Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

Long time reader occassional poster here!

So to make a long story short: I've been a bit lazy with the upkeep on my M35 and let the last service go nearly 4 or 5000 ks overdue (I hardly drive it these days and my brain tricks me into thinking I'm not racking up any ks and never pay attention to the odo). Shortly after the last service a sort of ticking/clicking noise appeared from the engine bay somewhere. Didn't think anything of it, thought it must have been something the fan was hitting or something (read: me stupid). Fast forward several months later and now my turbo has blown up, again. Not sure if related...

Now my dilemma is do I get a new turbo or is this ticking noise a whole other can of worms? I'm happy to shell out a couple of grand to get it up and running, but if it's a case of getting a half cut and installing that then I might be better off selling as is for some crazy low price :(

I've taken it to my mechanic, but as good as he is he's not really that familiar with VQ engines. He sent me off to research because he can't use computers :closedeyes:

Thankyou stagea gods

Cheers

Glenn

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/431924-engine-and-turbo-woes/
Share on other sites

Where are you Glenn? It might pay to take it to someone who knows a lot about these cars (eg Jetwreck in Sydney, Scotty M35 in Melb) for some advice.

I'm in Canberra which isn't helpful, and driving it to sydney wouldn't do me any favours! I guess I could get it towed/transported though but my wife is about to murder me already over what this car is costing and I'd have to convince her it'd be worth spending more on it before doing that :)

OK then. What makes you think the turbo has failed; is it just the ticking noise or doesn't it make boost? Is it the standard turbo or a hi-flow?

It's a rebuilt turbo, from Hypergear a few years ago. Standard bearing, not ball. I'm pretty sure it's gone because there's this kind of cruching kind of noise whenever it gets on boost, plus some intermittient random crunchiness at idle as well. Power seems lower too. The mechanic also said it abrubtly lost power when driving up a hill yesterday, like it had just siezed up.

Sounds like the banjo bolts in the sump weren't drilled out, and the turbo died from a lack of oil supply. If you can drop the turbo out again, checking the shaft play on the way out, I think you will find it needs a new set of bushes and a thrust washer replaced. (at least the bush cores are cheap to rebuild if there isn't too much damage.

I would be hitting Stao up for a rebuild price, but I suspect he will need to check the damage first.

Make sure your mechanic drills out all three banjo restrictors when it goes back in.

It's a rebuilt turbo, from Hypergear a few years ago. Standard bearing, not ball. I'm pretty sure it's gone because there's this kind of cruching kind of noise whenever it gets on boost, plus some intermittient random crunchiness at idle as well. Power seems lower too. The mechanic also said it abrubtly lost power when driving up a hill yesterday, like it had just siezed up.

This is in a Silver Stagea isn't it? I'm pretty sure it's the one I drove drown to Canberra to do a while back.

Definitely sound like the turbo is gone....and it was a Hypergear! I remember it very well because I had issues fitting it up.. :angry:

Sounds like the banjo bolts in the sump weren't drilled out, and the turbo died from a lack of oil supply. If you can drop the turbo out again, checking the shaft play on the way out, I think you will find it needs a new set of bushes and a thrust washer replaced. (at least the bush cores are cheap to rebuild if there isn't too much damage.

I would be hitting Stao up for a rebuild price, but I suspect he will need to check the damage first.

Make sure your mechanic drills out all three banjo restrictors when it goes back in.

My mechanic said it probably was a lack of oil supply that did it, but I think it was probably me to blame because he also mentioned there wasn't much oil left when he flushed it, like only a couple of litres. I know it's extremely bad ownership on my part for not keeping up with checking the dipstick regularly but at the very least I've never had the dash light on for low oil. :unsure:

This is in a Silver Stagea isn't it? I'm pretty sure it's the one I drove drown to Canberra to do a while back.

Definitely sound like the turbo is gone....and it was a Hypergear! I remember it very well because I had issues fitting it up.. :angry:

Yep it's silver and a Hypergear turbo but the guy I'm dealing with now is the same guy that fitted the turbo 3 years ago. He had a lot of trouble back then getting the old turbo off and swore he'd charge me an extra $30 an hour next time he worked on my car!

Has anyone come across any issues with the ticking/rattling noise before? I can't remember exactly what the mech suggested it could be but he gave me 3 options to do with the variable cam timing and chains and transfer???

$650 labour should be the going rate for removal and install if it still has all the heat shields....if no heat shields you can knock off $100....anything over that and your getting ripped.

The ticking/rattling noise...is it on idle or only under power?

Well this is a older high flow that has been done three years ago. Taking advise from M35Scotty, today's bearing housing and fittings are all made for direct bolton applications which is a lot easier to fit.

