the bracket with the compressor (~$1200). Either of this or the above option "without the compressor" is if you already have an Echo comp or you are able to source one locally. Whatever the case, in this option, you will need surgery done on your hoses to adapt to the new compressor. When I said "the Frenchy's kit", I meant the whole kit in option 1. It is obviously somewhat more $$ than a $1500 OEM compressor. But if I had to spend $1500 on an OEM compressor, I would certainly consider spending double that to renew and significantly update everything forward of the firewall. Another option is to rebuild your original compressor. My R34 comp is currently dead and I will be most likely doing that to it if the spare one in the shed is also leaky.
×
×
  • Create New...