Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

It's my understanding solid lifter cams won't work in hydraulic lifter engines as the profile shape is different.

...yeh im listening, can you elaborate on how the profile is different?

I cant see there being any real effect especially at under 7,400rpm. Fair enough the valve springs may be a bit different due to the difference between sold v hydraulic lifters.Also the solid cams in order to have higher lift over same duration must have a higher ramp rate then RB20 hydraulics.......but i dont know, just thinking/guessing

Dont hydraulic lifter engine normally run higher spring rates then sold lifters? So is it safe to assume that putting a solid lifter cam in a hydraulic application is safer / will work better then hydraulic cam into sold lifter engine?

Excuse me if not using the proper terms...its been 4 years since i passed MOMs :Oops:

The RB20 has 240deg - 7.8mm lift intake & 240deg - 7.8mm lift exhaust

The RB26 has 240deg - 8.5mm lift intake & 236deg - 8.2mm lift exhaust

So any increase in power will come from the increase in lift, not duration

  • Replies 285
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

it all depends on lift as to whether they work with hydro lifters or not.

i think there is a 0.9mm increase in lift with the GTR cams over std, but i think anything over 9.5mm (not 100% if its exactly 9.5) and the hydraulic lifters need to be changed to a solid lifter kit.

Of interest is that Tomei make the following cams, and are abolt in affair using std hydraulic lifters and RB20DET valvesprings:

256° / 8.50 inlet (PONCAM)

260° / 8.50 exhaust (PONCAM)

So from a mechanics (dont tell me i have to digout my mechanics of machine texts from uni) i suppose you could have an issue with increasing lift without the duration as the valve velocities would increase, which is perhaps why the above Tomei cams work with the std RB20 valvetrane.... then again we are perhaps makign a mountain out of an ant mound considering the physics of it all.

i used tomei springs in my rb25 and that suit up to 8.8 lift from memory, so the rb20 would be very similar i would say, i used a rb26 exh cam to get the max lift with more duration so i would like to know any diff between solid and hyd lift cams

The old solid versus hydraulics question, there's a blast from the Chevy past. :Bang:

When the follower fills with oil it is SOLID, not compressible, so the effect on the valve (open and close) is exactly the same. The only real difference occurs as the oil is moving into and out of the follower, simplistically, when the valve is closed.

The "filling up with oil rapidly enough" is worth noting as this is why the rpm limit for hydraulic followers is lower than for solids. They, what is called colloquially called, pump down ie; the oil level gradually falls as it can't get in fast enough to hold the follower at full extension. Thus the clearances get large and the follower start to knock. :)

So, provided the followers don't leak oil pressure and fill up with oil rapidly enough, then there is basically no difference between a current generation of hydraulic follower and a solid follower. :(

This of course was not the case with the Chevy, the lifters leaked, the oil was slow moving, the oil itself was not so good. So "hydraulic" cams had softer ramp rates than "solid" cams to allow time for the oil to flow. :dump:

Time has moved on and the dinosaurs are gone, well from my garage anyway. ;)

OK i've been following this thread for a while and are thinking of doing the swap but it seems to have hit a snag, i'll be doing some other mods at the same time and was asking what would be the salution to the idle problem? example, the ECU does it need a swap to after market or a rechip or maybe a piggy back system.. any surgestions/help....

... i'll be doing some other mods at the same time and was asking what would be the solution to the idle problem?

My suggestion is if you are goin gto install the cams get a flexible management system first... then after the car is set up a nd running properly with new management then intall the cams.

I did the cams, AFM, cam gears and ECU in the one hit and workshop is having trouble getting the thing running, could be a completely unrelated problems (coincidence) or could be a combination of issues arising from all the parts bolted on in one hit....so unless you gave done the GTR cam swap before, (or your workshop), then id suggest small bites as it makes everyones life easier, if not a little more expensive.

My suggestion is if you are goin gto install the cams get a flexible management system first... then after the car is set up a nd running properly with new management then intall the cams.  

