Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

Hi guys...

Just after a straite yes/no answer, been doing some research and cant find what i need...

I have a R34GTT and im looking at buying a s/hand Excedy twin plate clutch from a R33 GTR. It is a pull type clutch, comes with replacement flywheel only

Will this bolt straite in and work or will i need a push pull convertor? Are the clutches the same size?

Any info you guys can give me would be great

Thanx

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/397535-r34-gtt-twin-plate-upgrade-help/
Share on other sites

AT the moment the car is running stock turbo, the plans of a bigger turbo are on the cards for the near future though, so im planning ahead...

The clutch is cheap!! Under $500 thats why im looking at it

The R34 pull type clutch uses a 250mm plate so straight off the bat they are gonna hold more torque than the 240mm plate on the previous models. Unless you are going to be making more than 550hp at the wheels then you can get a really good brand new single plate from NPC for about the $900 mark or less and if you aren't going to go over 400hp at the wheels, an organic plate behind a slightly modified cover will suit you fine and they are $100 cheaper.

Is it worth buying the second hand stuff to suit a different model and possibly having issues just to save a couple of hundred?

It certainly won't save you any money if there is problems and you have to pay twice to have it fitted or fixed

Twin plate clutch on a std gtt, do it like everyone else does upgrade power and handling and wait for shit to break.

Upgrading the clutch first with a possible stuffed used twin plate is stupid.

I hear what your saying and thanks for your words of wisdom. The twin plate excedy to buy for my car is over $2k so if i can buy a s/hand one from a a different model for a quarter the price then i would be crazy not to give it a go if it was to work the same..

Im trying to find out as much as i can re: fittment to try work out if i have to mod anything to make it work and then i can see if its going to be cost efficient.

power wise i doubt the car wil see 500hp@wheels. plans are for a 35R on E85 around 20-25pound with some drop in sticks

Twin plate clutch on a std gtt, do it like everyone else does upgrade power and handling and wait for shit to break.

Upgrading the clutch first with a possible stuffed used twin plate is stupid.

Im not going to buy the clutch if its stuffed am I!!!

I hear what your saying and thanks for your words of wisdom. The twin plate excedy to buy for my car is over $2k so if i can buy a s/hand one from a a different model for a quarter the price then i would be crazy not to give it a go if it was to work the same..

Im trying to find out as much as i can re: fittment to try work out if i have to mod anything to make it work and then i can see if its going to be cost efficient.

power wise i doubt the car wil see 500hp@wheels. plans are for a 35R on E85 around 20-25pound with some drop in sticks

GT35R on 25 pound of boost and E85 is going to see 500 hp.

On the subject of buying a stuffed clutch - do you know what you are looking at? How are you going to tell if the plates are worn out or if they have X life left?

Then even if you know that, are you going to be able to tell if there is spline damage, a warped hub or a fragmenting friction material?

Just because something is is $2000 new and you can get it for $500, doesn't mean it's going to work well and the fact that it's 1/4 of the price would usually tell me that it needs rebuilding.....which is going to set you back about $800-900 anyway.

Just because something is is $2000 new and you can get it for $500, doesn't mean it's going to work well and the fact that it's 1/4 of the price would usually tell me that it needs rebuilding.....which is going to set you back about $800-900 anyway.

Exactly.

power wise i doubt the car wil see 500hp@wheels. plans are for a 35R on E85 around 20-25pound with some drop in sticks

come back and ask the question again once youve done all of this ^^^^

cause you make it sound so easy... if your skimping on a new clutch but have these plans to a 35r you either dont know what your talking about or it will never happen anyways...

leave the 'twin plate' clutch till last, get a clutch that will handle stock power for now if your current once is dead...

you do realise for under 500hp you dont actually need a twin plate necessarily...

do some more research

Damm this has turned into a HATE fest!!

Excedy web site shows same part number for both applications, so that tells me it will work. Advise given re: it might need a rebuild... isn't that the risk we all take on buying second hand parts ???

I am also aware that a single will probly do the job, well it will do the job but i would rather just go hard on the clutch while im there, better to go over kill now then have to replace it again in 12 months when the car is making power as FYA would do!!

If i have to rebuild the clutch it will be as good as a brand new unit and still cheaper then buying brand new unit in the first place

Not a hate fest at all...

just dont understand, if your aiming to do things right the first time why but a used gtr clutch, why not get a decent new clutch to suit your car...?

after the conversion to make it fit and then the possible rebuild, you would of been better buying the right clutch first time round...

plus the fact the twin plate will suck with everything else std...

your simply doing it wrong...

FYA i think u need to read my post again....

The clutch is the right clutch for my car. There will be no conversion! Its the same part number so that means its the right part for the job.

The car has everything else done, just still running stock turbo. Will the setup i have now its making 270@wheels so I think the twin plate will be fine. It has a sprung centre so drivabilty for my weeker should be perfect.

Thanks all for your input

Question: Can I bolt an R33 GTR clutch to my R34 GTT RB25DET Neo and will it work?

Answer: Yes

Secondary answer: They are not the same. Even though Exedy may now sell them under the same part number, they have different release properties due to cylinder differences and the fact the GTR has a clutch booster, so you may get a shit pedal feel. Most people adjust it out but there is a tradeoff..

