Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

Hi All,

I bought some ARP main studs for my RB30/26 about 5 years ago from Spool and recently started building the engine.

The block was sent away for machining with the studs and I requested that the mains girdle be torqued to 65-70 ft lbs with ARP Moly lube for the main tunnel honing as per the torque specs in this thread http://www.skylinesaustralia.com/forums/topic/388491-help-what-tension-arp-main-studs/?hl=arp+main+torque#entry6196886

Got the block back and torqued the girdle down to 70ft lbs to measure the bearing clearances with plastigauge. Clearances were fine so final assembled and then found that I needed to cut one of the 3 long studs down to clear the shaft that passes through the RB26 sump. Released the girdle, cut the appropriate stud down and re-assembled back in its hole. Torqued the main bearing ladder back down and one of the shorter studs sheared before it reached 70 ftlbs !

post-4871-0-29073300-1371502721_thumb.jpg

post-4871-0-90047400-1371502830_thumb.jpg

Managed to drill the bugger out but now I'm left wondering why exactly it sheared. The threads in the block were clean. The stud was hand tightened first. ARP moly lube was used in assembly and the main studs were tightened in the appropriate order with a good quality Snap-on torque wrench.

Is it just a case of 70ftlbs is too much or could it be a faulty stud ?

Should I replace the whole set as a precaution or is it safe to just replace the single stud do you think ? If thats the case does anyone know the ARP part number for one of the short studs ? It would appear to be M10 x1.5 where it screws into the block, 105mm long and the nut end would appear to be a different pitch thread - possibly M10 x 1.25

During my searching I've found torque figures of 55, 60, 65, 70 and 73-75 ft lbs for RB ARP main studs so some clarity and real world experiences would be nice.

Edited by mambastu

I'm told by ARP that there isn't an official main stud kit for the RB30 and the stud kit arrived in a bag so Spool must make up a kit and unfortunately there wasn't a spec sheet with them.

Incidentally the 73-75 ft lb torque figure came from your excellent thread at http://www.skylinesaustralia.com/forums/topic/378823-engine-internals-comp-ratios-general-info/?hl=%2Barp+%2Bmain+%2Bstud+%2Btorque if you're able to edit that at all (you may not be able to due to its age) it could help people with future searches. :)

  • 1 month later...

There has been a batch of arp studs floating around snapping. I usually torque them to factory nm +10nm and NEVER have a issue however a couple of years ago we had several engines primarily rb getting snapped studs on factory or below torque settings. We werent the only people to of suffered this. Try getting arp2000 or l-19 studs. Secondly DO NOT CUT that stud down. Have it machined off at a machine shop. TBH ive NEVER had any clearance issues with this stud so many have

When was your torque wrench last calibrated? Just because its a snap on wrench it doesn't mean its even close to being with spec. They are a pain in the ass to calibrate and get parts for too.

Seriously consider having it calibrated again before you do up another set of studs, lest you start breaking rod bolts next.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • Hey @Butters, did you end up getting this clutch in ? I have just ordered to a uniclutch track to go in my getrag 6 speed that’s in my BNR 32     
    • I know you don't want to hear this comment, but I can't not say it.  I just can't see 200kw being worth the time and effort. Its like guys with NA cars, putting in headers/exhaust/tune for a massive 20% jump in power. Great, the slow car is still slow and you're down $10,000.  My vote is leave it NA or price in a gearbox upgrade and shoot for at least 300KW, preferably 350KW+.  Now you have a NC that will try to kill you from time to time and will be exciting to drive
    • Ah yep. The main message I want to pass on is, try not to get scared of ghosts when thinking about knock/knock detection.  What I mean is, healthy engines make noise. Knock is also noise. Your knock sensor and ECU combo are trying to determine bad noise from good noise based on how loud the noise is. The factory knock sensors and ECU are not good at doing this.  Modern ECU's are pretty decent at it, however I'd still say that you would want to verify that if your ECU says it's knock, that you actually listen to it and confirm that it is correct.  Are you familiar with the plex knock monitor?  https://www.plex-tuning.com/products/plex-knock-monitor-v3/ I expect you're the type of person that would be very keen to play with something like this. It is great knock detection and you can pop some headphones on and listen to what's going on.  Knock that you've deliberately induced in low load low RPM areas is not really putting anything at risk and is a great tuning/learning/verification tool.  I just thought this was worth mentioning based on the way you were talking about setting up a base map and the Haltech base map settings. There are better ways to spend your time then chasing ghosts and worrying about detonation in scenarios that it is crazy unlikely to encounter it.  I was also wondering, what ECU are you planning to get? Will it be long til you pick it up?
    • This came quicker than I thought. It ain't even 2025 yet.
    • I somehow quoted my post instead of editing it. I regret nothing.
×
×
  • Create New...