I did the cams, AFM, cam gears and ECU in the one hit and workshop is having trouble getting the thing running, could be a completely unrelated problems (coincidence) or could be a combination of issues arising from all the parts bolted on in one hit....so unless you gave done the GTR cam swap before, (or your workshop), then id suggest small bites as it makes everyones life easier, if not a little more expensive.

top quality advice...

i'd agree and say the 'little bites at a time' method of trying one thing before the next (rather than everything at once) is much more effective at diagnosing problems that generally arise. unless you are going to a top workshop that specialises in skylines then most mechanics will shake their head if you swapped alot and they can't get it to work - if only we lived in japan where skylines are the equivilent of commodores/falcons and mechanics know them inside-out!

tif only we lived in japan where skylines are the equivilent of commodores/falcons and mechanics know them inside-out!

Ho ho ho, you couldn't afford to pay them. Mechanics in Japan charge like brain surgeons. :) That's why everything has to be bolt on.

I was contemplating doing GTR Cams, Gears, GTR injectors all at once on my Cefiro because a friend of mine does alot with Nissan ECU tuning (Makes bulk SR daughterboards etc *another top aussie export product!*) and I figured it would be cheaper for dyno time to do it all at once (Can get the tune done for free). I was also going to start off with a base Mines map aswell.

So perhaps no now? I would have presumed it would be rather common for people to do fuel stuff, cams & boost all at once to get good performance? Im hoping not to see any issues from screwing up the boost and putting in cams, but just getting the electronics for the injectors running shouldnt be too much of a drama either.

Crawl before running?

JK

  • 3 weeks later...

Well, bringing this thread back from the dead. The GTR cams into RB20 has resulted in a dead engine. Dont read too much into that statement without reading all the post.

Like bbenny when my inlet cam went in it was a bit tight to turn the cam wheel by hand. With the timing belt back on i could turn the engine over easily by hand so didt think too much of the tightness.

Now it appears the car when trying to get tuned was skipping teeth on the belt, so me thinks DOH i rooted the timing belt/tensioner when playing with the engine. But it appears that the tightness in the inlet cam was enough resistance to encourage the 80,000kms timing belt and worn cam wheel to hop teeth.

And today im the proud owner of an engine with a bent inlet valve in cyl #1 :D , such as sad death for an engine that had been cained for 170,000kms and never skipped a beat...it deserved a warriors death screaming down the straight at Phillip Island at 1.5 bar with rods out the side of the block with me spinning/crashing/burning on my own engine oil. :flamed:

Not a rough 500rpm idle and cough...GAME OVER :O

So if doing this mod, if you notice any tightness in the inlet cam like bbebnny and i did, abandon the mod and see a professional, as to date no one can expalin to me why my inlet cam may be as tight as it is?

Oh and now have a set of R33 GTR V-Spec cams for sale :Oops: ...

Ok WTF is going on,are people putting the cam cap thingys on backwards (I don't mean you Roy)  

WazR32GTSt has his running,did you use the GTR cam caps?

LOL...Why not me, im the Hannibal Lechter of the DIY crew :Oops:

My cam journal/caps were 100% on the right way, all markings lined up correctly, at TDC the flank of the #1 cam lobe even appeared to be in the right position?!?! i dont know what else i could of visually checked to ensure everything was lined up correctly. And i was using RB20 caps, and the exhaust side was fine

I dont know but i suspect my problem has to do with the age / condition of my engine, it has seen over 3,000kms of track work and 170,000kms total. Even though i was amazed how clean the valve gear was it is old and i think it may be a lifter problem as the engine did have the occassional ticking when the car first started up when cold.

New head goes in this week, if the mechanic is adventurous after we get it running tuend with std cams may convince him to give the GTR cams a go in the other head and see how it goes...may be able to get some before after results with the TD06 so will show if the std cams hurt flow / performance on the RB20s.

i can confirm it is the ECU flysky. because i checked and tried everything, there were no other causes. and SydneyKid has done several running a PFC with no problems and considerable gains. no probs with standard cams joel

adjusting any of the cams will probably cause it run poorly at idle, hence changing the cams with a stock ECU is probably not a great idea as the ignition timing is basically set for a stock cam combo afterall. That would make sense wouldn't it (?)

