Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

Hey Guys,

What could be causing it to break again within 2 months of getting one replaced? It was replaced with a standard one, not a reinforced one, but it should not be breaking regardless in such short time.

Clutch is 18months old and is a Exceedy Heavy Duty item. No slippage.

cheers

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/384884-clutch-pivot-ball/
Share on other sites

Thanks guys, actually it wasnt broken again! Just talked to my mechanic.. he said the something about the Bearing on the clutch fork wasnt on properly.. i dont know much about gearboxes sorry. Hut he said the retaining pin was still on it.

Said hes never seen anything like it before... but im not getting charged for any of the work.

  On 08/12/2011 at 12:11 AM, Checkbuzz said:

+1 - The standard clutch pivot ball is a known weak-link and you are running a HD clutch. You can pick up a NIMSO item off Ebay for $60 (40% stronger).

Job Done :thumbsup:

I have only ever seen these break on heavy twin and tripple plate clutch setups or when the clutch spring seizes. I wouldn't call them a weak link. If the people replacing clutches have properly greases the pivot ball, it should never break unless the above conditions are met.

  On 08/12/2011 at 12:15 AM, SlowSkyline said:

Thanks guys, actually it wasnt broken again! Just talked to my mechanic.. he said the something about the Bearing on the clutch fork wasnt on properly.. i dont know much about gearboxes sorry. Hut he said the retaining pin was still on it.

Said hes never seen anything like it before... but im not getting charged for any of the work.

It's likely the retaining clip for the carrier was not on properly or the pivot ball retaining clip was not on correctly

Not common unless someone didn't do it right when the clutch/ball was done the first time

  On 08/12/2011 at 12:53 AM, Elite Racing said:

I have only ever seen these break on heavy twin and tripple plate clutch setups or when the clutch spring seizes. I wouldn't call them a weak link. If the people replacing clutches have properly greases the pivot ball, it should never break unless the above conditions are met.

Mine broke after 3-4 years with an OS Giken comp twin plate, but it looked like it had worked itself loose, which caused it to snap the thread.

Either way $60 at Autobarn for a Nismo one was good insurance.

  On 08/12/2011 at 12:53 AM, Elite Racing said:

I have only ever seen these break on heavy twin and tripple plate clutch setups or when the clutch spring seizes. I wouldn't call them a weak link. If the people replacing clutches have properly greases the pivot ball, it should never break unless the above conditions are met.

It's likely the retaining clip for the carrier was not on properly or the pivot ball retaining clip was not on correctly

Not common unless someone didn't do it right when the clutch/ball was done the first time

Just called him again.. He put it all back together, went to go for a road test and the clutch went to the floor again :(

He doesnt really have any idea why its doing it.. he did say the piston into the slave cylinder was hard to get in again.

he was checking it to see if that was the issue.. got a call this morning, hes now replacing the clutch throw out fork he said its fairly worn.. and getting a reinforced clutch pivot ball just in case.

Still not sure why its going to the floor, he said all the hydraulics look fine, and when he blead the system the clutch felt great! he got it 2m out of the workshop and it went to the floor again.. some bearing is twisting even with the pin on it.. not sure what it is called.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • Update Issues 5 (plus #4) - 10 After making a claim about issue #4's missing part, DeAgostini Japan sent a whole new issue #4 and it arrived about 2 weeks after that. That was back in early March. It took another 4 weeks to receive issues 5 - 13 though. This update is for issues 5 - 10. Ove the 5 issues the front left suspension and most of the engine have been completed. The quality of the castings and fit of the parts is quite good, it seems better than DeAgostini's BNR34 Skyline GT-R from the Fast & Furious 2 movie, which (to me anyway) doesn't seem to have as tight tolerances or quite as accurate castings.  Each issue has a lot of info about the 1989 - 1993 Skyline range and other Nissan models from that era, but the focus is on the BNR32 Skyline GT-R Nismo and the various racing it did in Japan, Europe (Spa 24hrs) and of course Australia. I've included some text translated with Google Lens in some photos and will add to them if there's anything worth including. 
    • If it's for a SR20, make sure it's not the American Poncams, might as well call them Poocams. Had a set in a friend's car, all scuffed up after a few track days. Like the metallurgy Tomei USA used is junk. Went back to JDM OG Tomei Poncams, no issues till now.   Tomei USA is not the real OG Tomei.   Random rant over, fk the US of A, bunch of c u n t s. 
    • Most of the industry in North America either runs on Siemens or Allen Bradley. I have two redundant S7-1500's on my desk right next to me for simulation. Siemens has been losing ground though since Stuxnet, as cybersecurity is a big thing. In my line of work that is federally regulated, you must by law have a cybersecurity management program in place and its audited and inspected every so often.  I work with Emerson PLC's daily (RX3i's) and have done large biogas/refinery projects with their DCS's. Their PLC's are somewhat OK minus the way they do PLC redundancy (You have to download on both PLC's separately every time you make a change )  As for their DCS's... you'll be limited financially first before anything else stops you. Costs are exorbiant at roughly 10x what it would cost you to do with any other system (e.g AB PAC).  1990's, those suckers are brand new haha! Kraft-Heinz (An old client when I use to work for an ESP) still runs Siemens TI505 PLC's from the mid 80's. Ohh how I don't miss working with those... you could only do a certain number of online downloads until it's "Change" buffer would be full and you would then need to go offline to do a full download. There was no warning of when this was coming up and it generally would happen when you would go in at 2am to make changes before production -_-.     
    • Unfortunately, not only is that not the case, one of the main "Selling points" of safety over comms is they clearly state in writing that there's no need to segregate safety networks from non-safety networks. It always gets intermingled with everything else on an ICS/OT network. 
×
×
  • Create New...