I will make a 50c bet that says the $500 pull type twin plate makes a better boat anchor than it does a clutch that will serve you well. Rebuild it - IF it's possible to and the damage is not too severe AND you have just outlayed $1300-$1400 when you could have just bought a proper single to do the job that will feel nicer, drive better and will be BRAND NEW for half the price.

I understand where you are coming from though, but out of every customer that walks in my door and presents me with a second hand part to fit, they have ended up needing to pay more than what it would have cost to do it properly the first time.

If you still want to get the secondhand twin plate, let me know coz I have a few old rear main seals and an alright looking spigot bush laying around somewhere.

  • 3 weeks later...

Hey R33L,

I can relate very muchly to overenginnering everything you put into the car.

The confidence whilst driving that the machine is strong and nothing you are going to do will hurt it; makes me very happy.

I achieved this just by putting in an exedy heavy duty and the flywheel that went with it... It feels stronger than anything else in the car.

Then again i'm not making 270 :(

But if this part has come out of a 33gtr it could be more than a decade old... And You've

got more issues to worry about upcoming than just the clutch too.

By the time you've done 130,000 like My car has you'll have your synchros in the gearbox starting to wear out too. Mines having a recondition now.

Pain in the arse.

I have HKS GD max Twin Plate clutch and lightweight Flywheel for sale its only done max 500klm max to suit r34 GTT might suit others as well 32,33,34 GTRs,

took it out as I personally didn’t like it, it has that stock feeling very light but bitiey as hell .went back to single plate .

I have paid $2700 + shipping for this HKS twin plate clutch brand new

Will sell it for

$1300 firm

just to cover costs of my single plate ,

please let me know If your Interested PM me and I can send u some photos and measurements of how thick the discs are.

Fark no, please dont use a secondhand clutch plate, the bastard could have been tortured to the shithouse and caused damage that wouldnt be obvious till you have had it fitted to your car

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • Pfft. As if I'd ever point a high pressure washer at my car.
    • The nature of my commute has changed. Way back then it was traffic lights all the way, for ~28km. It sucked. When they finally stitched the expressway together I could do a good 15+km of it at a steady 80-100 with no stopping. That alone has gotten me down to flat 10s. Prior to that it was mid-high 10s. I can't remember the delta that I saw when I got the idle down. It was only ~150 rpm, because the idle speed was never terrible, but for the delta in consumption to be noticeable it would have had to have been at least 0.2-0.3 L/100km - which is not to be sneezed at when it comes for absolute free. It's only about 50L per year, but that's ~$100. A few extra pizzas is always welcome. Note that I have a record of every tank of fuel that has ever gone through my car except for a handful put in by someone else, like my mechanic. I can show you the difference between stock RB20 and tuned RB20, stock RB5Neo and tuned, winter and summer fuel blends, winter and summer fuel blends when the ambient temperature is not appropriate for the blend, working O2 sensor, blown O2 sensor, boosting f**k out of it and frightened to boost it because it is pinging, and so on. OK, I probably can't do all that now with 100% clarity - but at the time when any of those things were in event, you could see it in the records. There's 25+ years of simple tank after tank records, so you have to look for landmarks to work out approximately how old any single record is. What's really important is the meta data and that lives in my head.
    • If you're claiming the issues are not skyline specific, then either the USA is living in the 90s / early 2000s, OR you have the issue of "survivor bias". Which is you're mainly hearing and listening to those with terrible experiences, and haven't found the guys who have cars with good decent builds and no problems. It happens in AU too, that plenty of people keep having issues, and they keep going to the workshops that are known to be shit "because I read on the internet". Even worse, are those who keep posting on the internet as though they know for a fact what something is, when they've never touched/looked at said item in their life, and again are making assumptions, based on something they read, or because it's a certain way in other cars. It's even funnier when those same people debate the facts with the people who've lived and breathed this stuff for over 15 years. Example, I've had someone tell me you can't do something with a Skyline, because they read it on the internet, except I can tell they're wrong, as I did that exact thing back in 2008 with my Skyline.
    • The funniest part I saw, was someone would bitch and moan on FB about something, Andy would be the one to respond, asking for more info, if he could contact them, what the engine setup is, what their config file was, and 95% of the responses were people just going "der! It doesn't work" and Andy going "What doesn't work?" And then going "The firmware!" And they'd go around in circles as no one could ever give information, and Haltech couldn't fault things on the bench, (especially when people wouldn't give any specifics).   Many moons ago, when Andy was back at e420c stage, he reached out to me, and asked me to test different plug and play looms for him (already had an e420c in the car on his V1 PNP loom). And he kept asking me, as I was competent enough to be able to give him some specific feedback on what was/wasn't working, how to replicate the faults etc, and work through things with him. Most people are terrible at answering the questions they're asked, or being able to provide quality feedback other than "it doesn't work".
    • I say it often, none of this stuff is really Skyline-specific per se. But in general there's not a lot of people who actually know what they're doing. A lot of people charging like they do. Agile software development probably isn't the greatest idea for an engine controller.
×
×
  • Create New...