Even just with an exhaust camgear added on my old car to change things a little, i noticed the idle was a lot poorer, and more "lumpier".. stock ECU w/ S-AFC. Was fine to drive, but idle = goats. Wasn't absolutely terrible but in the mornings had some trouble and revs would jump all over the place at idle. With a proper aftermarket could probably tune it out I would imagine. Never got to find that out.

That is not good news! Did you compare the physicaly dimensions of the standard cams and the GTR cams? Both had issues with the inlet cams... very interesting...

Now im very weary of upgrading my cams, or atleast the Inlet cam (worth the hassle just putting in the exhaust one?)

Any further info you can provide us with?

Thanks

JK

Hi Roy, I have been thinking about this camshaft tight in the bearings problem. I haven't seen it in an RB engine, but I have in other 6 cylinder DOHC engines. The camshafts are very looooong and I have found 2 that where not straight. Looks like they were in an engine that overheated or had the head torqued down incorrectly. This "bent" the camshafts and they went tight in the bearings.

We have had one of the race GTR's lock up an inlet camshaft which may or may not have been as a result of a "bent" camshaft. It is certainly "bent" now, but I can't tell if that was the cause of the problem or the result. So I am suspicious that RB's may not be immune from this problem.

So Roy, can I strongly suggest that you get the camshaft checked for straightness before you put it in another head. I am going to get the dial gauge out and check a set of RB26 cams that are destined for one of our RB20's. I will let you know what happens. :D

You can get digital verniers from places like Jaycar / Dixk Smith. As for dial gauges, i think it may be best to go see your local engine / machine shop and get them to check for you, as to check the cam with a dial gauge you will need a jig/fixing to rotate the cam in?!?!?!

Hey All,

Sorry to bump this thread up again but I've just purchased some R34 Nur spec gtr cams at a very very good price. I'm putting them aside for my new RB20 when I replace my current somewhat tired one.

Was just wondering if anyone knew of differences between the various gtr cams and if possible what differences I might find with the N1 cams.

I did a couple searches on the forums for gtr cam differences but couldn't find anything apart from a slight mention earlier in this thread.