For diagnostics, remove the induction pipe for a visual inspection, if there are no circular markings on the compressor housing profile then have a feel for shaft play. If there are none in and out, with a sticky +/- <1mm side to side, then the turbocharger it self is probably ok. Other wise it requires overhaul which we can sort that out without much expanses.

$650 labour should be the going rate for removal and install if it still has all the heat shields....if no heat shields you can knock off $100....anything over that and your getting ripped.

The ticking/rattling noise...is it on idle or only under power?

It's on idle, becomes less apparent once the car is moving along at speed, very hard to hear if it's still there or not. The 2 people I've taken the car to have both thought it sounded like a chain noise of some sort. Coming from the front side of the engine.

Well this is a older high flow that has been done three years ago. Taking advise from M35Scotty, today's bearing housing and fittings are all made for direct bolton applications which is a lot easier to fit.

For diagnostics, remove the induction pipe for a visual inspection, if there are circular markings on the compressor housing profile then have a feel for shaft play. If there are none in and out, with a sticky +/- <1mm side to side, then the turbocharger it self is probably ok. Other wise it requires overhaul which we can sort that out without much expanses.

The car is still at the mechanic's yard so I'll let him know what to look at if I think it's all worth fixing up.

  • 2 months later...

...... 3 months later and my mechanic has managed to procrastinate about this job the whole time.

The ticking noise has gone away after flushing some oil through the engine and topping things up. The theory is it might have been a stuck lifter due to low oil levels.

So that just leaves me with the busted turbo.

I've organised for some mechanically minded friends to do the turbo swap in my backyard but when I rang the mechanic today he started on about how he's spoken to 3 workshops about the car, and all advise against replacing the turbo, saying that it's a gamble that the second turbo could blow up due to oil contamination/loose fragments left from the old turbo, and that the car was running with the lifter problem for so long etc so who knows what other damage has been done etc... He advised sourcing another motor and swapping the lot, or selling as is.

The question is, does this sound right? There has to be plenty of other people that are as hopeless as me with checking oil and servicing that have blown up turbos from oil starvation and I'm pretty sure they don't chuck the whole motor because of it.

Any advice? Ultimately looking to sell the car as I already have its replacement.

Thanks for your help guys!

Call John at Trojan Motorsports on (02) 62426277 (Canberra). BTW he owns and drives a Stag. The majority of vehicles he works on are Skylines.

He wont feed you any BS. Your current mechanic is - Get rid of him now

BTW did you find any metal or objects what so ever when you did the flush of the old oil ?

Just because the turbo may have shat itself it is most UNLIKELY and Extremely unlucky you will end up with fragments in your engine block.

R32 GTR's are the exception and even then it does not happen very often at all. Later models are better designed.

and yes lack of oil will increase the ticking noise so will the wrong grade of oil

Call John and have a word with him.

Edit. I recently blew my Turbo on my 34GTT Neo. Had it highflowed and put back in. No issues.

Edited by Sinista32

The theory is it might have been a stuck lifter due to low oil levels.

The question is, does this sound right?

No, it doesn't sound right, as the VQ doesn't have lifters.

Sounds like your mechanic used the wrong grade of oil. Where are you located Glenn?

I agree with everything Sinista said, go to the mechanic he recommended. I guess if you plan to sell the car after repairs then just take whatever route works out to be cheaper. More than likely just a turbo repair will be cheaper than finding and fitting another complete engine.

It really saddens me to see "mechanics" treating customers this way; either start doing some research, and learn to do the job for the customer, or be honest; and admit you are out of your depth.

Advising you to sell the car broken, and at a huge loss; is terrible advice, and shows you no respect as a customer.
Why would he not remove the sump and at least inspect for the alleged metal particles that have supposedly destroyed the engine?

At this point; yourself and some mechanically minded friends couldn't do any more harm, as long as you get some good advice & take your time with the repairs.

Have a chat with Scotty; he knows these inside out, and will steer you in the right direction.

As an aside; when my turbo completely failed; it made a noise that sounded for all the world like a noisy lifter. Replace the turbo; and see where you are.

Call John at Trojan Motorsports on (02) 62426277 (Canberra). BTW he owns and drives a Stag. The majority of vehicles he works on are Skylines.

He wont feed you any BS. Your current mechanic is - Get rid of him now

BTW did you find any metal or objects what so ever when you did the flush of the old oil ?

Just because the turbo may have shat itself it is most UNLIKELY and Extremely unlucky you will end up with fragments in your engine block.

R32 GTR's are the exception and even then it does not happen very often at all. Later models are better designed.

and yes lack of oil will increase the ticking noise so will the wrong grade of oil

Call John and have a word with him.

Edit. I recently blew my Turbo on my 34GTT Neo. Had it highflowed and put back in. No issues.