Thanks for your help

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now



  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • Thanks, I removed the fuse and the relay from the car and made my own circuit with them to test them with a test bulb.  I will look for the wiring diagram and go from there.
    • Jdm DC2R is also nice for a FF car compared to the regular hatches of the time.
    • Now that the break-in period for both clutch and transmission is nearly over I'd like to give some tips before I forget about everything that happened, also for anyone searching up how to do this job in the future: You will need at least 6 ton jack stands at full extension. I would go as far as to say maybe consider 12 ton jack stands because the height of the transmission + the Harbor Freight hydraulic platform-style transmission jack was enough that it was an absolute PITA getting the transmission out from under the car and back in. The top edge of the bellhousing wants to contact the subframe and oil pan and if you're doing this on the floor forget about trying to lift this transmission off the ground and onto a transmission jack from under the car. Also do not try to use a scissor jack transmission lift. You have to rotate the damn thing in-place on the transmission jack which is hard enough with an adjustable platform and a transmission cradle that will mostly keep the transmission from rolling off the jack but on a scissor lift with a tiny non-adjustable platform? Forget it. Use penetrating oil on the driveshaft bolts. I highly recommend getting a thin 6 point combination (box end + open end) wrench for both the rear driveshaft and front driveshaft and a wrench extension. These bolts are on tight with very little space to work with and those two things together made a massive difference. Even a high torque impact wrench is just the wrong tool for the job here and didn't do what I needed it to do. If your starter bolts aren't seized in place for whatever reason you can in fact snake in a 3/8 inch ratchet + 6 point standard chrome socket up in there and "just" remove the bolts for the starter. Or at least I could. It is entirely by feel, you can barely fit it in, you can barely turn the stupid ratchet, but it is possible. Pull the front pipe/downpipe before you attempt to remove the transmission. In theory you don't have to, in practice just do it.  When pulling the transmission on the way out you don't have to undo all the bolts holding the rear driveshaft to the chassis like the center support bearing and the rear tunnel reinforcement bar but putting the transmission back in I highly recommend doing this because it will let you raise the transmission without constantly dealing with the driveshaft interfering in one way or another. I undid the bottom of the engine mount but I honestly don't know that it helped anything. If you do this make sure you put a towel on the back of the valve cover to keep the engine from smashing all the pipes on the firewall. Once the transmission has been pulled back far enough to clear the dowels you need to twist it in place clockwise if you're sitting behind the transmission. This will rotate the starter down towards the ground. The starter bump seems like it might clear if you twist the transmission the other way but it definitely won't. I have scraped the shit out of my transmission tunnel trying so learn from my mistake. You will need a center punch and an appropriate size drill bit and screw to pull the rear main seal. Then use vice grips and preferably a slide hammer attachment for those vice grips to yank the seal out. Do not let the drill or screw contact any part of the crank and clean the engine carefully after removing the seal to avoid getting metal fragments into the engine. I used a Slide Hammer and Bearing Puller Set, 5 Piece from Harbor Freight to pull the old pilot bearing. The "wet paper towel" trick sucked and just got dirty clutch water everywhere. Buy the tool or borrow it from a friend and save yourself the pain. It comes right out. Mine was very worn compared to the new one and it was starting to show cracks. Soak it in engine oil for a day in case yours has lost all of the oil to the plastic bag it comes in. You may be tempted to get the Nismo aftermarket pilot bearing but local mechanics have told me that they fail prematurely and if they do fail they do far more damage than a failed OEM pilot bushing. I mentioned this before but the Super Coppermix Twin clutch friction disks are in fact directional. The subtle coning of the fingers in both cases should be facing towards the center of the hub. So the coning on the rearmost disk closest to the pressure plate should go towards the engine, and the one closest to the flywheel should be flipped the other way. Otherwise when you torque down the pressure plate it will be warped and if you attempt to drive it like this it will make a very nasty grinding noise. Also, there is in fact an orientation to the washers for the pressure plate if you don't want to damage the anodizing. Rounded side of the washer faces the pressure plate. The flat side faces the bolt head. Pulling the transmission from the transfer case you need to be extremely careful with the shift cover plate. This part is discontinued. Try your best to avoid damaging the mating surfaces or breaking the pry points. I used a dead blow rubber hammer after removing the bolts to smack it sideways to slide it off the RTV the previous mechanic applied. I recommend using gasket dressing on the OEM paper gasket to try and keep the ATF from leaking out of that surface which seems to be a perpetual problem. Undoing the shifter rod end is an absolute PITA. Get a set of roll pin punches. Those are mandatory for this. Also I strongly, strongly recommend getting a palm nailer that will fit your roll pin punch. Also, put a clean (emphasis on clean) towel wrapped around the back end of the roll pin to keep it from shooting into the transfer case so you can spend a good hour or two with a magnet on a stick getting it out. Do not damage the shifter rod end either because those are discontinued as well. Do not use aftermarket flywheel bolts. Or if you do, make sure they are exactly the same dimensions as OEM before you go to install them. I have seen people mention that they got the wrong bolts and it meant having to do the job again. High torque impact wrench makes removal easy. I used some combination of a pry bar and flathead screwdriver to keep the flywheel from turning but consider just buying a proper flywheel lock instead. Just buy the OS Giken clutch alignment tool from RHDJapan. I hated the plastic alignment tool and you will never be confident this thing will work as intended. Don't forget to install the Nismo provided clutch fork boot. Otherwise it will make unearthly noises when you press the clutch pedal as it says on the little installation sheet in Japanese. Also, on both initial disassembly and assembly you must follow torque sequence for the pressure plate bolts. For some reason the Nismo directions tell you to put in the smaller 3 bolts last. I would not do this. Fully insert and thread those bolts to the end first, then tighten the other larger pressure plate bolts according to torque sequence. Then at the end you can also torque these 3 smaller bolts. Doing it the other way can cause these bolts to bind and the whole thing won't fit as it should. Hope this helps someone out there.
×
×
  • Create New...