Thanks for the referral, I'll give him a call this week. He didn't mention any findings in the oil. It sounds like he's talked to a few people that have said what MAY happen in a worst case scenario. Surely if you replace the oil line, flush everything out again, remove whatever bits from the old turbo that are laying around the piping, and prime the new turbo properly, you shouldn't have any more risk than normal?

No, it doesn't sound right, as the VQ doesn't have lifters.

Sounds like your mechanic used the wrong grade of oil. Where are you located Glenn?

I'm in Canberra, probably a bit far for you to come and look!

It really saddens me to see "mechanics" treating customers this way; either start doing some research, and learn to do the job for the customer, or be honest; and admit you are out of your depth.

Advising you to sell the car broken, and at a huge loss; is terrible advice, and shows you no respect as a customer.

Why would he not remove the sump and at least inspect for the alleged metal particles that have supposedly destroyed the engine?

At this point; yourself and some mechanically minded friends couldn't do any more harm, as long as you get some good advice & take your time with the repairs.

Have a chat with Scotty; he knows these inside out, and will steer you in the right direction.

As an aside; when my turbo completely failed; it made a noise that sounded for all the world like a noisy lifter. Replace the turbo; and see where you are.

Thanks for that. I'll go see the guy today if get time and suggest to take the sump off and have a look. The diagnostics so far seem to be based off of talking to people rather than actually looking.

Thanks for that. I'll go see the guy today if get time and suggest to take the sump off and have a look. The diagnostics so far seem to be based off of talking to people rather than actually looking.

Don't waste your money with the guy. Just advise him you plan on picking it up. The guy obviously has no interest in working on the car.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • NoS, 2 of the big ones.
    • Oh, that's grim. Something bad has been happening there.
    • Put an endoscope down the hole and saw this. Not quite all around the bore but a good 60% at least. Chin to the chest and towards further disappointments I guess.
    • 2 does "sort of" applies, maybe......but looking at what parts would be needed for the swap to get engineered, registered, and insured, and basically that's everything under the car, the modifications the make it legal would be problematic and horrendously expensive, all for a street car that just cruises around and hits a few twisty roads on the weekends Also, from looking at the NSW rules and Regs, with all modifications that is required just to make the car safe and not twist itself to pieces, and then actually get registered for street use, may still be impossible nowadays As for 1, when you add in a fresh engine, fresh transmission, rear cradle and diff, tailshaft, suspension, brakes, cooling, and all the other fabrication required, your probably looking at up to $100k to do it right, all for a 20 year old MX5 that is over engineered and you would never be able to actually use the power it has on the street, much like your beastie, which I love, but you actually track that thing and can use all of its powers in anger, in a safe environment  Hell, the old Bogan Cruise Ship had more power than I could use on the street, and in hindsight, I went a bit silly on that thing, it didn't really need the 500hp it had for what I actually used the car for, it was fun, but basically unusable on the street if you value your licence  As for cams, yeah, I'll probably book it in for them to get installed and tuned soonish, like next month after MX5 Mania are back at work....... and yes, I've already sent a email to bin the turbo quote and quote instead to install cams and a new Fluidampr balancer that will suit the 2.5 better than the OEM 2.0 balancer that is swapped over for the 2.5 install, as the balancer needs to get pulled to time the cams it's a while your in there sort of thing I did think a bit about flex fuel for a laugh, but being na, and no where really around locally anymore to get E85, I've binned that idea, so no sweet sweet corn smells are set for the car I wish E85 was more of a standard fuel, it's better for the environment, better for tuning, plus that sweet sweet smell we all love As for fitting in the family, that's not needed, as everyone in the family already owns a car that can seat 5 humans comfortably enough, the MX5 is "my toy" As for buying a car that is already built, nah, I would rather pick and choose my parts, I enjoy the process, and in the big picture, the additional cost is well worth the enjoyment, and the occasional frustration, I get out of doing it, albeit with other people spinning the spanners, and me, just paying the invoice 🤣
    • Excuse me, but 2) does apply 1) Would also apply if you consider how much is spent in the alternatives. Also there's the option of 3), buy one pre-built that you can put your family in (it's me, it's my car)   That said, I went on a ~500km drive the other day. I didn't use anything more adventurous than 3rd/4th gear at about ~3000RPM and 50% throttle and I was going as fast as anyone has any sense doing on a public road, with enough grip to the point where I didn't want to go any faster. I was obviously under the limit of the current car etc etc. MX5 with 2.5 N/A to achieve the same speed would be more fun for any road scenario. Maybe consider cams. I wouldn't boost it. The use case is just not there and it won't actually make the car more enjoyable unless you really do plan on wringing gears from 1st to 3rd (at least) at 100% WOT on a public road to 150+kmh.
×
×
  • Create New...